DATA AND AI ARE CHANGING THE WAY ORGANIZATIONS THINK, DECIDE, AND ORGANIZE. IT’S TIME HUMANITIES, MANAGEMENT AND SOCIAL SCIENCES GET INVOLVED.
Metalab

NEWS

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.

EVENTS

[Student IDEAS] by Céline Viévard - Global BBA at ESSEC Business School

Is greed really good? Milton Friedman’s statement (1970) that profit maximization is the sole responsibility of companies has recently been up for debate. With the repeating tech titans’ data privacy scandals, a stark reality lays bare: people can come second to profit. In parallel to these giants' rise in influence, consumers are increasingly concerned regarding the societal impact of companies (Lewis, 2021) - they are now more than ever put under the microscope. Amidst the constant pursuit of “what’s next?”, a crucial question now arises: what is the purpose of driving this innovation?

Considering the fast nature of such an industry, are short-termism initiatives for profit maximization the most appropriate for survival? Is incorporating purpose going beyond their core mandate? Are profit maximization and purpose mutually exclusive? How could purpose be adopted in such a turbulent environment? 

The why of tech

But what even is purpose? Corporate purpose, once synonymous with Friedman’s shareholder primacy, now encompasses all stakeholders and involves broader societal considerations (Business Roundtable, 2019). This new definition aligns with the concept of the Triple Bottom Line (TBL), which emphasizes that a company's purpose should consider not just its financial performance (Profit), but also its social impact (People) and environmental impact (Planet). Delivered in the form of environmental, social and governance (ESG) initiatives, purpose is a company’s commitment to:

  • Provide value to customers
  • Invest in employees;
  • Deal fairly and ethically with suppliers;
  • Support communities;
  • Generate long-term shareholder value.

Considering the range of stakeholders tech companies hold, with 91% of organizations undergoing digital transformation (Gartner, 2020) and over 5.35 million people globally using the Internet (DataReportal, 2024), purpose is a crucial force. On one hand, while 65% of employees feel their leaders overlook the societal impact of digital initiatives (Bannister et al., 2020), defining the ethical use and purpose of technology reduces risks like data privacy breaches, algorithmic biases, cybersecurity threats and others. On the other hand, as 68% of consumers believe companies need to drive positive social and environmental impact (Lewis, 2021), tech companies can leverage their resources to create value exceeding that of a product or service by contributing to causes for the communities they serve. 

While most tech companies have adopted a purpose, many fail in their design or application (Kennedy et al., 2022b). This incongruence, known as the purpose gap, reflects a lack of alignment between the stated purpose and the company’s strengths, stakeholders and activities. Bridging this gap, aligning business with broader societal concerns while preserving company identity, is a complex dance. Yet, an achievable one when the following moves were respected.

First, define purpose with all stakeholders

At the heart of the purpose gap lies a lack of communication. For purpose to truly echo within and outside an organization, all stakeholders need to identify with it. What better way to find a purpose that all stakeholders are aligned with than directly discussing it with them? 

Regarding top teams, many admit purpose is a subject they want to address but fear is not considered a top priority (Gast et al, 2020). The consequence? The Abilene Paradox, where silence is misinterpreted as agreement. The solution? Starting the dialogue. A way to ease into such a discussion is through an ‘ESG teardown’ - a strategic assessment of a company's existing ESG initiatives. This surfaces which key issues are being addressed and why - were they related to the key strength of the company? Or was it mimicking a competitor? You may also notice if there is an imbalance in the rigor of certain letters of ESG. Think of questioning whether ESG is reflected within operations - and if not, why? Completing this by evaluating your performance to your competitors will lay out a first draft of initiatives to introduce, keep, improve and remove.

Next are stakeholders - those who experience or perceive the company’s purpose. Their voices are crucial during its design and implementation. Employees, for example, face the dilemma between purpose and profit on a daily basis. For alignment, surveys like the Inclusion Index by Microsoft (McIntyre, 2023) alongside questioning what they value and where they find value in work is recommended. Assigning “purpose ambassadors" to champion employees’ desired purpose is also favorable. They could gather employee stories where your company truly lived its purpose, a powerful tool for later the integration phase. Such surveys can also be sent to consumers or investors to define what they seek in the company’s purpose and what they believe are its strengths and weaknesses.

With this range of potential purpose initiatives at hand comes the time to prioritize. The most suitable must match the company’s strengths: what unique value do you provide? How does it relate to purpose? How can it create value? They also need to generate stakeholder impact: what is the tangible impact? Metrics such as how much wage increases boost purchasing power or how much solar panels reduce greenhouse gases are examples. The long-term shareholder value must also be considered: what were the financial gains? Ideally, this should be in monetary terms like increased revenue or cost reduction. Some of these will not have monetized value, in that case, asking stakeholders to rank the initiatives or looking at what other organizations do may help guide your choice. Once selected, commit with a timeline and objectives for credibility but also to measure your success in the future.  

Then, integrate purpose

For purpose to be more than a marketing campaign, it needs to initiate change within the organization. 

There will be opportunities to go against your purpose, sometimes unknowingly. It’s important to keep in mind that nonmanagers are actually more likely than leaders to face this tension (Gast et al., 2020). Projecting possible scenarios of friction will help set a framework to guide them when the time comes. This can be done by making them test the purpose on their activities and communicate how it influences decisions and if there are any tensions. Through this feedback, you can refine your purpose statement and set a toolkit on how employees can demonstrate purpose daily.

It is important to set an ethical policy and culture reflecting your purpose. To do so, introducing and involving new key players like a chief ethical and humane officer as done by Salesforce (n.d.) or an AI and Ethics Research Committee like Microsoft (2018) has proven to be efficient. Such positions can assist in building a framework, ensuring its flexibility and monitoring or addressing any issues. Including non-financial stakeholders on the board can also help represent purpose during decision-making and embed such a culture. 

With all of this set, it’s important to share with all stakeholders how purpose is now a part of your organization. For impact, this needs to be more than just communicating plans, you need story-telling to inspire (London Business Forum, 2016). Sharing the stories collected by the purpose ambassadors on value creation through work or the feedback on how purpose has guided decision-making are examples. Sharing will not only assist in its adoption but also push employees and decision-makers to take accountability and acknowledge the impact they have.

Finally, measure your impact 

Although it will take years to truly impact society, it is essential to communicate goals, progress and setbacks. Not only does this push for accountability but will also highlight the quality of your impact and its returns, motivating all stakeholders.

There exists a wide range of reporting standards with varying levels of rigor for reference such as:

  • The StakeHolder Capitalism Metrics by The World Economic Forum (2021) 
  • The EU Non-financial Reporting Directive (European Commission, 2014) and Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (European Commission, 2023)
  • The United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (n.d.)
  • The Global Reporting Initiative framework (n.d.)

It is essential for the reporting to be adapted to your purpose and your initiatives. It may even be relevant to introduce new metrics to best measure your impact. Ask yourself: What data is crucial in understanding the performance of your impact? Have your current metrics given insight on how to improve your purpose? Is anything not being measured on your societal impact? Including metrics of the five dimensions of stakeholder impact may guide and ensure the completeness of your measures.

  • Financial impact, improving your stakeholders' long-term financial well-being.
  • Environmental impact, how your activities affect environmental health. 
  • Health, improving the organizations’ and stakeholders’ health. 
  • Capability-building, improving stakeholders’ abilities and skills.
  • Satisfaction impact, improving your stakeholders’ experience with your company or its products and services.

By tracking these comprehensive impact metrics, companies gain valuable insights. These metrics not only guide decisions about which initiatives to maintain, improve, or discontinue but they can also be used to incentivize employees by linking their compensation to long-term value creation. This aligns with current trends, as research shows that linking compensation with purpose enhances stakeholder outcomes (Sutherland & Falk, 2021). Such a data-driven approach to purpose can ensure company efforts translate into real-world improvements for all stakeholders.

And repeat

The tech landscape is constantly evolving and the frameworks chosen today may be obsolete tomorrow. This is why the processes chosen need to be highly flexible to adapt to any potential changes. Through your measures you may also see there are still some inconsistencies and points of improvements on your purpose statement. Purpose is not just a subject you address once and never go back, it’s a daily matter. 

The Purpose Imperative: Beyond Profitability

Purpose is becoming not only a fruitful asset across all industries but its adoption requires resources, analysis and patience. Without respecting the careful steps for its implementation, there are high risks of falling in the purpose gap. Through a careful design process integrating all stakeholders, embedded within all operations and regular measurement and refining, purpose can shine within and without the organization's walls and set an example for other players across industries. As stakeholders progressively become focused on impact, with the rise of ethical consumerism and growing investor expectations regarding ESG principles, purpose could become the ultimate competitive edge, even trumping innovation.

Key takeaways

  • Purpose is gaining an increasing amount of importance to all business stakeholders across all industries. 
  • For purpose to be fruitful, it needs to be aligned with the company’s strengths, activities and stakeholders. This lack of alignment, the purpose gap, is the reason behind the failure of most purpose statements today. 
  • The definition process of purpose within a company needs to include and be based on all stakeholders. 
  • Purpose should translate into real-world changes through policies, additional expertise and communication.
  • For accountability and improvement, purpose needs goals and monitoring through a set of chosen metrics.

References

[1] Friedman M. 1970. The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. New York Times Magazine, September 13.

[2] Lewis, S. (2021, July 7). How to realize the full potential of ESG+. https://www.ey.com/en_fi/sustainability/realize-potential-esg-plus

[3] Business Roundtable. (2019). Business Roundtable Redefines the Purpose of a Corporation to Promote ‘An Economy That Serves All Americans’. https://www.businessroundtable.org/business-roundtable-redefines-the-purpose-of-a-corporation-to-promote-an-economy-that-serves-all-americans

[4] Bannister, C. et al. (2020). Ethical tech. Making ethics a priority in today’s digital organization. Deloitte Insights. https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/topics/digital-transformation/make-ethical-technology-a-priority.html 

[5] Gartner (2020). Digitalisation Strategy for Business Transformation. https://www.gartner.co.uk/en/information-technology/insights/digitalization

[6] DataReportal, Meltwater, We Are Social. (2024). Number of internet and social media users worldwide as of January 2024 (in billions). Statista. Statista Inc.. Accessed: March 30, 2024. https://www-statista-com.essec.idm.oclc.org/statistics/617136/digital-population-worldwide/

[7] Kennedy, D. et al. (2022) Solving the tech industry’s purpose problem. https://www.bcg.com/publications/2019/solving-tech-industry-purpose-problem.

[8] Gast, A., Probst, N., & Simpson, B. (2020, December 3). Purpose, not platitudes: A personal challenge for top executives. McKinsey & Company. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/people-and-organizational-performance/our-insights/purpose-not-platitudes-a-personal-challenge-for-top-executives

[9] McIntyre, L. (2023, November 2). Microsoft’s 2023 Diversity and Inclusion Report: A decade of transparency, commitment and progress - The Official Microsoft Blog. The Official Microsoft Blog. https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2023/11/01/microsofts-2023-diversity-and-inclusion-report-a-decade-of-transparency-commitment-and-progress/

[10] Salesforce (n.d). Ethical and humane use. https://www.salesforce.com/company/intentional-innovation/

[11] Microsoft News Center. (2018, March 29). Satya Nadella email to employees: Embracing our future: Intelligent Cloud and Intelligent Edge - Stories. Stories. https://news.microsoft.com/2018/03/29/satya-nadella-email-to-employees-embracing-our-future-intelligent-cloud-and-intelligent-edge/

[12] London Business Forum. (2016, March 11). David Pearl - Storytelling [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4C0bbDAql_A

[13] World Economic Forum. Explore the metrics. (2021, September 20). https://www.weforum.org/stakeholdercapitalism/our-metrics/

[14] European Commission (2014). EU non-financial reporting directive (NFRD): Directive 2014/95/EU, European Commission, October 22, 2014, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2014/95/oj. 

[15] European Commission (2023). Corporate sustainability reporting. Finance. https://finance.ec.europa.eu/capital-markets-union-and-financial-markets/company-reporting-and-auditing/company-reporting/corporate-sustainability-reporting_en

[16] United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs. (n.d.). THE 17 GOALS | Sustainable Development. (n.d.). https://sdgs.un.org/goals 

[17] Global Reporting Initiave. (n.d.) GRI - Standards. https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/

[18] Sutherland, S., & Falk, B. (2021, March 26). How a purpose-led strategy can help boards prioritize stakeholders. EY Finland. https://www.ey.com/en_fi/board-matters/how-a-purpose-led-strategy-can-help-boards-prioritize-stakeholders

[Student IDEAS] by Michelle Diaz - Master in Management at ESSEC Business School

Very few things are as malleable and rule-stricken as language, composition, and rhetoric. In 2022 alone, Merriam-Webster added 370 new words to the English dictionary. But certain grammatical rules have been in place for centuries. Perhaps it is this contradictory, confounding, and ever-evolving nature of language that allows trained writers to still overwrite artificial intelligence (AI). However, a recent paper suggests that even writing-intensive professions are exposed to AI, with 80-100% of the US workforce affected (Eloundou et al., 2023).

But what does this mean for academia? Should academic institutions hurry to shift assessment standards, create safeguards, and implement fraud-detection measures? Most say yes; others insist it is a threat to education like no other, while some tout it as a wondrous opportunity. AI is all of this and more: a chance for a wider array of students to understand, appreciate, and learn the art of composition—to consider the skill as something they would like to possess. Rather than outsource to AI-powered chatbots, simply because they can.

Reaction to ChatGPT – a lot of old rhetoric?

The reaction to the release of ChatGPT, an AI-powered chatbot developed by Open AI has been wide-reaching. The reception can be found in almost every sector, from business to healthcare, law, and entertainment to name a few. But in no sector is the reception more mixed and controversial than that of academia, the common denominator of almost every sector. Every prospective CEO, health professional, lawyer, screenwriter, and professor must, in one way or another, prepare for their career through some level of education.

