[Student IDEAS] by Yinzhe HUANG - Master in Data Sciences & Business Analytics at ESSEC Business School and CentraleSupélec
Digitalization and AI-based applications are being integrated into firms’ human resource management (HRM) approaches for managing people in domestic and international organisations. Amongst the whole process of HRM, Talent Acquisition (TA) is the best-equipped one with Digitalization. There is no doubt that machines are good at some sort of work. However, we must know that the efficiency sometimes takes costs, such as privacy and bias.
In general, TA can be splitted into three main steps: planning, sourcing, and selection.
Meanwhile, the processes of TA are not separated. In practice, the processes work in a PDCA way, with continuous iteration and evolution as the business moving forward.
To visualise the comprehensive picture of how digitalization technologies affect TA and human-machine configurations at work and their influences on organisational level outcomes, we develop an overarching conceptual framework through this review:
In general, the PDCA circuit [3] is essential in the organical combination of Talent Acquisition & Artificial Intelligence. AI assists in HR planning by determining future employee needs and making effective recruitment decisions [4]. It is also evident that AI-enabled recruitment and selection play a crucial role in attracting and selecting the most talented work pool to the organisations, as these advanced technologies can access data and make decisions at a speedy pace and can handle large volumes of information in a time that far exceeds human capacity [5]. As a result, AI algorithms can improve job candidate identification, that is who is most interested and suited for the job and provide better communication of the job opening. Influencing job seekers’ technology increases their participation in AI enabled recruiting [6]. AI also assists in making the job interview process more effective, so that the interview process is now changed from face-to-face to internet-based interviews, such as asynchronous video interviews (AVIs) . Moreover, Pessach et al. [7] found in their studies that using a hybrid decision-support tool helped HR professionals in the recruitment and placement processes and increased the impact of recruiters and maximised organisational return on investment. AI Algorithms allowed HR professionals to identify suitable profiles for job vacancies, eliminating cognitive biases of race, gender and sexual orientation that mar human judgement in recruiting activities. The latest work of Baidu [8] even takes the salary management into account.
In the following paragraphs, we will take two examples from the Chinese context to show how system design and AI can empower talent acquisition.
Before talking about how AI upgrades automation in the talent acquisition process, we would like to briefly introduce the key elements of a user-friendly digital talent acquisition system. In this section, we would like to take Lark (an enterprise cooperation platform developed by ByteDance) as an example.
Founded in 2015, Baidu TIC aims to form a systematic data-driven solution for talent management based on the accumulated advantages in AI and Big Data of Baidu (HBR China, 2018). After 6-year cultivation in this area, the team developed many algorithms with real-world applications in Talent Acquisition.
In terms of technical accumulation, the team started from the analysis of trend of job market [9] by dynamically tracking the evolving recruitment topics with hierarchical dirichlet processes. And then, the team evaluate both the profile of employers [10] and the skills of employees [11]. With those key insights being clarified, they built a Person-Job Fit Neural Network [12] Design, Operation, Product, and Technique) and enhanced the model by designing an Ability-Aware Mechanism [13]. Apart from the resume filtering which gets HR into loads of repeat work, the team also focused on AI-driven Interview Assessment [14], which enables a variety of applications in job interviews, and AI-driven Salary Management [15], which assesses skill value from a market-oriented perspective.
Nonetheless, we shall always notice that even state-of-the-art techniques are the means to realize the end. It is more important to recognize the value creation than to simply show off IT skills. Therefore, the systematic design, which combines the value creation chain and the state-of-the-art techniques organically, is even more essential for business success.
With the technical backbone, Baidu is able to build a whole solution for AI-driven Talent Acquisition (CSDN) which can boost HRM extraordinarily. The solution concentrates on three main perspectives in HRM: talent, organization, and culture. In this article, which focus mainly on talent acquisition, we would like to emphasise more on the first part.
In the talent perspective, the solution covers almost the whole process of talent acquisition, including job analysis, sourcing, and selection.
Covering almost the whole process of Talent Acquisition, this solution has become a module of Baidu AI Services. In application, Baidu co-operated with Beisen to help CP Group to realize Digital Transformation in Talent Acqusition.
We evaluated above some digital evolutions in Talent Acquisition. However, it is important to realize that efficiency comes at some costs. In this part, we would like to evaluate some of the concerns of digitalization in talent acquisition.
Digitalization can improve the efficiency of talent acquisition in two main aspects: well-defined enterprise cooperation systems and machine decision. The former way improves the workflow by integrating the whole process, extracting process knowledge for stakeholders decisions under context, and seamless cooperation with other tools. The latter way protects the HRs from manually evaluating the candidates one by one.
However, several concerns arise under the digitalization. We have to make an ethical trade-off between efficiency and personal rights. The way to digitise the Talent Acquisition processes is to improve the efficiency in systematic design under the prerequisites of compliance to regulation and respect of privacy. Not only do we need the improvement of efficiency, but also should we cage the power so that it can remain under control.