The bombardment of headlines ranged from the optimistic, “AI Could Be Great for College Essays” (Lametti, 2022), to a nuanced analysis, “The Brilliance and Weirdness of ChatGPT” (Roose, 2022), and the proactive response, “How to Use ChatGPT and Still Be a Good Person” (Chen, 2022). The timeline of these headlines was early in the launch of ChatGPT. But the headlines since the release of ChatGPT-3.5 and GPT-4 have in large part reflected the same flurry of mixed emotions, with “The Chatbots Are Here, and the Internet Industry Is in a Tizzy” (Mickle et al., 2023) and “‘Let 1,000 Flowers Bloom’: A.I. Funding Frenzy Escalates” (Griffith et al., 2023), and the op-ed of the esteemed father of modern linguistics, “Noam Chomsky: The False Promise of ChatGPT” (Chomsky et al., 2023).

Irrespective of the views on ChatGPT, one thing is clear: a paradigm shift is needed. The repercussions of ChatGPT’s very existence mean the technology will only get better given the historical rate of technological innovation and competition within the market. On March 21, 2023, Google launched its Bard chatbot, the tech giant’s bid to rival Open AI’s ChatGPT. While Baidu, the Chinese search giant, released their own chatbot, Ernie, earlier in March 2023, (Murgia, 2023). In essence, a proactive approach is required to handle the effect on academic integrity.

Defining Academic Integrity

What exactly is academic integrity? And how do chatbots like ChatGPT, Bard, and Ernie threaten it? Moreover, how might we leverage these chatbots to improve education instead of sending teachers, schools, professors, and universities into a frenzy of concern over academic fraud? According to Donald McCabe, the founding father of research into ethical policy in academia, “the term involves the avoidance of plagiarism, cheating, and other behaviours of misconduct” (McCabe et al., 2016).  The speed at which detective measures have sprouted is commensurate with the capacity of the technology. Indeed, the benchmarks done by Open AI for GPT-4 reveal that the model can perform exceedingly well in a simulation of exams originally designed for humans:

(Open AI, 2023)

Hence, it comes as no surprise that, not three months since ChatGPT’s release, Edward Tian, an undergraduate student at Princeton University, created GPTZero, a bot to detect a text written by ChatGPT (Bowman, 2023). Similarly, Eric Mitchell, a graduate student at Stanford University, is working on DetectGPT, yet another means to distinguish between human and large language model (LLM)-generated text (Mitchell et al., 2023).

In effect, many of the metrics that society at large measures academic performance can be gamed by AI. Like essay assessments that require no oversight at the time of writing. But there has always been a case to mitigate academic misconduct, even before AI: “In the past, students could hire a ghost writer through widely available and easily accessible essay mills to write an assignment. Now with ChatGPT, they can instruct artificial intelligence (AI) instead of a person, at no cost…” (Harte et al, 2023). The qualifying difference is the ease with which students may now cheat.

AI: The Skill of Writing & the Real Conundrum

Interestingly, the one area in which GPT-4 has performed less admirably is the skill of writing. It showed no significant improvement from the last two versions for AP English Language, Literature, and the writing portion of the GRE (Open AI, 2023). Consequently, one must distinguish between subjects wherein equal weight is put on a text’s content and the quality of the writing itself. One can argue that assessment standards should be modified to require the high clarity, concision, and eloquence that is often demanded of students studying subjects like creative writing, literature, or philosophy. Or else, the mode of assessment be modified, or a reliable means of detecting AI-written text made widely available.

In early 2023, The New York Times published an article wherein more than 30 professors, students, and university administrators were interviewed on how to adopt to ChatGPT. Together, they outlined three ways to address the issue: require a higher standard of writing, modify assessment, and create a detector for AI-written text. One professor claimed that the “imagination, creativity, and innovation of analysis that we usually deem an A paper needs to be trickling down into the B-range papers.” Another professor now requires students to write their first drafts in the classroom. Lastly, the article underlines how more than 6,000 professors from Harvard University, among other tertiary institutions, have signed up for Edward Tian’s GPTZero (Huang, 2023).  

In any case, one thing is clear: the real conundrum is the ease with which students will willingly use ChatGPT for their academic assessments. Indeed, therein lies the potential of AI to either be beneficial or detrimental. If a student can save time, effort, and learn better with ChatGPT, then academia is better served by ensuring that students are more inclined to use it without forgoing academic integrity; to act based on an intrinsic preservation of integrity, rather than the avoidance of negative extrinsic repercussions of misconduct. And certainly, the uses of AI to improve academic practice are abundant, from providing a personalized learning experience to helping students brainstorm ideas to curating relevant resources (Hamdan, 2023).

Opportunity Amidst Chaos

Considering the dilemmas ChatGPT raises about academic integrity, it is prime time to refocus on a core issue that predates AI: the perception on the necessity of learning to write well. In 2002, Petelin coined the terms, “working writers and writing worker to distinguish between professionally trained writers (career writers) and those who are not necessarily trained as professional writers but whose jobs require them to write.” The former refers to journalists, playwrights, poets, etc. While the latter refers to lawyers, managers, engineers, architects, etc. (Petelin, 2022). The perception is that certain occupations require less training in writing, and indeed, not every individual must aim to write to the degree that career writers do. After all, a medical student is better prepared by spending more time on the sciences.

However, instilling students with the desire to learn writing beyond the requisite level to pass their courses is an investment that is unquestionably worthwhile. As Oscar Wilde once said, “If you cannot write well, you cannot think well; if you cannot think well, others will do your thinking for you.” Likewise, Joan Didion, a celebrated American writer mirrored this sentiment: “Had I been blessed with even limited access to my own mind, there would have been no reason to write.” While Stephen King notes that “writing is refined thinking” (King, 2000). These writers, whether they knew it at the time or not, were talking about the writing-thinking-learning connection, a relationship that language scholars have long since studied. Essentially, writing about something allows one to understand and learn it better, thus exploiting the connection between the three acts (Petelin, 2022).

Moreover, research shows a high correlation between writing and speaking. A study done in 2022 revealed that “student achievement in learning writing skills can predict achievement in learning speaking skills, and vice versa. If a student has good writing skills, it is almost certain that he will have good speaking skills as well” (Rahman et al, 2022). And speaking well is indubitably beneficial across different careers. Furthermore, a meta-analysis on the effects of writing on learning in science, social studies, and mathematics concluded that teachers in these subjects “can reasonably expect that asking their students to write about content material will enhance learning” (Graham et al, 2020). Not to mention the capacity of writing to be therapeutic and beneficial for mental health (Bergqvist et al, 2020). Value is found in the act of writing itself, exclusive of the output produced; value that is forgone by heavily relying on AI.

A Comprehensive Approach

To effectively capitalize on AI while preserving academic integrity, intervention can be divided into two categories: changing academic practices and student attitudes toward the importance of writing well. For the former, we have the tactics outlined by professors, like modifying assessments and creating GPTZero. While the latter category requires a stronger push. But combined, the two interventions provide intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and are thus a better way forward for students and academic institutions alike.

But what does changing student attitudes toward writing well look like? As it stands, the way that we teach students to write differs too much across disciplines, and some students inherently find the act of writing cumbersome. Instead of an enjoyable, empowering, and powerful skill for any career – “Its importance in organisations often goes unnoticed until there’s a document-related crisis” (Petelin, 2022). Furthermore, in most “Australian and British universities, writing is under-taught, under-valued, and under-researched” (Petelin, 2022). In contrast to American universities, where there is a long and strong tradition of rhetoric at the undergraduate level (Petelin, 2022).

Exposure to Inspire – Room for Improvement

Good rhetoric and composition speak for themselves. Often, the challenge is exposure to quality writing that inspires; to strings of words that entice not only with their content but with an eloquence that arrests. Sentences that speak not only about desire, but is desire embodied—obsessively, incessantly, and with a maddening hunger whose tendrils worm their way into a reader’s mind. No. The kind of writing found in required texts for subjects outside of the arts and humanities is far too often dry. Texts that read more like an instruction manual than anything else. How often do people read the instruction manual? Only when the table, despite all the tinkering, cannot be trusted to hold itself together. Now, perhaps the last couple of sentences sparked in you a defiance, a sort of stubbornness that proclaims: I always read the instruction manual! Or, most plausibly: not all writing needs to be creative writing! Indeed. I concur.

But all writing can benefit from amelioration. At the time of Dr. King’s illustrious I Have a Dream speech, he was scarcely the only man who dreamt of the “unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness for all men” (King, 1963). But he was one of the most eloquent. And while eloquence by itself does not a great leader make, it is a common denominator. From Dr. King to former president Barack Obama and to Professor Richard Feynman, notable not only for his contribution to physics but also for his ability to teach well.

Ergo, a solution might be to initiate introductory classes on literature and composition for academic departments like the hard sciences, healthcare, and business; make the skill more accessible. In this way, students learn early the supremacy of good writing, heightening the likelihood that they willingly invest time in the craft. Despite the presence of technologies that can write for them. Or else, more universities could adopt the practice of many American universities, where students must take classes on rhetoric and composition. Regardless of their chosen major (Petelin, 2022). If done correctly, swiftly, and universally, AI may very well bring about a resurgence in the art of rhetoric and composition—to the benefit of society at large.

Institute for AI & Business IDEAS newsletter #9 has just been released!

If you would like to read interesting articles on artificial trees capable of generating green electricity, or a revolutionary AI model for weather forecasting, check out the content below!

Institute for AI & Business IDEAS newsletter #8 has just been released!

If you would like to read interesting articles on the impact of Web3 technologies on sport, or on alliances in GenAI, check out the content below!

HOW MIGHT AI PLAYERS DRIVE SUSTAINABLE INITIATIVES?

[Student IDEAS] by Qinglan Huang & Yiyang Zhao - Master in Management at ESSEC Business School

Abstract

The article discusses the relationship between AI and environmental sustainability, emphasizing the need for "Green AI" to reduce AI's carbon and resource footprint. It covers strategies to improve energy efficiency in data centers, shifting to cloud and edge computing, optimizing algorithms, and ensuring the circularity of AI hardware components. It highlights the importance of regulations, transparency, and incentives to promote sustainable AI practices and the role of the EU in governing the green AI sector. The ultimate goal is to make environmentally friendly AI the industry standard.

---

When you think about “Artificial Intelligence” and “Green”, what connection could you make between these two fields? You may probably consider Artificial Intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) as a powerful tool to combat climate change. Indeed, AI has been used by governments, industries, and companies for collecting and computing data to prepare for change. However, with such unprecedented impact, it is imperative to examine the negative effect that massive AI adoption might have on the environment and climate in particular. While the potential of AI is frequently highlighted as a gamechanger for the transition in areas such as agriculture, building and mobility, the energy and resource consumption associated with AI computing is skyrocketing, along with a surge in estimated carbon emissions. What can it take to reduce this impact? And how might Multinational Companies (MNC), Small and Medium Enterprises (SME), and other AI players are working upon this green AI issue?

What is green AI and how is it governed?

Green AI is an emerging field to tackle environmental sustainability for the use of Artificial Intelligence. Its primary objective is to develop tools and techniques to mitigate the carbon and resource usage of AI adoption. The document “A role of Artificial Intelligence in the European Green Deal”, led by the European Parliament, illustrated the urgent needs for regulation and governance to manage the dynamics related to AI in implementing environmental objectives. Various sectors are actively working towards creating suitable regulatory instruments for assessing and integrating the evaluation of AI's environmental impacts within the current European regulatory framework.

A role of Artificial Intelligence in the European Green Deal. Source: European Parliament

In addition to the incoming assessments and regulations around AI sustainability, numerous programmes and initiatives have also been implemented to incentivise sustainable business applications and create more market opportunities. Incentives like loans aligned with the future EU taxonomy or targeted ‘green’ adjustments to public procurement law have accelerated the empowerment of specific actors and the implementation of sustainable AI.

AI emissions are core to the tech sector, entailing stronger strategies

There is no secret that the use of AI requires vast amounts of energy, along with their life cycle emissions rather than just training data. For companies dependent on AI technology, the carbon emissions resulting from AI operations have become a significant and growing concern.

Training a machine learning system, for example, needs to simulate millions of scenarios and perform statistical analyses on them. These processes can go on for weeks and even months, consuming a lot of computing power. The MIT Technology Review reported that training one large AI model can emit more than 626,000 pounds of carbon dioxide equivalent - nearly five times the lifetime emissions of the average American car.

Chart: MIT Technology Review. Source: Strubell et al

However, to accurately measure the footprint of AI is difficult. One has to determine first its power usage, which mostly funnels into the data centers that provide computational power to process, analyze and store vast amounts of datasets. In addition to the power for data center’s own use, cooling systems, such as air conditioning and liquid cooling, also require substantial energy consumption to prevent overheating caused by continuous operation of servers, storage systems, networking equipment, and maintaining optimal operating conditions. 

Emissions related to data centers are mainly categorized as Scope 2 emissions for tech companies, meaning emissions from purchased electricity by the organizations. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), data centers and data transmission networks alone account for about 1-1.5% of global electricity consumption. This percentage is expected to rise at a surprising speed as more organizations and industries adopt AI technologies.

Another big part of the emissions of AI usage is coming from the life cycle of hardware used. AI models run on hardware - computers that incorporate resources such as processors, memory, and networks. The embedded carbon emissions arise because there are energy uses in each of the life cycles of hardware used by AI, including extraction of materials, manufacturing, upstream transportation, and disposal. 

The rise of AI emissions has been crucial for the tech sector to combat their carbon emissions, requiring them to develop a holistic and robust approach around green AI. In the subsequent study, we will identify the key pathways for green AI practices and the low-hanging fruit for companies to see impacts immediately.

Improve the energy efficiency of data centers

One way of abating carbon emissions of AI usage is to adopt next-generation infrastructure more efficiently. A simple approach is to improve the power usage effectiveness (PUE)1 of data centers used. This can be done by incrementally increasing current data centers or by replacing and adding data centers with the latest practices. One example is to shut down “zombie servers” - those that use electricity but no longer have workloads or data on them - consolidating workloads so that there are more per server, which reduces the number of servers and in turn enhances the utilization of a single server. 

For large deployments, it is also feasible to implement advanced cooling systems that host the servers and data centers. Enterprises are able to simply move data centers to cooler locations or invest in new cooling technology, but this could be expensive. This has been implemented by Microsoft. They have built a Thermal Energy Center and developed a more efficient cooling system by leveraging the temperature difference between sub-ground soil, which remains constant year-round, and that of ambient air, which changes with seasons. This system is expected to reduce energy consumption by more than 50% of a typical utility plant. 

Waste heat recycling of data centers could be another upgraded option. Microsoft's new data center in the Helsinki metropolitan area, which will use 100% emission-free electricity, is able to capture the excess heat generated from itself and send the clean heat for multiple use. Fortum, a power company in Helsinki, helps transfer the clean heat from the server to homes, businesses and public buildings that are connected to the local heating system. It reduces about 400,000 tonnes of CO2 emissions annually and brings an upgrade of community heating networks in Finland. 

Source: Microsoft data center collaborated with Fortum in Helsinki. Source: Microsoft

Shifting to cloud & edge AI computing might be more effective and less costly

Improving the efficiency of data centers may sound glorious, but in fact, it is expensive and results in limited carbon decrease. A company would cut carbon emissions by only 15-20% by doubling their investment on existing infrastructure and cloud to reduce PUE, according to a Mckinsey analysis. 

It is suggested that for most AI adopters, compared with improving their on-premise data centers, a much more efficient approach is to shift their business directly on cloud infrastructures. Hyperscalers (also known as cloud service providers) and co-locators have already invested massively in ultra-efficient data centers with PUEs of 1.4, 1.3 or even as low as 1.1 on occasion, whereas the current industry average is 1.57 for an on-premise data center. In recent surveys, researchers even found that running business applications on cloud infrastructure, rather than in on-premises enterprise data centers in Europe, could reduce associated energy usage by nearly 80%. Public cloud services providers such as Microsoft, Google, Amazon are generally much more efficient than those enterprise-operated servers in terms of their data center usage. However, for those small deployments that exist for a particular reason and cannot easily be shifted to the public cloud, it is suggested to consider other alternatives.

PUE data for all large-scale Google Data Centers. Source: Google

At the same time, cloud computing also brings drawbacks such as service downtime or significant slowdowns due to connectivity or network issues. This could lead to slower responses and undoubtedly increased energy consumption. The emerging Edge AI is well positioned to address this issue. Edge AI eliminates the need for connectivity between systems and allows users to process data in real time on local devices such as computers, Internet of Things (IoT) devices, or dedicated edge servers. As a distinctive disrupter, Edge computing reduces the need for high-performance computing infrastructure and thus leads to a significant reduction in energy consumption and carbon emissions.

Edge computing is increasingly seen as the next potential to compete with GPUs for the vanguard of the AI computing market. OmniML, an AI startup recently acquired by NVIDIA in a secret deal in February 2023, is a company that specializes in shrinking machine learning models to edge devices, enabling machine learning tasks to be 10x faster on different edge devices with 1/10th of the engineering effort. Last year, OmniML launched Omnimizer, a platform that can adapt computationally intensive AI models to low-end hardware. The adaptation bridges the gap between AI applications and edge devices and hugely increases the potential of the devices. As data storage and computation become more accessible to users, the adapted and hardware-aware AI is also faster, more accurate, energy efficient, and cost-effective. Edge AI plays a critical role in Green AI, enabling energy-efficient and decentralized AI systems.

Designing algorithms from a systematic view unlocks exponential reduction in energy consumption

To reach the overarching goal of green AI, it is comparably notable to develop more efficient models and algorithms accommodated to the progress of hardwares. As state-of-the-art machine learning is shifting to run on the edge devices, more constraints are introduced compared to traditional algorithm design approaches. This could also prompt the efforts in developing better models to represent data patterns and algorithms to fine-tune the model's parameters. 

Approaches to reduce electricity usage can be identified in different stages of an AI system’s life cycle (e.g, data collection, training, monitoring). In the pre-training session, feeding structured data instead of large raw data can reduce the size of training sets by several orders of magnitude. With a baseline set, similar performance can be achieved with fewer training examples or fewer gradient steps. These reference frames set initially will require substantially fewer samples in the model. During the training, designing more efficient training procedures and inference can reduce the required model variants. In addition, the chosen model and algorithm are crucial in implementing a holistic view of computational power savings in the pre-training and training phase.  For example, tree-based models with sparse features rather than neural networks in deep learning could serve as a viable alternative to mitigate energy use. A study in the International Journal of Data Science and Analytics in 2021 has shown that by selecting branches that require less computational efforts, the tree-based models can be 31% more energy efficient with minimal impact on accuracy. 

Reporting performance curves and building up consumption metrics will be the catalyst for making progress toward measuring and mitigating carbon footprint of algorithms. Training curves provide opportunities for future developers to compare at a range of different budgets and running experiments with different model sizes provides valuable insight into how model size impacts performance. Last year Microsoft, in partnership with the Allen Institute for AI and the Green Software Foundation, released energy consumption metrics within Azure Machine Learning, allowing developers to pinpoint the most energy-consuming work. The methodologies allow users to make wiser decisions about selection of models and highlight the stability of different approaches. It is also a vital step toward more equitable and green AI with clear and transparent reporting of electricity consumption, carbon emissions, and cost. 

Workflows to assess machine learning models. Source: Azure Machine Learning

Ensuring the efficiency and circularity of components of physical assets is key

A majority of carbon emissions of AI usage is classified as scope 3 emissions under the category 2 Capital Goods, referring to the emissions related to long-lasting physical assets such as infrastructure and equipment. To reduce the emissions from manufacturing, transportation and disposal of components, it is essential to ensure that the components sourced from the suppliers are not carbon intensive from a life cycle perspective. 

A key approach is to advance the life cycle assessments of components procured and adapt the sourcing strategy to favor more energy efficient hardwares. For instance, Microsoft has set a responsible sourcing strategy and ensured eco-design requirements for cloud hardwares. They have made sustainability considerations a key part of the entire Microsoft Azure hardware design process - including energy efficiency, repairability, upgradability, and durability. They have also taken initiatives around their zero-waste goal in managing cloud hardwares at their growing fleet of data centers. 

Some companies have also taken similar measures to ensure the efficiency and circularity of their data center components, whereas current initiatives must be upgraded with more stringent policies and concrete targets set by the companies. AI players should constantly keep their engagements with their suppliers to incentivise them to innovate themselves and bring more carbon-free solutions to the market. A comprehensive circularity design guidance and a recycle scheme are also essential to reduce the resources to operate an AI system needed.

What are the quick wins?

AI is likely to continue growing in the upcoming years both in terms of capacity and application. Given the growing attention on environmental sustainability matters brought by AI usage, companies are looking for quick wins that can be applied today. Whether a solution is on one hand low-hanging, on the other hand impactful, depends on its technology and market maturity, affordability, and abatement potential. It also varies with different types of AI stakeholders in the first place. 

Switch to cloud or consider edge computing (for AI adopters)

Switching directly to cloud or leveraging edge computing capacities would be a much better option than optimizing the efficiency of current data centers. Since the investments to improve efficiency could be costly and painful specifically for those AI adopters, companies relying on AI to improve their traditional business processes. 

More efficient and centralized cloud service or edge AI is regarded as a great helper to reduce both environmental and economical cost. 

Improve the algorithm

A portfolio of Green AI tactics in choosing right models and algorithms will help mitigate  energy consumption across the Machine Learning lifecycle. What needs to bear in mind is that small changes and conscious choices compounded in each step during all the different stages make a big difference in the final energy consumption. While the hardware is evolving to allow more decentralized and economical computing, upgrades of algorithms are expected to be adapted with power- efficiency and responsibility in mind, not just to be developed to stay at the bleeding edge.

Explore more eco efficient cooling methods (for tech giants)

For companies whose AI strategy is at the core of their business models, like Google and Microsoft, instead of transitioning to the cloud services they already possess, it is recommended for them to explore novel approaches for cooling infrastructures. Based on our analysis, the current PUE of the data centers is already low, while there is still a lack of well-established methods for cooling the operational computational power in a sustainable manner. For smaller deployments that must remain on-premise for a specific purpose, it is suggested to carefully evaluate the temperature and cooling conditions of the chosen location and circulate the heat generated back to usage. This will help ensure optimal energy efficiency for the cooling infrastructure in use, while remaining affordable and eco-efficient. 

Source renewable power

Of course, sourcing renewable power by signing PPA contracts with local utilities or generating green electricity by companies themselves is a universal option for AI players, which has already been adopted by many tech giants.

Establish the capability to better measure emissions

In terms of the life cycle emissions coming from the AI hardware, the primary step is to establish an inhouse Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) capability to better assess where the emissions come from to build AI infrastructures. Knowing that the majority of emissions comes from a single or a selection of components, companies can effectively act upon it. 

Set proper policies and incentives

A systematic approach is to integrate environmental and circularity metrics into their internal policies. With corporate policies that favor components with smaller footprints, the scope 3 emissions derived from the capital goods purchased within the value chain will be mitigated. This could also result in a virtuous cycle to encourage players in the whole value chain to develop more carbon-free solutions in the market. 

Closing thoughts

To harness the full potential of AI without  negative impacts on the planet, relevant stakeholders in the industry should be aligned on their definition of the concept. Rather than be vaguely elaborated by technical experts. Transparency is essential to make it actionable. By now, rather than accordant practices around sustainability developed by small and industrial AI players, we see a lot of variation of strategies and lack of data and information provided by companies. AI emissions should be important for tech players, but the actions are neither sufficient nor consistent enough to solve the problem. A shift toward more sustainable AI adoptions necessitates huge investments, proper market mechanisms and readiness, which by now, are yet to come. 

We advocate for the essential role of regulations to intervene and drive transparency in the market. Green requirements for AI should be developed to ensure a minimum sustainability attribute of AI usage. Right incentives should be introduced to the market to encourage companies to go for cleaner AI solutions when making business decisions. Green certifications and resources could reduce the information asymmetry in the market and promote clear guidelines and standards for environmentally friendly AI practices. 

The EU is a pioneer in governing the green AI sector. It has already set a tone in the development of a comprehensive regulatory framework and has provided concrete recommendations for AI players to mitigate their environmental impacts. But with the rapid speed of AI proliferation and the pressing environmental consequences in recent years, we anticipate more to come.

Green AI is not just a technological process to automate computation. It's how we collectively bring together all the brilliance and expertise to solve the world’s challenges: economical, environmental, social and legal challenges. Provided a clearer regulatory framework and more actionable guidelines for all relevant stakeholders in the industry, more solutions around green AI are foreseen to grow rapidly in the future. A more holistic and responsible mindset and joint efforts involved in AI development will produce a ripple effect.  The ultimate goal is to trigger a paradigm shift so that sustainable Artificial Intelligence applications could become the norm for the whole industry.  

References

[1]  The power usage effectiveness (PUE) ratio is a metric of how efficiently a datacenter consumes and uses energy. 

[2] Karen, H. (2019, June 9). Training a single AI model can emit as much carbon as five cars in their lifetimes. (MIT Technology Review)

[3] Vida, R., Emi, B., Brendan, R. (2023, July 11). Data Centers and Data Transmission Networks. (IEA)

[4] Gerrit, B., Luca, B., Anamika, B., Andrea Del, M., Jeffrey, L., Pankaj, S. (2022, September 15).The green IT revolution: A blueprint for CIOs to combat climate change. (Mckinsey Digital)

[5] Garcia-Martin, Eva & Lavesson, Niklas & Grahn, Håkan & Casalicchio, Emiliano & Boeva, Veselka. (2021). Energy-aware very fast decision tree. International Journal of Data Science and Analytics. 11. 1-22. 10.1007/s41060-021-00246-4. 

[6] FORTUM CORPORATION PRESS RELEASE (2022, March 17). Fortum and Microsoft announce world’s largest collab­o­ration to heat homes, services and businesses with sustainable waste heat from new data centre region

[7] 2022 Environmental Sustainability Report. (Microsoft)

[8] Peter, G., Anke, H., Jan Peter, S., Cara-Sophie, S., Cristina, U., Andreas R., K. and Sibylle, B. (2021, May 1). A role of Artificial Intelligence in the European Green Deal. (European Parliament)

Institute for AI & Business Review has just been released!

Enter the domain of innovation, where the most brilliant young intellects come together to unravel the intricacies of the digital revolution.

The Institute for AI & Business team take immense pleasure in introducing the inaugural edition of the Institute for AI & Business magazine, which is a curated compilation of erudite articles composed by students, shedding light on the symbiotic relationship between data and artificial intelligence, and their profound impact on the realms of commerce and society at large.

In this first volume, we invite you to explore a thought-provoking assortment of articles crafted by IDEAS students, where knowledge converges with inspiration, and the future of data takes on greater definition.

To access the magazine please follow this link.

HOW CAN BLOCKCHAIN TECHNOLOGY PLAY A ROLE IN ELIMINATING BIAS FROM REPORTS AND CLAIMS SHARED FOR GREEN PROJECTS?

[Student IDEAS] by Amir Khan - Master in Finance at ESSEC Business School

Abstract

This article will look into the origin of the Green Movement and the definition of Greenwashing along with its prevalence, what it entails for consumers & investors, and the current legislative actions in this regard. Post establishing the significance of this challenge, the article will explore Blockchain technology as a potential solution. It will touch upon some of the current projects and critically evaluate them as well as the larger use case in an attempt to map its key challenges and growth trajectory.

---

When you purchase a box of that cereal or ground coffee that you need to start your mornings, have you ever found yourself wondering about what exactly the manufacturer will do with the money it is making from the sale? Besides producing more of the same stuff you’ve come to love, of course. This food for thought has been catching traction with consumers and investors alike, bringing the cryptic answers out of the explanatory notes of complex financial statements into mainstream attention. The bottom-line is that in a world facing several inter-related environmental crises, which are quickly turning irreversible, people don’t want to give their money to companies that are a part of the problem. This attitude is personified in the environmental movement.