[ESSEC KNOWLEDGE] by Wilfried Sand-Zantman - Professor of Economics at ESSEC Business School.
The text discusses the economic significance of data in the digital ecosystem, where firms harvest, process, and sell information. It highlights the issue of data ownership and control by consumers, with legal responses in Europe and the US. The article explores the impact of allocating data ownership to consumers or firms in a two-sided market framework. It suggests a trade-off between data overexploitation by firms and data under-processing when consumers have control rights. The optimal choice depends on the market value of data; when it's low, consumer ownership is better, and when it's high, firm ownership is more beneficial. However, determining the value of personal data is complex, and questions of multiple ownership add further complexity to creating a data market.
[To read the full article please follow this link.]
[ESSEC Knowledge] by Vivianna Fang He - Associate Professor at ESSEC Business School
The text discusses the dynamics of university-industry collaborations, such as the one between Oxford University and AstraZeneca in COVID-19 vaccine development. It highlights that asymmetry in goals and perceptions between academic and industry partners can exist. Research involving multiple collaborations revealed that such asymmetry is common but doesn't necessarily hinder success. Conflict can impact collaboration but varies between cognitive (task-related) and affective (personal) conflict. Managing conflict and perception asymmetry is crucial for effective academia-industry collaborations, with recommendations for monitoring, training, and addressing different types of conflict. Acknowledging and managing these differences can lead to successful partnerships, even when goals are misaligned.
[To read the full article please follow this link.]
[ESSEC KNOWLEDGE] by Fabrice Cavarretta - Associate Professor in Leadership and Entrepreneurship at ESSEC Business School.
The text explores the evolution of artificial intelligence (AI) in management and delves into the challenges and prospects of AI. It raises questions about whether AI can emulate human intelligence, particularly in areas like intuition and emotions. The text points out the current practical limitations of AI, including the inability to replicate human cognitive processes. It describes how AI has progressed in waves of innovation and how the future of AI is uncertain, with both overly optimistic and pessimistic projections. The author emphasizes that true AI may require multiple waves of progress and the combination of symbolic and machine learning techniques. The text also suggests that AI will only reach human-level intelligence when it exhibits a form of free will and motivated cognition.
[To read the full article please follow this link.]
[ARTICLE]
By Prasanna Tambe, Peter Cappelli & Valery Yakubovich - Professors at ESSEC Business School & Wharton Business School.
The authors consider the gap between the promise and reality of artificial intelligence in human resource management and suggest how progress might be made. They identify four challenges in using data science techniques for HR tasks:
1) complexity of HR phenomena,
2) constraints imposed by small data sets,
3) accountability questions associated with fairness and other ethical and legal constraints, and
4) possible adverse employee reactions to management decisions via data-based algorithms.
They propose practical responses to these challenges and converge on three overlapping principles - causal reasoning, randomization and experiments, and employee contribution—that could be both economically efficient and socially appropriate for using data science in the management of employees.
[Please find the research paper here]
[ESSEC Knowledge] by Jeroen Rombouts - Professor at ESSEC Business School where he holds the Accenture Strategic Business Analytics chair.
AI is transforming the way we experience the world, offering personalized, efficient, and always-available interactions. Examples from businesses like Carnival and healthcare institutions like Albert Einstein Hospital demonstrate AI's ability to anticipate and cater to individual needs, improving efficiency and care.
AI is reshaping the end-to-end processes of organizations, enhancing prediction, automation, and customer service. The top-performing companies adopting AI early and developing expertise outperform their competitors, yielding three times the return on investments.
Consumers now expect always-on, personalized experiences, and AI is helping businesses meet these demands. Organizations use AI to analyze data from millions of interactions, enabling them to offer relevant experiences in real-time. Examples include Avianca Airlines, Spotify, McDonald's, KFC, Shiseido, and L'Oréal.
AI is also revolutionizing public services, from defense planning to healthcare prediction and autonomous mobility solutions. The impact of AI is happening today and affects every sector of life, bringing both excitement and challenges.
To read the full article please follow this link.
[ESSEC Knowledge] by Claudia Archetti - Professor in Operations Research. She is member of the Operations Management & Operations Research (OMOR) Research Cluster.
The explosion of information technology services is deeply shaping the economy and the business world by generating new industries and fields of production and service that were not even conceivable thirty years ago. In particular, e-commerce has revolutionized customer behavior and needs and, consequently, the way companies do business.
Figure 1. The explosion of e-commerce.