Let’s talk about the Green Movement

Concern for the impact on human life from air and water pollution goes back to at least the Roman times. This concern also arose between the late 14th century and the mid-16th century in wider Europe when pollution was being associated with the spread of epidemics. However, the modern environmental movement began much later in late-19th century. It was based around concern to protect the countryside in Europe and the wilderness in the United States, as well as the health effects of pollution caused by the Industrial Revolution. This was also the time that the Sierra Club was founded (1892). It was finally in the 1960s that these philosophical and social strands of environmentalism – among various others – were given political expression through the establishment of the “green” political movement. This movement aims to protect planet Earth from harmful environmental practices and maintain sustainable living standards. Since the 1980s, climate change has become a primary concern of the green movement among other concerns like organic agriculture, pollution reduction, preservation of forested lands and endangered species, and opposition to nuclear power.

A crucial facet of this movement is green consumerism. Also known as sustainable consumerism, this is the practice of making purchasing decisions in a way that minimizes environmental impact and supports sustainable products and practices. This is based on the belief that individual choices can contribute to positive environmental change, encouraging consumers to be more mindful of the environmental consequences of their consumption habits.

Beyond consumerism, another key facet is green investing. This is an investment ideology that seeks to support business practices that have a favorable impact on the environment. Often grouped with socially responsible investing (SRI), green investments target companies and projects focused on sustainable development and preservation of the environment.

However, it is a mistake to believe that all green consumption & investment till date has actually been aligned with environmental interests and this is because of the widespread problem of greenwashing.

But what is Greenwashing?

How does a fund end up carrying an AA or AAA ESG rating while having close to 70% of its revenues being derived from environmentally harmful activities?1 The answer is greenwashing. The term “greenwashing” was coined by prominent environmentalist Jay Westerveld in a 1986 essay targeting the hotel industry's practice of promoting the reuse of towels as part of a broader environmental strategy; when, in fact, the move was primarily a cost-saving measure. Such practices have been undertaken by numerous corporations and projects, over the decades, to mislead consumers and investors to believe that their products, aims, and policies are ESG oriented.

More recently, in January 2021, the European Commission and national consumer authorities released the results of a screening of websites focused on greenwashing to identify breaches of EU consumer law in online markets; reporting that there is reason to believe that in 42% of cases the claims were exaggerated, false or deceptive and could potentially qualify as unfair commercial practices under EU rules2.

Even more recently, in March 2023, MSCI Inc. announced that it will lower its ESG ratings for around 31,000 funds, a change that will mean only 0.2% of funds will have a AAA rating moving forward compared to the current 20%.[1] This move comes as ESG rating providers have continually drawn criticism for using inconsistent rating methodologies that are yet to be properly regulated, creating room for greenwashing.

Therefore, with nearly half the sustainability claims made by companies online in Europe being misleading and close to one-fifth of ESG funds having been rated higher than they actually stand, this problem is bigger than ever.

Greenwashing is everywhere around us!

Even in daily life, not falling for greenwashing has become akin to picking your way through a minefield. A classic example of greenwashing, now referred to as “Emissionsgate”, is when Volkswagen was found cheating emissions tests by fitting its vehicles with a “defect” device, with a software that detected when it was undergoing an emissions test and altered its performance to reduce its emissions level. So, while the company was advertising the low-emissions and eco-friendly features of its vehicles; in reality, millions of their cars were emitting up to 40 times the allowed limit for nitrogen oxide pollutants. This went on from 2009 to 2015 till Volkswagen was caught.4

Fossil fuel giants like BP widely take up advertising tactics that focus on their work on low-carbon energy solutions while oil and gas make almost the entirety of their cost allocations and revenue sources.5 Elsewhere, FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) giants focus heavily on marketing to bury down news like Nestlé, Coca-Cola, and PepsiCo being named the world’s top plastic polluters for the 3rd year in a row in Break Free From Plastic’s 2020 annual report.6

So, then what are Governments doing about it?

Different parts of the world are making progress in environmental legislation at different paces based on their respective socio-economic and political situations, but the ball is definitely rolling when it comes to legislation for sustainability reporting in 2023.

The European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, is planning to release new industry rules in the first half of 2023. The organization has published its “Green Claims Directive”, which is subject to the approval of the European Parliament and Council before it comes into force. The new measures are designed to prevent companies from making unsubstantiated environmental claims about their products and services, warning that they could soon face penalties of at least 4% of their annual revenue for “greenwashing.”7

Meanwhile the UK is planning to table the “Digital Markets, Competition and Consumer Bill”, under which large companies face the threat of civil penalties of up to 10% of their global turnover for breaching consumer law, which will also cover misleading environmental claims.8 The British prime minister, Rishi Sunak, has called the passing of this new bill a “priority” for his government. On the investing front, the UK has launched a consultation on the extent to which ESG raters need to be reined in by clear rules.

Across the Atlantic, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued two new sets of proposed rules in 2022: “Investment Company Names” (“Names Rule”) and “Environmental, Social, and Governance Disclosures for Investment Advisers and Investment Companies” (“ESG Disclosure Rule”). Combined, these two proposed rules are meant to combat greenwashing. They dictate that only funds with an ESG purpose will be permitted to label or indicate themselves as ESG, and a new mandatory disclosure for these ESG-focused funds will allow outside parties to ensure whether such purportedly ESG-focused funds are following their stated investment purpose.

Life is not simple for green investors

In May 2022, Tesla was removed from Standard & Poor’s (S&P) 500 ESG Index, which continued to retain Exxon Mobil. This means that the index, which tracks companies based on S&P’s own sustainability standards, considers the fossil fuel major to have better overall sustainability credentials than the EV giant. However, on the other hand, research by Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) shows that this view may not be shared by other rating providers.9 This is because the disparity in outcomes of ESG ratings between providers suffers from “the lack of unified objectives and standards for ESG measurements, disclosures and methodologies.” The subjective nature of these ratings makes them incomparable and difficult for green investors to use in decision making. In fact, green investing still faces the fundamental problem of a lack of globally accepted definitions and standards on what actions constitute the fair usage of terms like ‘Conscious’, ‘Eco-friendly’ and ‘Zero Environmental Footprint’ among others in public claims.

On the sustainability reporting end, while the initial approach has been orientated towards traditional financial auditing, there are significant issues in this approach to reporting and auditing environmental data. Sustainability reporting encompasses a wide range of qualitative and quantitative data, including environmental impact, supply-chain wastage, and corporate governance practices; factors that are often complex and subjective. This makes it challenging for traditional auditing approaches, which primarily focus on financial metrics, to capture and evaluate the full scope of environmental performance.

ESG metrics data is gathered from various internal and external sources, including self-reported information, 3rd party assessments, and industry benchmarks. Ensuring that this data is comprehensive while also being accurate and reliable is beyond the scope of traditional auditing practices. This is because traditional auditing relies on robust internal control systems and verifiable financial records, whereas sustainability data tends to be more decentralized and subjective, making it easier to manipulate.

The solution: “In Blockchain we trust”

When dealing with high volumes of data that has such a wide qualitative and quantitative range, being collected from sources which in turn are dispersed and diverse, it is natural to question the accuracy of the reports being created based on the same. It is in this critical role of reliable and transparent data management that blockchain can be leveraged.

Blockchain is a decentralized, distributed, and public digital ledger that is used to record transactions in batches called blocks. The ledger is stored across many computers so that the record cannot be altered without the alteration of all subsequent blocks and the consensus of the network. Because of this, blockchain is ideal for storing shared information since it provides a de-facto immutable and decentralized record. A blockchain network can track many metrics and with all network members sharing a single view of the data, the technology offers greater confidence in the data reported.

In terms of greenwashing, blockchain can minimize the possibility of data manipulation of the collected data points, in the process creating a transparent data pipeline for accurate sustainability reporting. A prospective structure of such a process for reporting to stakeholders can be as follows:

Data Collection

Automated data collection through technological tools not only reduces the related cost of labor but also helps reduce the possibility of errors and manipulation in the data. A real-time data feed can be developed by combining environmental and/or supply chain data collected from satellite-based sensors, power smart meters, web scraping, imaging drones and IoT sensors.

Data Management

Blockchain technology’s role in transparent sustainability reporting is through its ability to provide immutable certification and automated reporting of data points related to an organization’s ESG metrics data. By using this, manufacturers can track and trace products and labor conditions along their supply chains, storing these findings on the blockchain alongside their other metrics. By integrating data from their vendors and suppliers, companies can measure every relevant metric using a uniform mechanism. All the information would be immutable and remain on-chain, therefore, ensuring that it is free of any manipulation once it has entered the blockchain.

Data Sharing

The unalterable record of sustainability data on the blockchain can then be shared in a transparent and efficient manner. Smart contracts are a great way to do this; these are digital, immutable, and automated contracts on a blockchain in which the contracts’ rules and execution instructions are written directly into self-executing code. Smart contracts can be used to automatically disclose ESG information either in real-time or based on a preset schedule to the public or regulators. Since human supervision is not required, errors are minimal, and the authenticity of the data is ensured.

While immutability of data is ensured by the blockchain network, we face a similar limitation of garbage in, garbage out as we do with other technologies. Rigged meters or sensors becoming faulty over time are very real possibilities and can hamper the accuracy of data, a serious concern when said data becomes immutable. This point of fragility, termed the “Oracle Problem” can be strengthened by incorporating solutions like decentralized oracle. Decentralized oracles act as public libraries with multiple sources of information, through these multiple data sources they minimize counterparty risk and transfer on-chain the most accurate data available. Over time, the ability of these decentralized oracles improves through “learnings” by penalizing individual oracles that provide inaccurate data.

Blockchain projects and startups forging the way forward

Application of blockchain to counter greenwashing is an area of discussion that has been ongoing for the past few years and has relatively recently started giving rise to its first implementation projects. Here we look at some of the solutions currently being scaled:

EY and its EY OpsChain ESG platform

One of the Big 4 accounting firms, EY is looking to offer carbon traceability and carbon credit services with the launch of EY OpsChain ESG by leveraging blockchain technology. Carbon traceability is the ability of an organization to trace its own carbon footprint, and carbon credit – also known as carbon offset – is a reduction or removal of emissions of carbon dioxide to compensate for emissions made by an enterprise.

This new solution is based on the EY Blockchain SaaS platform. It offers a single and verifiable view of CO2 emissions to help organizations accurately measure and track their carbon footprint, offering enough granularity for enterprises to be able to link their carbon output to specific product output. The platform is developed on the Ethereum blockchain and is independently verifiable by using key emissions data validators.

This product offering has been introduced in May 2023 under the leadership of Paul Brody, EY Global Blockchain Leader and is managed by Sam Azad, EY OpsChain ESG Product Owner. Their team has developed this platform based on the standards for Carbon Emissions Tokens published by the Sustainability Business Working Group of InterWork Alliance.

Provenance and its 'Proof Points' system

Provenance is an early-stage startup founded in 2014 that has developed a blockchain-based data platform designed to offer open and accessible information about products and supply chains. Founded by Jessi Baker who currently acts as CEO, Provenance is headquartered in London and is working with 200+ beauty and cosmetics brands across D2C and retail partners in USA, UK, and the EU.

The startup offers digital verification for sustainability claims such as ‘Reduced Carbon Footprint’, ‘Fully Recycled Packaging’ and ‘Upcycled Ingredients’ as well as 3rd party certifications like Fairtrade and Leaping Bunny Cruelty-Free. Currently, Provenance offers verification for close to 90 claims, divided into 5 categories: climate, waste, nature, workers, and communities. These claims are displayed as ‘Proof Points’ that offer deeper information to consumers.

This entire platform is powered by blockchain. Phil Verey, Managing Director at Provenance explains “The way we use blockchain at Provenance is really just to provide a secure, immutable and transparent way of logging claims, make sure they are fact-checked, that they have the right evidence and making sure those claims are then accessible to anyone who wants to see them”.

Provenance’s aim is to create a future where shoppers make purchases based on verified information instead of blind trust on ESG claims. Going further, the company is even exploring the potential of taking their project to an ingredients level of transparency for the cosmetics industry.

Empower

Empower is an early-stage startup founded in 2018 by Wilhelm Myrer (CEO), Carl Nesset (COO) and Gjermund Bjaanes (CTO) that combines plastic recycling and blockchain to create a sustainable circular economy platform that ensures zero greenwashing. The Norwegian startup aims to extend Norway’s incredibly efficient national plastic exchange system (that recycles 97% of all plastic bottles) to a global scale.

Empower uses blockchain for every step of the process starting from collecting plastic at the source through the sorting process to its eventual recycling and reintegration back into the supply chain. The use of blockchain doesn’t just allow each step in the process to be fully verifiable with incorruptible documentation but also allows for seamless tracking and monetization of plastic - even in 3rd world countries where a large part of the population is unbanked.

By tracking every aspect of the journey, from on-the-ground plastic pickup operations to eventual reuse in other products, the level of transparency negates any chances of greenwashing and that is attractive to companies, plastic processors, and consumers. This increases the value of the waste plastic collected, turning plastic collection into a viable earning activity for the world’s underprivileged populations.

Treejer and its Treejer Protocol

Treejer is a seed stage startup founded in 2021 that connects sponsors to rural planters worldwide. It is a “A unique borderless approach in Climate Action powered by blockchain technology.” Treejer creates a link between those who fund trees and those who plant them even in the most remote parts of the world. The platform uses smart contracts to record credit ownership and enables secure payment between different parties.

Founded by a team of 6 people in Iran, the CEO of this fledgling project is Ermia Saharkhiz. Over the last 12 months, the team has launched the Treejer Protocol on Polygon, a public and eco-friendly blockchain. This enables anyone anywhere to fund and plant forests using Treejer’s apps. Donors use a web interface to fund planting of trees and expand their forests online while rural planters use the app to get onboarded, submit planted trees, and receive support for their contributions.

The whole process takes place through direct crypto payments enabled by Treejer’s smart contracts on the blockchain. These smart contracts receive, store and release payments based on predefined terms. The planters are provided with user-friendly and non-custodial crypto wallets to receive their conservation rewards without bank accounts. In this way, Treejer unlocks new opportunities to support unbanked local communities around the world by creating reliable monetary incentives for planting trees.

Critical Evaluation

Application of blockchain in sustainability reporting has gathered significant steam in the last few years through numerous initiatives and startups. The projects covered in this article have made great strides as well in the past couple of years. Provenance has established its presence in Europe, North America, and Asia Pacific; partnered with Douglas, a sizeable European e-commerce platform for beauty and health; and closed a $5m funding round led by Working Capital Innovation Fund and Nordic Eye. Empower has launched EmpowerChain, a blockchain network that provides tools, infrastructure, and incentives needed for the circular economy to work; developed the Empower Product Passport in collaboration with EY Doberman; and recycled 32mn kg of plastic till date. Treejer was selected for the 2021 UNICEF Venture Fund cohort, successfully ending up as one of the 5 joiners to graduate from the fund in September 2022; and is making deep inroads into Africa and Latin America through several strategic partnerships. EY’s OpsChain ESG platform launched a few months ago is already onboarding prospective clients onto its beta version and plans to leverage EY’s global reach to take this platform far and wide.

However, at the same time, the path forward to scaling these solutions globally faces several challenges that need to be overcome, such as:

  • These projects tend to require heavy initial investments in digital infrastructure and technical expertise along with several initial pilot runs to develop the blockchain network and protect against the Oracle Problem.
  • This also brings into question the relative strength of different countries’ relevant infrastructure (internet availability and speeds, distributed and cloud computing, reliable supply of electricity, and digitized data, all of which power the blockchain) where these projects are supposed to operate.
  • Interoperability between various ledger types (public and private ledgers) is key. For this, blockchain architecture standards will have to be developed to allow interoperability between technology solutions for collaborative trust.
  • In the case of sustainable traceability management, system performance is vital for applying blockchain. The challenge being to consistently ensure the stability and robust performance of blockchain based applications.
  • Finally, blockchain technology does not have a legal and regulatory framework yet. However, there is good progress in this area thanks to The World Economic Forum, which in 2020 published the white paper “Global Standards Mapping Initiative: An overview of blockchain technical standards”. This white paper delivers a much-needed analysis and guide for sifting through technical standards.

These challenges signify the necessity for a systematic scaling up of the projects leveraging this use case of blockchain. Even so there is significant support available to these projects coming from the increasing importance of environmental sustainability in today’s times. Bloomberg's “Sustainable Future Study”, sponsored by Mubadala estimates the valuation of ESG assets to hit $50 trillion as soon as 2025, this represents more than a third of the projected $140.5 trillion in total global assets under management. This boom in funding is coupled with changing attitudes in the corporate world with a resounding 71% of global business leaders believing that, “Eventually, no investment decisions will be made without considering ESG.”

Most of the startups in this area are still at Seed to Series A stage; therefore, funding is going to be a key requisite for these enterprises to scale. On that end, McKinsey reports positive findings: “Climate investing experienced a period of breakout growth in capital formation over the past four years. From 2019 until the end of 2022, private-market equity investors launched more than 330 new sustainability; environmental, social, and governance (ESG); and impact funds. The cumulative assets under management in these funds grew threefold, from $90 billion to more than $270 billion.” In this rapid growth of private market investment, the public sector will also be a significant investor. The US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), passed in 2022 has allocated more than $370 billion in funding for climate change mitigation, while the EU Green Deal can potentially dedicate upwards of €1 trillion in public and private funds. As a result, while these businesses will have to earn their valuation in a tough fundraising market, there is enough dry powder with VCs and other investors to fund these projects.

However, a key challenge also exists on the demand side. Companies must feel the need to incorporate these solutions in their sustainability reporting, something they might be averse to especially if these solutions disclose greenwashing that is covering practices and emissions earning them billions. Essentially, it is the ESG equivalent of a financial audit, and auditors aren’t exactly the best friends of the management. Therefore, mass scale adoption of these solutions on a voluntary basis can end up being very gradual, based on consumer pressure and increased ethical enlightenment among management circles. To circumvent this issue government involvement in terms of legislation is crucial. The pertinent question here being “Does mandating sustainability reporting make a real difference if measures to avoid greenwashing are not mandated as well?”

Closing Thoughts

Several startups have developed scalable solutions applying blockchain technology to eliminate bias from environmental claims and reports. Their growth is tied to the growth of the larger ESG industry and government regulations will play a key role in the same. Within climate-tech, the number of unicorns has not only been rapidly expanding, but the age of new unicorns is also compressing. Close to 60% of the climate-tech unicorns in 2021 reached the $1B valuation mark in less than 7 years. However, startups founded after 2017 have consistently grown into unicorns in 4 or less years, notably making up 40% (approx.) of the prominent 2021 climate-tech unicorn cohort. Based on the funding and valuations trajectory that has stayed strong for climate-tech even after economic headwinds of 2022, the next 7-10 years will see these blockchain-based startups scaling up, turning into unicorns and hopefully – with the help of regulators – counting manufacturing, automotive, aviation, and energy behemoths of the Fortune 500 as their clients. This will finally bring about meaningful change in the trust consumers and investors place in sustainability reporting and who knows, we might save the planet after all.

References

[1] White, N., & Schwartzkopff, F. (2023, March 30). Over 30,000 Funds to Get Their ESG Ratings Downgraded at MSCI. (Bloomberg).

[2] Press release. (2021, January 28). Screening of websites for ‘greenwashing': half of green claims lack evidence. (European Commission).

[3] White, N., & Schwartzkopff, F. (2023, March 30). Over 30,000 Funds to Get Their ESG Ratings Downgraded at MSCI. (Bloomberg).

[4] Robinson, D. (2022, July 17). 10 Companies Called Out For Greenwashing. (Earth.org).

[1] Robinson, D. (2022, July 17). 10 Companies Called Out For Greenwashing. (Earth.org). [1] Robinson, D. (2022, July 17). 10 Companies Called Out For Greenwashing. (Earth.org).

[5] Ibid.

[6] Ibid.

[7] Meredit, S. (2023, March 24). A ‘greenwashing’ crackdown in Europe hasn’t gone down well. (CNBC).

[8] Ungoed-Thomas, J. (2023, February 19). ‘Greenwashing’ firms face steep new UK fines for misleading   claims. (The Guardian).

WHY DO WE NEED A CENTRAL BANK DIGITAL CURRENCY WHEN MONEY IS ALREADY DIGITAL?

[Student IDEAS] by Paul Bédier - Master in Data Sciences & Business Analytics at ESSEC Business School & CentraleSupélec

Abstract

The article aims to provide the reader with a better understanding of Central Bank Digital Currencies by giving them the required background to critically assess their usefulness and stakes. We explore the motivations behind these new projects, delve into the issue of public-private money balance seating at the core of their genesis, and provide different perspectives on possible implementations. Our view is that central banks should strive to chart cautious yet efficient paths towards CBDC. 

---

Brand new acronym, same old idea?

CBDC: the new 4-letter acronym that will no doubt be the subject of heated disagreements for the years to come. It stands for “Central Bank Digital Currency.” For the average reader, the central bank rhymes with monetary policy and interest rates while digital currency would be associated with fintech companies and the crypto sphere. Confused? Let us attempt to clear the haze surrounding the buzz and jargon. 

First, think about digital currency for a minute. Most people should be aware that an overwhelming majority of money already sits on digital ledgers: bank accounts. It is through a game of accounting entries that transactions are carried out. Tangible money like coins or bills is estimated to account for only 3 to 8%1 of the world money supply (with variations among countries). Why then do we keep hearing about digital currency as if it were this great transition we are on the verge of? 

The answer is simple: central banks have been ramping up the communication about their Digital Currency projects, hence we are increasingly hearing about it. As of 2023, 130 countries2 (representing 98% of world GDP) are in the process of evaluating the launch of CBDC projects. Eleven countries have already launched theirs. What are these projects about? They can take different forms, but all revolve around the idea of transforming centrally issued banknotes and coins in a digital format and making them accessible to the public for transactions at its most basic level, or for savings and other financial operations at a more advanced level.

Here you might stop and say: “well how is that any revolution? I already have a bank account with digital money inside it and I use my credit card instead of bills to settle transactions”. It is indeed a subtle but undeniable revolution. The main distinction between what we have now and CBDCs is the same distinction that has always existed between private and public. The digital money you currently use through your credit card is issued by a private bank, while CBDCs would be issued by the central bank just like banknotes and coins. So, the definition of CBDC is simply the following: “A Central Bank Digital Currency is the digital form of a country’s fiat currency.”

After this explanation, you may feel a bit underwhelmed. We will simply have digital banknotes and coins now, why not. Does an old idea already materialized in our world really warrant a brand-new acronym? 

Yes, it does, because the distinction raised above between private and public money is critical. Indeed, CBDCs are groundbreaking for two main reasons. First, the motivations behind them are numerous and diverse, and find their roots in questions of economic stability, financial efficiency, international geopolitics, and even sociopolitical objectives. Second, their mere implementation has the potential to be a can of worms and may compromise the financial stability they are meant to help with. By their nature of being digital currencies, they will intrinsically carry with them the potential for many advanced functions, through their programmability for instance, which might enter in direct competition with the private financial - and technological - sector. We will see that for these reasons, different countries have different plans for CBDCs. 

Now comes the question we will strive to address in this article. Will CBDCs be useful to society? Are they necessary? The answer is not straightforward. Let us dig into this!

Motivations behind CBDCs, a tangled web

The idea of CBDC certainly is not new, and one tentative attempt at identifying its original author attributes it to Nobel laureate James Tobin3 who in 1987 already advocated for a public payment “medium with the convenience of deposits and the safety of currency”. Ignored for a long time, the proposal regained traction in the recent years, with central bank and public officials warming to it as a solution to rising issues: the decline of cash, exacerbated during the COVID crisis, and the relative spread outside of the traditional monetary system of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin or, perhaps even more concerning, stable coins backed by tech giants such as Libra (Diem).

For Society and Businesses: Improve Financial Inclusion & Monetary Efficiency

On paper, motivations behind launching a CBDC could come from a genuine objective to better society and improve financial services. One of its most noble impacts would be to provide each citizen with a universal bank account at the country’s central bank, bringing basic and low-cost banking services to all. The positive repercussions of such a move, especially in developing countries with high unbanked rates, could be staggering. 

Furthermore, CBDCs would bring with them a number of technological innovations, pushing efficiency upward for both individuals and businesses. Most of these innovations already exist, propelled by fintech companies, but they would take an even wider scale within the fiat currency infrastructure provided by central banks. With intermediaries such as commercial banks or clearing houses eliminated, real-time payments and settlements could take place, thus reducing financial risk, complexity and in turn lowering transaction costs. Proof of transaction in the form of a digital record located either on a distributed ledger (yet still centrally controlled) or a centralized database would foster trust and transparency in the financial system, making it more difficult for conflicts to arise and for fraudulent activities to take place. Finally, CBDCs would allow for easier programmability and bring with them a large number of beneficial features for the financial system. The best and most famous example is with smart contracts, which can be automatically settled and remove much of the counterparty risk usually involved in transactions.

Another motivation for CBDCs, and one that should please proponents of the neoclassical school of economics, is the heightened competition between private banks that would ensue a CBDC launch, as they would need to offer better services and interest rates to their customers for fear of losing them to the central bank. Now, this is a hot-issue topic and there is dissent among both central banks and public officials as some fear this could backfire. Indeed, they argue that by eroding the banking sector’s profitability and encouraging financial disintermediation, the consequences for the economy at large in terms of efficiency and innovation could be detrimental. Let us delve more into this issue later in the article. 

For Central Banks: Regain Monetary Authority

Central banks have clear motivations behind CBDCs, which boil down to reaffirming their authority over money. Indeed, while they used to be fine relinquishing money issuance activities to private banks as long as it meant they could focus on monetary policy through their direct and indirect control - required reserves, policy rates, open market operations to name the main tools at the central bank’s disposal. In fact, this proved quite successful all things considered, as the commercial banks could compete with one another and innovate to win over customers, while the central banks essentially outsourced financial intermediation and credit issuance activities. The decline of cash - public money - to a baseline level was merely an accepted consequence. 

However, this system is now being challenged from different sides with the spread of alternatives to fiat money: cryptocurrencies and stable coins. The former, coming from society’s underground, is a threat to the central bank’s authority and control over monetary policy and in their eyes a source of volatility arising from unregulated speculation and therefore a risk to global financial stability. However, cryptocurrency adoption remains low and its viability as a fiat money alternative is very debatable, as explored in the previous article of this series. The latter, coming from tech giants and the fintech industry, has the potential to become an even larger threat to central banks by short circuiting the established financial system. Finally, cash decline could now turn into full-fledged cash disappearance after the fintech industry filled the holes created by the COVID crisis, leaving our societies entirely reliant on private forms of money.

CBDCs could be the answer central banks are looking for, as they would intrinsically bring back public money in the economy, reaffirm their authority over the monetary system and even grant them new vectors of monetary policy. For the latter, this could simply take the form of direct transfers to the public with public money issuance, or so-called “helicopter money.” More refined approaches could involve programmability of money, say implementing expiration dates which would spur spendings and discourage savings – something that was assessed by China in their pilot program in Shenzhen. Finally, CBDCs could help central banks enhance financial stability by offering an alternative to fractional reserve banking and thus limiting the risk and impact of bank runs, and by avoiding a potential flight to unregulated and volatile cryptocurrencies or stable coins. 

Now, of course the claim central bank’s authority was eroding to start with should be nuanced. In the last decade, institutions like the Federal Reserve of the United States of America (“Fed”), the European Central Bank (“ECB”), Bank of England, People’s Bank of China (“PBoC”), and many more have unleashed massive quantitative easing programs in the wake of the 2008 market crash, overflowing the market with liquidities in support of their respective economies. Recently, most of them have started a series of policy rate hikes to fight inflation caused by COVID crisis recovery and the Russian-Ukraine war supply shock. This would tend to show central banks are still very much in control of the monetary system and that their authority over the matter was not threatened quite as much as previously implied. 