Focusing on the logistics implications of e-commerce, the rapid increase of the speed of delivery has generated enormous challenges in the organization of the distribution of on-line orders. In particular, last-mile delivery is the most challenging part of the distribution process, counting as the highest cost component (https://www.mckinsey.com/, Travel, Transport and Logistics, September 2016 [3]). Last-mile delivery corresponds to the last leg in the distribution process, whereby the consignment is delivered from the last distribution point, either a warehouse or a distribution center, to the recipient, either at the recipient's home or at a collection point. The main activities performed in last-mile deliveries are related to warehouse management and the transportation of goods to the recipient. In detail, warehouse management includes picking operations as well as inventory management, performed in a setting previously defined by strategic and tactical decisions (e.g., warehouse design, product allocation). Organizing the transportation, instead, implies defining the daily operations related to the distribution. A great example of the challenges related to managing distribution activities for on-line shoppers is provided by Amazon fulfillment centers.
[To read the full article please follow this link.]
[ESSEC Knowledge] by Jeroen Rombouts - Professor at ESSEC Business School where he holds the Accenture Strategic Business Analytics chair.
Many organizations are investing in data and analytics to become more data-driven and incorporate AI, transitioning from descriptive analytics to predictive and prescriptive analytics. However, the challenge lies in changing the culture towards agility and experimentation, necessitating reskilling and training programs.
Historically, the software development industry transitioned from a linear waterfall approach to the more adaptable agile methodology, and further to DevOps, which bridged the gap between development and operations. Today, the question arises: what can DevOps offer in the era of AI?
AI and machine learning present unique challenges due to their data-centric nature, and MLOps (Machine Learning Operationalization) is introduced as a set of practices that combine DevOps, machine learning, and data engineering to deploy and maintain ML systems in production. MLOps standardizes processes, fosters experimentation, ensures rapid delivery, and addresses performance monitoring, concept drift, accountability, and compliance issues.
Despite data science training programs, MLOps principles are often not adequately covered, and business leaders may struggle to create an efficient development and operations environment for their data teams. The complexity of ML algorithms and the perception of them as black boxes create a gap between AI and business.
MLOps should involve all stakeholders in data-based solutions, and it is essential for future data leaders to acquire basic MLOps skills to break down the barriers between business and engineering teams in the realm of AI and data.
[To read the full article please follow this link.]
by Elisa Operti - Professor of Strategy and Network Analysis courses in various programs (MS, Executive, PhD) at ESSEC Business School.
The study by Elisa Operti and Amit Kumar focuses on the impact of collaborative efforts on innovation and entrepreneurship within regional contexts. In this case, they examined the Hauts-de-France region's efforts to promote collaboration among local entrepreneurs, private firms, and universities and analyzed the paradoxical outcomes observed.
The research introduced a typology of regional collaboration networks based on two key factors: internal brokerage and the number of collaboration ties outside the region. This led to the identification of four archetypes: "fortress," "playing field," "absorber," and "multilevel brokerage."
The study collected data on collaboration networks between inventors within and between U.S. municipal areas and explored how these structures affected regional innovation output. Surprisingly, the findings indicated that while both internal and external collaboration ties are beneficial, it is challenging for innovators in a region to handle both types simultaneously. As a result, "playing field" or "absorber" configurations often proved more conducive to innovation than "fortress" or "multilevel brokerage."
The counterintuitive results could be attributed to cognitive and information overload associated with multilevel brokerage. Managing diverse local and distant collaborators can strain the innovators' resources and attention. Additionally, innovators who build local bridges while engaging in external initiatives may face conflicting demands and organizational cultures, which can affect their motivation and implementation capacity.
The study has several policy implications:
For innovators and entrepreneurs, the research provides valuable insights:
[To read the full article please follow this link.]
by Ho Hoang - Professor of Corporate Strategy in Masters and Executive-level programs, focusing on competitive and cooperative dynamics of incumbent and entrepreneurial firms at ESSEC Business School.
Employee entrepreneurship refers to the creation of new ventures within an existing organization, often aimed at introducing innovative ideas and benefiting the organization. In a study involving physicians in the UK National Health Service (NHS), the transition from being an employee to an entrepreneur within the same organization was explored.
These employee entrepreneurs had various motivations, with some intending to innovate and improve the NHS, while others had a deep attachment to the organization and aimed to enhance its functioning. However, they faced challenges, such as a mismatch between their job responsibilities and innovation goals, leading them to seek resources and support outside the organization. These individuals often maintained their NHS affiliation, seeing the organization as a source of inspiration, knowledge, and opportunities for their ventures.
The desire to remain connected with the parent organization influenced the design of their entrepreneurial projects, which often had interdependence with the NHS, serving as customers, advisors, supporters, or referral sources. This research highlights the importance of identity in driving hybrid entrepreneurship, where individuals simultaneously pursue new ventures while retaining their existing employment. Employers can capitalize on this by developing policies and support systems to encourage and promote interdependent ventures, contributing to more innovative organizations. Employee entrepreneurship offers a valuable pathway for employees to align their career and entrepreneurial goals while maintaining their organizational membership.
[To read the full article please follow this link.]