However, much can be told from how the central bank’s own stance on the matter shifted at the turn of the COVID crisis. Indeed, up to 2020, the consensus towards CBDCs was still fairly negative, or at least erring on the side of high caution. Now, the tone is a lot more positive, with central banks eager to communicate on their CBDC projects and deliberations. This is primarily the result from a better understanding of the impact of digital currency’s implementation on the existing financial system, and how it could be mitigated. But this is also due to renewed interest as central banks now would not reject an increase in the scope of their policies nor access to additional tools. Especially when economists are increasingly pointing out the risk of a decoupling between traditional monetary policy and the real economy.

For Sovereign States: Compete in the Monetary Arms Race

Sovereign states presumably act in their citizen’s interest and thus would be aligned with all the motivations listed above for individuals, businesses, and central banks. But they also have specific interests in the launch of Central Bank Digital Currencies. A domain in which they could be helpful to the state is the fight against illicit activities. Indeed, a digital repository theoretically makes them able to keep track of the exact location of each monetary unit of the currency. This could have repercussions for tax collection, making evasion more difficult through means of offshore banking or unreported employment via underground economies. It also makes it easier to spot criminal activities, track money laundering and reverse fraudulent transactions. Of course, all these benefits depend on the type of implementation chosen by the central bank, the amount of transparency in the system and the status of cash in the new system. 

Another game is however at play here, with states fighting in the realm of geopolitics and international competition. Indeed, like any significant technological breakthrough – nuclear weapons, advanced semiconductor chips, artificial intelligence, the potential cost of not developing it may be too high and countries will get caught up in the infamous prisoner’s dilemma. You might ask: “what are the risks in the case of CBDCs, they appear harmless enough.” But this would be discounting the scale and significance of economic warfare. One of the risks to a country is simply to get overrun by the financial innovations provided by the CBDC of another country. This could manifest in increased capital flights, with investors flocking to the other country’s financial markets to benefit from increased efficiency and additional features, as well as individuals using the foreign CBDC as a safe asset. This in turn would have direct detrimental consequences on the economy, as the central bank would need to adjust policy rates in ways which might adversely affect the economy. 

The highest and most critical risk waiting at the end of this path is an outright currency substitution. You may have heard of the concept of “dollarization.” which occurs when a country’s citizens partially or fully rely on a foreign currency (historically it often was the dollar, hence the term). Of course, this can have catastrophic consequences for sovereignty and economic independence, something that most countries want to preserve against. But even the simple erosion of a country’s monetary influence on the world can be perceived as a nightmare for said country. Imagine a world where the USA loses the dollar as the most influential currency and can no longer use it to write the rules of international trade (USD is currently estimated to represent 90% of total foreign exchange volume).4 CBDCs, with their highly efficient cross-border transaction settlement potential could displace the USD from this historic role. It does not take long to see how the US government might fight against this and feel obligated to pursue CBDC developments as a hedge against this risk. Consider also how China is part of the five countries who launched their CBDC pilot programs, while the US remains at preliminary research and deliberations, and you might sense uneasiness.5 

Now that we have outlined the main motivations at play here, let us delve a bit deeper into the potential implementation of CBDCs and how they must find a difficult balance.

Public and Private money, a fragile balance

The Great Illusion

Central banks are great contenders for the title of most impressive magician out there. Not because they seemingly create money out of thin air or make it disappear just as easily, although that is certainly a neat trick. No, it is because they have created and maintained one of the longest running illusions in the history of humanity, on a wide scale. What is this illusion? We may call it the “illusion of one money.” Ask yourself, is there any significant difference between the currency you hold in your wallet and the one you hold in your bank account? If your answer is no, then you were successfully tricked. Indeed, as we have touched upon in the introduction, the former is public money issued by the central bank, while the latter is private money issued by a commercial bank. This subtlety is critical, as it stands at the core of the existing financial system. 
How do central banks manage this? By their role as a “lender of last resort,” they guarantee immediate convertibility of private banks deposits into fiat – public – money. In essence, we collectively place our trust in this state institution and the result is that we can benefit from the private banking industry’s services on a scale that the central bank would not be able to offer on its own. To the point where, in stable countries, we barely ponder the difference. Reality only comes back to hit us in the case of a bankruptcy, with the infamous bank run scenarios. A good analogy, although slightly provocative, is the casino one. Depositing your money at a commercial bank is like entering a casino and exchanging your money against chips.6 These chips are a form of “I owe you,” legal tenders for any transaction inside the casino and ones that bind the casino to exchange them back to you for currency.

However, if you go outside and try to pay for your groceries with your chips, you will likely raise an eyebrow. The illusion of one money is broken. In the case of the banking system, interconnection between banks helps maintain the illusion further, allowing us to use our “private chips” almost anywhere. These interconnections are made possible by clearing house systems, on which a digital form of public money is automatically and periodically compensated, balancing out overall private bank accounts through required reserves. 

Now is the time to introduce the distinction between wholesale and retail CBDC. The former is an evolution of the process described above. The central bank issues a digital currency, which private banks hold and can use to settle with one another in real time. As such, interbank transfers could become much faster than they are today. A wholesale CBDC would also facilitate cross-border transactions. Today, the public form of money that banks exchange is already remarkably close to what a wholesale CBDC would be, minus the technology allowing for instantaneous settlements. Retail CBDC on another hand is a much more significant project to grant access to digital public money to the general public and is what we have been describing in this article so far. Note that hybrid projects exist, which would work to implement both in one package. 

The “Benevolent” Intermediary

To better understand the fragile balance between public and private forms of money, one must be aware of the money creation process. Today’s banking system is organized as “fractional reserve banking.” This means that commercial banks, as credit institutions, have near free reign to create money out of thin air by crediting your accounts. This is a loan, or debt instrument, and is how the money supply is expanded. Of course, loans should eventually be repaid, and banks want to make a profit through interests. This means that lending money to individuals or businesses involves credit analysis and due diligence over the borrower’s solvency. Furthermore, banks do not have completely free reign over lending, as they are required to hold reserves at the central bank. This consists of a fraction of their deposits, hence fractional reserve banking. The role of central banks is to control the money supply through different instruments, required reserves ratios being one. This has an impact on the dynamics of the economy – supply expansion, or heightened lending activities, will stimulate investments and GDP growth, while supply contraction might harm the economy but will exercise downward pressure on inflation rates. 

Private banks thus play the role of the intermediary in the system, managing deposits and granting loans, on a scale that the central bank would not be able to sustain. Of course, they do not do this out of benevolence, but profit seeking (or return objectives in the case of credit unions). This system promotes competition between banks, which in theory is beneficial to customers through lower interest rates and better financial services. Financial innovation is also fostered, leading to more efficient payment and transaction settlement schemes. The convenience of using these payment schemes has pushed back the use of cash. In recent years, new entrants have progressively challenged the traditional banking landscape, mostly coming from the tech industry with both large companies – think Google and Apple – and smaller “fintech” startups – think neo banks, international transfer, decentralized finance. This is further eroding cash use, and leads central banks to worry as, compared to banks, they do not yet have a large regulatory apparatus for tech companies. In a sense, today the balance already weighs heavily in favor of private forms of money.

The Elusive Equilibrium

By issuing CBDCs, central banks would attempt to rebalance the scale and have public money play a renewed and strengthened role in the economy. The right equilibrium is however hard to pinpoint. A significant risk which made most central banks frisky about CBDCs for years was that CBDCs would lead to the uncontrolled disintermediation of the system. Because of the potential attractiveness of central deposits to the public due to factors like safety, liquidity and solvability, the launch of CBDCs could turn people away from commercial banks, deteriorating their balance sheet and causing the risk of bank runs. Such a disintermediation would also be catastrophic for the economy, as the activity is fueled by investments made possible by loans. This might sound overly apocalyptic, as there is reason to believe an introduction of CBDC would not substitute commercial bank’s deposits overnight. After all, many less financially literate people would have trouble seeing the difference and the benefits of switching. Nevertheless, central banks considered this a serious enough issue to pull the brakes on CBDCs and launch in-depth review programs and impact studies. The critical point is that even if a large-scale bank run is avoided, even a slow but steady disintermediation of the financial system could be detrimental. 

Reaching the right equilibrium will be a crucial element in the choice of CBDC deployed. Wholesale CBDCs present no risk, being a simple evolution of the current interbank system. Retail CBDCs present a higher risk and warrant more caution. In recent years, central banks task forces have examined hybrid infrastructure which promises to solve this problem if well calibrated. Restrictions on deposits and CBDC programmability could be used to keep the private banking sector attractive and mitigate the disintermediation risk. To conclude, the main approach should be caution, something that central banks understand well. In a report by the Bank for International Settlements co-authored by seven major central banks published in 2020, they outlined a Hippocratic Oath for CBDC: “First, do no harm”.7 

Now that we have explored the motivations and explained the challenges, we have the required ingredients to answer our original question: “will CBDC be useful?”

Usefulness, a matter of perspectives

Usefulness, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder. 

For individuals, valid concerns

While individuals should be excited at the prospect of increased efficiency, better stability, and new financial services, many argue the cons outweigh the pros. Retail CBDCs are seen as yet another intrusion of the state into people’s lives. Indeed, the aim of every CBDC project is a centralized currency, even those that will use distributed ledger technology for efficiency, meaning the central bank will always have full control over the network. This gives a large amount of power to the state via the central bank to add or remove money from accounts. More concerning and realistic for non-corrupt states, the risk of cyberattacks with hackers taking control of the central authority and using it to modify accounts should not be thrown aside too quickly. 

Privacy concerns are obviously also a significant issue for many individuals. If the CBDC implementation gives full visibility over financial transactions and records to the state, which people argue is likely even if central banks include privacy walls into the system, everyone is at risk of seeing their financial data used beyond their consent. In a more extreme case, a full-fledged surveillance state could develop, monitoring its citizens’ transactions and enforcing limitations on certain activities via the programmability of the CBDC e.g., prohibiting purchase of alcohol on weekdays or donations to politically opposed NGOs. These are valid concerns and would resonate well with the quote “technological progress has merely provided us with more efficient means for going backwards” from Aldous Huxley,8 writer of the famous Brave New World dystopian novel. We let it up to the reader to assess the likelihood of this risk. Central banks will certainly need to balance the safeguarding of privacy rights and the transparency necessary to deter criminal activity. In any case, it seems the usefulness of CBDCs to the public will depend on the specific implementation chosen. It is our view that central banks should strive to provide all reassurance required by being transparent and including tight checks and balances to foster trust in the population.

For countries, different paths

Let us conclude this article by stating that there will not be one version of CBDC, there will be as many versions as there are countries implementing them. Each will have its own specific characteristics, trying to address the specific needs of the country but also rooted in that country’s sociopolitical ideology. China, for instance, already released to the public a pilot version of its CBDC, the digital yuan, back in August 2020. The currency has been progressively expanded to more regions, reaching 261 million of users for USD 13.8 billion worth of transactions at the end of 20219 – a moderate result, likely explained by the country’s pre-existing advance in digital payment services. The PBoC states that the objectives are to enhance efficiency and help the state fight against illegal activities. It also defends itself regarding privacy concerns and surveillance accusations, adding that they have included limitations on tracking as part of “anonymity control.”

On another hand, for major economies like the US or the EU, the implementation of CBDC will be much slower, as project calibrations are carried over the coming years and central bank laws will need to be ratified. The Fed has been involved since 2022 in extensive research projects in partnership with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology to assess potential implementations of CBDC as well as their impact. The US will most likely favor a hybrid system, with great incentives given to users to keep using the private banking sector in order to protect this leading industry. They will certainly incorporate into the project the ability for the central bank to directly transfer funds to deposit accounts, as an additional tool of monetary policy. The EU, champion of data protection regulations, will no doubt spend a considerable amount of time to reassure its citizens over the full transparency and limited tracking ability of the central bank. The ECB Governing Council will review the outcome of its first large-scale investigation phase, as part of the “Report on a digital euro” during Autumn 2023 and decide whether to carry forward with a realization phase.11 

Because individual and national interests may not align neatly, there is no doubt citizens of different countries will have diverging perspectives on the usefulness of CBDCs based on their nation’s chosen path.

Conclusion

Throughout this article, our aim was to give the reader a better understanding of Central Bank Digital Currencies. By exploring the numerous motivations behind them, by delving into the issue of the public-private money balance and assessing the usefulness of such projects for all the involved parties. Our view is that central banks should move with caution and high transparency if these projects are to have a controlled impact on the existing financial system and be widely accepted by the population. However, the risk of taking too much time to develop CBDCs in the context of a global economic arms race could prove dangerous to national interests. As such, central banks and the governments backing them should ensure to chart an efficient and resilient path towards CBDC.

We hope that this article will empower the reader to think about this technological progress in a nuanced and complete manner. By self-appropriating the issue and developing a critical perspective, one can participate in the broader debate and hold governments responsible for an appropriate and beneficial development of Central Bank Digital Currencies. 

References

[1] https://occaminvesting.co.uk/how-much-money-is-in-the-world/

[2] https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/cbdctracker/

[3] James Tobin, Essays in Economics (MIT Press), 1987

[4] https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt2212x.htm

[5] https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2023/number/4/article/the-geopolitics-of-central-bank-digital-currencies.html

[6] https://brettscott.substack.com/p/casino-chip-cashless-society

[7] https://www.bis.org/publ/othp33.pdf

[8] Aldous Huxley, Ends and Mean, 1937

[9] https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/blogs/econographics/a-report-card-on-chinas-central-bank-digital-currency-the-e-cny/

[10] https://www.bostonfed.org/news-and-events/press-releases/2022/frbb-and-mit-open-cbdc-phase-one.aspx

[11] https://www.ecb.europa.eu/paym/digital_euro/investigation/governance/shared/files/ecb.degov230713-fourth-progress-report-digital-euro-investigation-phase.en.pdf?704b0eee4c20eee4dbe4970f5091a96a

[Student IDEAS] by Nelberto Nicholas Quinto - PhD student in the Management department at ESSEC Business School

Abstract

This article offers a long-term overview of the transformative role of AI in shaping the future of creativity. Aside from democratizing creative production, it illustrates how AI enhances creativity by reducing the cognitive barriers to ideation and information recombination that is at the heart of innovation. However, issues related to rising quality benchmarks, acceptance, trust, and over-dependence may stifle these benefits. The article ends by offering a simple solution to these quandaries while highlighting other more pressing concerns related to AI’s march into the creative sphere.

---

AI's march into the realm of creativity has been teeming with trepidation, stemming from fears that increasingly sophisticated machines might eclipse our ingenuity and devalue the human experience. Dissecting the intricacies of co-creating works that are deemed creative– i.e. deemed both novel and useful – with generative AI in the first installment of this two-piece article series however reveals an inherently human process. A dance that involves iterative bouts of innovative experimentation, unique amalgamations of tools and ideas, and a critically overlooked component – emotion. The realization of these intensely human aspects offer a distinctly more hopeful perspective, contingent upon us remaining actively involved in the process. 

Transitioning from the debate concerning the retention of humanistic elements in AI co-creation – elements that imbue depth, meaning, and value to the creative process, as discussed in this article’s predecessor, this installment aims to elaborate more on the benefits, limitations, and long-term challenges to creativity that arise from this generative process. The question of whether AI could potentially spell the demise of creativity in the long-term is ultimately addressed, followed by a conclusion that steers the discourse towards identifying more pressing concerns about AI that will require much of our ability to provide novel and useful solutions.

Recapping the Creative Benefits to Leveraging AI

Creativity is understood as the generation of ideas, processes, or products that are both novel and useful1,2. When understood as an ability to produce works that meet this two-fold criteria of novelty (uniqueness, originality) and usefulness (value, quality), both the outcomes and processes inherent in generating them become relevant. One of the most widely observed benefits of co-creating with generative AI is that it streamlines and democratizes the process of creative production. By curtailing the costs related to skill, talent, and equipment (or software), AI facilitates the genesis of valuable, new creations –- be they illustrations, poems, marketing slogans, or strategic proposals. This empowerment invites a wider demographic to unlock their inherent creative potential and engage in the human-AI symphony of creation. Take, for instance, the case of Aamar Reshi discussed in detail in the first part of this article series. His imaginative journey to crafting a children's storybook in 3 days without any prior experience in illustration or creative writing was made possible by AI's ability to translate his motivation into captivating illustrations and engaging storylines.

AI also significantly lightens the cognitive load associated with conceiving original solutions to intricate, pressing problems. For instance, imagine a marketing team trying to brainstorm a new advertising campaign. Instead of spending hours coming up with basic ideas, a large language model (LLM) such as Chat GPT could generate a list of them within minutes. The team could then immediately start discussing which of these listed ideas are worth developing further. They could also combine different AI-suggested concepts to create something unique and impactful. In this way, AI allows for more effective use of the team's expertise and creative thinking. And while much of the content produced by LLMs tends towards the mundane and predictable, this in fact offers a crucial advantage. The immediate availability of a broad spectrum of highly conventional ideas allows individuals and teams to swiftly dispatch with the obvious, learn from these iterations, and refocus their cognitive prowess. In the context of prototyping, generative AI tools have emerged as a catalyst for quickly transforming abstract concepts in our heads into tangible, useful drafts. They shoulder the cognitive and labor-intensive burden of the initial groundwork, generating the first iterations swiftly. As a result, just as in brainstorming, teams can re-allocate their mental energy and time towards more creative tasks, including those where human expertise still surpasses AI.

AI’s Impact on Quality Standards Perpetuates Creativity

As we hurtle into a future fraught with increasingly complex challenges requiring novel solutions, it's clear that both creativity and generative AI’s role in the creative process is here to stay. While individuals will continue to extract value from AI, the benchmark for what constitutes quality and usefulness will concurrently increase. When productive expectations rise, fostering creativity and innovation to meet these heightened standards will always be a need, and often, a priority. While the influx of novel combinations of information and ideas might make the task of generating something truly different and unique with AI progressively challenging as well, it will undeniably necessitate increasingly creative methods to continuously derive value from current tools and systems. Thus, regardless of how sophisticated AI systems become, creativity will always have a place within organizations and society. 

For instance, in producing digital art, some graphic designers are already leveraging AI image generators such as Midjourney and Stable Diffusion to simulate prototypes of their ideas, draw inspiration from different styles, or ultimately create distinct artworks that require minimal post-processing. At first, such use of AI was deemed innovative, and there have been many cases where fresh and valuable works have been produced through such a process. But as leveraging AI capabilities have become more widespread, the novelty of such techniques have declined, and the average uniqueness of generated works have suffered as well. Consequently, the standards for what is considered useful have risen as more people have realized the value of current AI tools. Artists must then deepen their creative explorations, finding fresh ways to collaborate with AI to generate art that remains innovative and valuable amidst the evolving landscape. This may involve countless experimentations with prompt patterns or combining different tools, systems, or methods to process works generated by AI.

Meanwhile, in organizational settings, particularly when teams make use of Large Language Models (LLM), such as OpenAI’s ChatGPT or Google’s Bard, to streamline brainstorming sessions, catalyze idea generation, and decode complex problems– the interplay between creativity and AI unfolds in the same manner as in the arts. Consider a tech start-up using GPT technology to augment their product design brainstorming. The AI solutions might generate new perspectives on user interface design, providing inspirations that the team hadn't previously considered. Companies that successfully integrate such technologies into their workflow stand to gain a competitive edge, as they can alleviate the cognitive burden inherent in creative tasks and propel their innovation teams into uncharted territories. However, as AI-assisted approaches become commonplace, the novelty of these processes diminishes. As more and more employees, teams, and organizations become accustomed to harvesting the creative benefits of AI across a spectrum of tasks, the standard for what can be achieved within a certain timeframe and resource set escalates exponentially.

In response, organizations would need to persistently cultivate creativity to extract further value from AI. They might deploy additional algorithmic tools to discern patterns from past AI-laden brainstorming sessions and predict potential hurdles. For example, a company could use AI to analyze both previous meeting notes and past AI suggestions given various employee-generated GPT prompt patterns. This would allow individuals and teams to leverage insights derived from such data analyses to consequently modify their use of generative technologies for idea development and prototype-building. Such a solution could also lead to routinized processes and systems that facilitate extracting more value from novel AI suggestions in order to suit their unique problem contexts. For example, a marketing team could develop protocols for how to synthesize campaign ideas developed through multiple rounds of brainstorming with generative AI, across several meeting groups. They could also devise a structured process that involves integrating these insights with those uncovered by social media trends, competitor campaigns, and customer behavior data that predictive AI models concurrently deliver. 

In such instances, creative production necessitates innovation in processes where different individuals and AI systems come together to meet the new, heightened standards for novelty and value that innovation and competition propel. However, when novel processes or new best practices are found to be creative at a given point in time, more and more companies are likely to find value in them. This implies that standards will rise again and organizations would need to search for more ingenious processes that leverage existing human and technological capital, fostering creativity and perpetuating its need.

Threats to Creativity: Under-Appreciation and Over-Reliance on AI

Instead of pondering the supposed demise of creativity, perhaps the real issue at hand is the skepticism and under-appreciation of the immense value generative AI brings to the table. It is unsettling to see how quickly some individuals abandon the use of these technologies, swayed by a few erroneous outputs, unsuccessful prompts, or the cynicism of others. On the flip side, there exists an equally troubling group – those over-reliant on AI to the extent that they forsake nurturing their own critical thinking, domain expertise, and breadth of knowledge. This excessive dependency threatens to hollow out human innovation and intuition, reducing our contributions to mere button-pressing reactions to whimsical needs. The remedy to both of these conundrums lies in fostering a comprehensive understanding of AI's capabilities and limitations among the broader population, as discussed in more detail in the first piece of this two-part series.

There is simply so much value-creation lost when people do not simply understand the usefulness of generative tools that can rapidly produce creative drafts and prototypes ; all while harnessing centuries of accumulated human knowledge to yield accurate, factual results in at least 9 out of 10 instances. As such, there is a pressing need to educate individuals about applying even basic generative AI capabilities to the multitude of use cases in their personal and professional lives. This requires promoting practices that encourage persistent experimentation with AI, while fully acknowledging its current bounds and how it can complement our unique strengths. 

The Solution: Continuous Exploration of AI-Human Boundary Capabilities

AI will continue to improve, and so too will our abilities, skills, and talents. In this constant cycle of progression, the necessity of understanding the evolving capacities of AI and human creativity cannot be overstated. Identifying the complementary intersections between AI and our innovative capacity enables us to effectively harness their combined potential. And this begins by ensuring that we remain determined to cultivate the requisite knowledge, expertise, and capabilities to credibly evaluate the usefulness, appropriateness, and credibility of AI generated outputs.

In this dynamic panorama of evolving AI systems and expanding human capabilities, the value of experimentation in demarcating the ever-changing boundaries of both AI and our personal abilities becomes paramount. In particular, this knowledge helps illuminate our understanding of what AI can and cannot do for us, and what we can achieve more efficiently with or without these technologies, for any given moment in time. It also enables us to identify which domain-specific skills and new capabilities we should invest our time in developing and refining. And as we navigate this blurred frontier, the role of continuous learning, engagement, and development of our unique creative abilities vis-a-vis AI becomes ever more critical.

While the “death of creativity” is far from imminent, the reshaping business and societal terrain calls for both prudence and immediate action. As AI emboldens individuals and organizations to leverage technology to augment their unique capabilities and cumulative expertise, navigating this evolving landscape thus calls us to reconsider our part in the redefined creative epoch. Are we disrupting, merely keeping up, or falling behind? Survival in competitive environments, after all, necessitates exploiting the opportunities emerging technologies offer, and we should therefore set aside time in our schedules to explore ways we can achieve this at a personal level. Again, this begins by carefully discerning what both we and AI uniquely excel in, and identifying potent synergies that allow us to balance each other's strengths and weaknesses for our specific trade and tasks. Whether you are a marketer,  musician, illustrator, business owner, or a corporate planner, understanding how emerging technologies affect the value and novelty you produce at any given point in time is paramount to continued success.  Stop. Think. Reflect. What critical inputs, processes, and skills does AI need from you to deliver in order for you to generate ideas, products, and systems that are new and valuable? What are you doing to know or develop this? Your answers to these questions may well define your survival amidst AI’s creative renaissance.

Beyond the Issue of Creativity: Where More Pressing Challenges Lie

While this thought exploration attempts to address whether AI would extinguish the flame of human creativity, it inevitably leaves a myriad of related issues unexplored. Indeed, while AI, with its prodigious generative capacities, promises to herald a creative renaissance—exploring uncharted territories of ideas and unveiling transformative solutions to pressing issues—we must also recognize the potential detrimental impact it could have on our artistic workforce. As discussed, the process of co-creating with generative AI still necessitates an intricate, often emotionally charged, and iterative human endeavor. It involves the careful orchestration of past human experiences to weave into the fabric of our creations. 

Yet a recurrent threat that we are treading is the dangerous line of devaluing the authentic human touch; that is– the artisanal signature underlying much of the creative work we know. Companies may start to undervalue the finesse of artistic capability, leading to reduced remuneration for graphic designers, composers, and other artists. This, even before a novice utilizing generative AI can genuinely outperform seasoned creators. Such devaluation can cause both current and aspiring artists to neglect nurturing their unique aesthetic skills and specialized capabilities, which could be detrimental to the future of creativity. After all, truly harnessing the power of AI for creative endeavors requires not just knowing its technological boundaries, but also having a robust foundation of one’s specialized domain and the aesthetic sensibility needed to both recognize and conjure quality art.

Furthermore, we need to tread carefully on the path of intellectual property (IP) rights. Artists may feel aggrieved as their creative genius– their unique output– is utilized to train AI systems without due recompense or consent. This could make it facile for others to mimic their distinctive style, enabling these individuals to build on years of the artists’ painstaking dedication without due permission or acknowledgement. If we fail to establish robust mechanisms for suitable compensation, recognition, and consent for creative IP, we risk discouraging artists from trusting and reaping the benefits of AI. Worse, we risk a decline in traditional artistic pursuits, which form the bedrock of cultural heritage and individual expression. On a less immediate yet significant impact, we risk losing valuable creative contributions that future generations could build upon. If we deter a whole generation from pursuing arts due to lack of passion or adequate incentive, we lose more than just individual livelihoods. The vibrancy of our cultural tapestry and our collective ability to innovate are at stake. It is therefore vital that we safeguard the livelihoods and IP of artists to prevent cultural impoverishment.

Moreover, while AI undoubtedly creates new job opportunities and uncovers novel synergies between human and machine to drive value and discover novel solutions to critical problems, the rapid pace at which AI is reshaping the job market is cause for concern. The velocity of job displacement could potentially outpace that of job creation and skill development across a wide-array of fields. Its reach already extends to every facet of work, life, and the economy, sometimes unpredictably. Such an imbalance could endanger a substantial segment of the workforce, along with their dependents.

While AI is not poised to extinguish the flame of creativity, it could expedite the ebb of certain industries and livelihoods faster than it rebuilds or expands them. This necessitates an inventive approach to temper potential fallout. Hence, the real merit of AI lies not only in catalyzing and amplifying human creativity to forge new solutions to high-value issues, but also in innovating answers to the challenges it itself surfaces– from that of artistic preservation, intellectual property rights, overly rapid job displacement, and beyond.

References

[1] Teresa M. Amabile et al., Affect and Creativity at Work, Administrative Science Quarterly 50, no. 3 (September 1, 2005): 367–403, https://doi.org/10.2189/asqu.2005.50.3.367.

[2] Teresa M. Amabile, The Social Psychology of Creativity: A Componential Conceptualization., Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45, no. 2 (August 1983): 357–76, https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.45.2.357. 

UNPACKING THE HUMANITY BEHIND GENERATIVE AI CO-CREATIONS

[Student IDEAS] by Nelberto Nicholas Quinto - PhD student in the Management department at ESSEC Business School

Abstract

As AI ventures into the world of creativity, fears are mounting about its potential to undermine human ingenuity and curb innovative pursuits, leading some to proclaim the 'end of creativity.' To navigate this complex issue, this article demystifies the concept of 'creativity,' explores its societal and organizational importance, and breaks down its key elements—novelty and usefulness. Amidst this analysis, a key concern emerges: does the 'human touch' – e.g. emotions, feelings, human experience and intention, etc. – matter in our evaluations of creativity, and if it does - are AI co-creation necessarily devoid of it? We analyze this in a case study and conclude on how this affects our understanding of AI’s effect on overall creativity. 

---

Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) have prompted us to ponder the fate of human creativity and its relationship with technology. Present-day AI platforms have demonstrated their prowess in generating a diverse array of creative outputs. From fabricating tailor-made digital imagery, crafting compelling advertising phrases, drafting cogent essays, or even composing infectious tunes, the allure of generative AI technologies is unmistakable. In 2022 alone, they have drawn a staggering $2.654 billion in investments, marking a tenfold increase since 2020. As AI encroaches upon what was once considered a uniquely human domain, the ontological, economic, and legal systems that underlie creative production are consequently being redefined in profound, uncharted ways. Amidst this upheaval, a question emerges: Is creativity dying, and is AI the culprit?

What Exactly Is Creativity and Why is it Important?

To untangle this provocative question, it is essential to probe into the essence of creativity—its core attributes and its significance to society and organizations. Creativity is defined as the generation of ideas, solutions, or products that are both novel and useful1,2. It is a multifaceted phenomenon, encapsulating not just the outcome or process of idea development, artistic creation, or problem-solving3, but also the inherent ability of individuals to produce the new and valuable. As the cornerstone of innovation, creativity transforms unique ideas into tangible actions or products, which in turn fuel technological advancements. Within organizations, creative employees are a catalyst for competitive advantage4. They contribute unique solutions to pressing challenges, resulting in strategies, business processes, and design concepts that drive success. Creativity also bolsters adaptability in the face of external changes and disruptive technologies, enhancing the likelihood of success for individuals and organizations5.

To grasp the essence of creativity’s central components – novelty (newness, originality) and usefulness (value, quality) – think of the last time you or someone around you has deemed something to be ‘creative.’ Was the value found in the end result or in the process that led to it? As will be revealed, this distinction is central to the debate of whether the growing impact of AI will usher in a creative renaissance or its antithesis.

How AI Affects Creativity: Perspectives, Benefits, and Limitations

The Product Perspective

The traditional perspective of creativity places emphasis on the final product. Think about an evocative novel or an influential film. Their creativity is gauged by the audience's experience with the completed work. The unpredictability of the plot, the introduction of nonconforming characters, and the use of groundbreaking narrative styles all serve as sources of novelty. Meanwhile, the exhilaration experienced from narratives that defy convention, the emotions they stir within us, the curiosity they spark, and the respite they offer from everyday life—all are markers of usefulness attributed to the end product. AI-generated designs, leading to a revolutionary product, align with this perspective. From a managerial standpoint, the value is not in the AI's process of creation but in the resultant artifact—its appeal in the market, and its innovative design that caters to and anticipates consumer needs.

From this product-centered perspective, AI emerges as a potent tool for enhancing our creativity. It produces innovative ideas and forms that inspire human artists and democratize access to creative production by making aesthetic prowess and innovative combinations more accessible. Generative AI can be conceptualized as a new 'paintbrush' for artists and creatives. Anyone can pick up this 'brush' and create—be it poems, design prototypes, or unique product concepts—without necessarily needing the traditional, extensive training or experience. For many, this accessibility may very well foster inclusivity, thereby encouraging a larger population to engage in creative pursuits. It brings people who might never consider performing artistic or innovative work into the sphere of creative endeavors, exploring their human ingenuity as they co-create with AI. 

AI Limitations in Creative Production

However, such democratization comes with its own challenges and limitations. The novelty of the output generated heavily relies on the creativity infused in prompts. The usefulness of the final output also remains somewhat limited, especially when considering the current state of AI wherein the quality of the generated paragraphs, images, or media may still fall short of those produced by traditional professionals.

There's often a substantial amount of trial and error involved in crafting the right prompts, as well as significant post-processing once a satisfactory output is achieved. While these are technical limitations that may be resolved as AI advances, there's another side to consider. As AI improves, so will the benchmarks for what is considered quality, useful, and new. Therefore, it's rare for a few string of prompts to suffice in creating something truly considered creative—that is, novel and valuable—for its time. Even with significant advancements in AI capabilities over time, leading to minimal post-processing or prompt engineering needs, there's always an inherent risk tied to tools that simplify processes.  

The Process Perspective

Another facet of creativity lies not in the final product, but in the process itself. Envision a Master Chef contestant, orchestrating a culinary symphony with a keen eye for novelty and a daring spirit to match the time and ingredient constraints set by Gordon Ramsay and his colleagues. Their masterpiece unfolds as an intricate dance of unexpected ingredient pairings, artistic presentations, and innovative use of techniques, equipment, and resources. Here, creativity is not solely defined by the outcome but by the culinary journey that unfurls, tantalizing taste buds and challenging preconceived notions of what can be done with limited resources. Similarly, improvisational theater values the performers' on-the-spot thinking, synchronized action, and narrative creation, as much as the final performance. The process is integral to determining creativity. Even in organizational settings, the sequential motions inherent in problem-solving —brainstorming, experimentation, and collaboration—are regarded as creative, alongside the effectiveness of their end solution.

Human Experience is Where the Real Issue Lies

Despite known limitations, numerous instances exist where works co-created with AI have been recognized for their creativity. Last year, a digital image generated by AI won a statewide art competition in Colorado. The judges affirmed that their decision to honor the contestant would have remained the same, regardless of prior knowledge of AI involvement in the artwork. In April of this year, a song that employed AI to generate melodies in the voices and styles of popular artists Drake and The Weeknd, went viral on social media. Titled 'Heart On My Sleeve', this track mimicked the stars' distinctive styles in verses ostensibly about pop sensation Selena Gomez, who has romantic ties with The Weeknd. The song was widely lauded for its innovative stylistic fusion and its infectious rhythm. Similarly, in corporate environments, generative AI has been employed to aid the development of innovative marketing campaigns as well as fundamentally novel and useful business strategies that managers can build upon and implement. As such, AI capabilities continue to improve over time, it's becoming increasingly apparent that there's little pushback against the technology’s ability to generate works that are novel and valuable, provided that creativity is interpreted from a product oriented perspective. Hence, the primary criticisms against AI's capability to produce or enhance creativity stem from adopting the process-centric one. 

Valuing process over product often comes with an emphasis on the emotional and sensory journey inherent in human imagination and innovation. This viewpoint suggests that the true value of creative work is deeply entwined with the feelings and shared experiences manifested in its creation. As AI produces creative works based on learned patterns– without true comprehension of our intentions, history, or emotions– creations that leverage it are seen to lack the depth and meaning that gives value to the creative process. Thus, for the many patrons of the human touch, any process void of these elements loses their usefulness automatically. Singer and songwriter Nick Cave eloquently expressed this very sentiment when reacting to a song written by AI chatbot GPT in 'his style':

"Songs arise out of suffering, by which I mean they are predicated upon the complex, internal human struggle of creation and, well, as far as I know, algorithms don’t feel. Data doesn’t suffer. ChatGPT has no inner being, it has been nowhere, it has endured nothing, it has not had the audacity to reach beyond its limitations, and hence it doesn’t have the capacity for a shared transcendent experience, as it has no limitations from which to transcend. ChatGPT’s melancholy role is that it is destined to imitate and can never have an authentic human experience, no matter how devalued and inconsequential the human experience may in time become.”

Are AI Co-Creations Really Devoid of Human Experience: A Case Study

In December of 2022, an intriguing event unfolded in the creative world. One, that invites reflection into the humanity behind AI-co creations. Aamar Reshi, then a tech worker in Silicon Valley, who had no prior experience in graphic illustration or creative writing, produced a children’s book in the span of 72 hours and sold 841 copies in Amazon over a week. His secret sauce? OpenAI's Chat GPT for the story narrative, and the AI art generator, Midjourney, for the illustrations. This well-documented accomplishment represents an interesting shift in the creative landscape, as tasks that traditionally demanded years of learning and skill honing were executed by Aamar in a mere three days—and at virtually no financial cost.

A crucial aspect of this narrative is that Aamar circumvented the laborious grind of mastering digital design and storytelling intricacies. His main inputs, as documented on his Twitter feed6 were two-fold: textual prompts that generated the narratives and illustrations found in his book, and his clever use of these digital tools to construct a coherent piece in a limited amount of time. Trial and error was central to his creative process, as he experimented with different prompts to craft his desired manuscript and illustrations. What used up most of his time was learning to maintain a consistent depiction of his protagonists, Alice and Sparkle on Midjourney. Yet, the conversion of his imagined images and plot ideas into tangible illustrations, descriptions, and written stories required merely a few seconds of waiting time for each iteration. While Aamar's journey showcases the power of AI to democratize the creative process, it also highlights the pitfalls of such an approach. His illustrations lacked consistency and detail, likely a result of his over-reliance on AI tools and his lack of domain expertise in the digital arts. In the end, Sparkle, Alice's robot companion, was rendered differently across each page due to Midjourney's inability to produce consistent illustrations from the same descriptions. Alice, too, was not spared from inconsistencies, depicted with missing fingers on occasion. 

The Creativity and Humanity behind Aamar’s Co-Creation with AI

Aamar was innovative in his clever use of limited resources to solve a pressing challenge: creating a children's book. Although he did not utilize traditional artistic techniques or software, his co-creation with AI served as a conduit for transmuting his imagination into tangible prototypes that allowed him to develop a novel plotline through experimentation with various prompts. Confronted with the issue of inconsistent images, Aamar applied his human ingenuity to devise a clever solution: describing Sparkle to be a robot that metamorphosed into various forms-  a creative fix that cohesively blended with his narrative. 

As noted, his case also illustrates the democratization and streamlining of creative work. Even if he lacked formal training in graphic design and had no prior experience as an illustrator or storyteller, he was still able to conceive an original, interesting story that had (somewhat) coherent and meaningful illustrations. In essence, he came up with creative solutions to turning his fresh ideas into a tangible product which found significant demand, and hence– value, upon its release. And although the usefulness of his work is limited by the inconsistent and, at times un-detailed, illustrations –a limitation which might diminish as AI technology continues to evolve and improve– the evidence suggests that Aamar’s final product is in fact, creative - i.e. novel and useful. Despite the innovative manner in which he developed his storybook however, the value in his process remains questionable to those who value the human elements which underlie creativity production. Therefore, the query looms: was his work void of the humanity that– arguably– gives meaning, depth, and usefulness to the creative process?

Not only did he “borrow” the feelings and emotions nested in the collective intelligence within Chat GPT's memory to produce his plot, dialogue, and illustrations, but upon further contemplation, much of his process actually involves a variety of inherently human attributes. The excitement he felt with his work, the love he felt for his niece that sparked this project, the oscillations between euphoria and melancholy during each imaginative iteration, and the victorious sensation he savored as he reveled in his accomplished masterpiece were all profoundly human experiences and emotions.

In the parlance of Nick Cave’s critique: his blood, sweat, and guts coalesced into a tangible expression of creativity– there at his desk– a realization of a nebulous idea that made its way to him. That is- within the vast expanse of algorithmic and artistic unpredictability, his creative idea found him. In all his humanity. And he made it come to fruition in three relentless days. Thus, Aamar’s case illustrates that the process of co-creation with generative AI can, and often does, involve quintessential human aspects where innovation emerges from processes and ideas that are new and valuable.

Reflections on the Generalizability of these Case Take-Aways

For those of you who have used AI to generate works that were considered novel and highly valuable by your peers, organization, or audience-evaluators, perhaps it is time to reflect and appreciate the inherent humanity in your creative work. For those of you who haven’t, you are invited to envision what such a process should involve as you go through the next sentences. 

Think of instances where you brainstormed ideas or developed potential solutions through a conversation with Chat GPT. Maybe there were times when you involved generative AI in creating a business proposal, an artistic illustration, a musical piece; or perhaps a scientific publication, an innovative product, or even a clever recommendation that was, in fact, considered original and beneficial. Did your creative journey involve the emotional roller coaster of highs and lows? The frustration felt when ideas fail? The iterative cycles where you leveraged multiple tools and information sources in inventive ways to achieve a part of your desired outcome? 

Did you harness feelings and intuitions from your gut? Did you rely on tacit heuristics and knowledge formed from years of accumulated experience and social interactions deeply embedded in your human psyche? If the answer to some of these questions are a yes, then it only shows that Aamar’s experience was not an isolated case- but is, in truth, a generalizable one. 

These aspects are integral to our humanity–our shared experience– and they would very likely have been present in the generative AI co-creation instances that you experienced or envisioned. Even the journey to developing your accumulated expertise in whatever it is you do involves painstakingly human ways in which you labored to sharpen them.  More people need to be reminded that the knowledge and skill that you and I have developed is critical to both evaluating and building upon the intermediate outputs produced by AI to produce works that are actually novel and useful. 

Indeed, the route to producing work that is genuinely innovative, with or without AI's assistance, invariably involves a unique recombination of our lived human experiences and abilities. As can be drawn from your personal cases, and that of Aamar Reshi’s, creators often employ a range of tools, techniques, and information sources to generate value and endure iterative procedures that are seldom smooth and free of emotional dynamics. As such, so long as humans remain in the production loop, any creative process that leverages generative AI still retains significant traces of our shared experience and human nature.

When Does Co-Creating with AI Harm Creativity then?

As with all tools that streamline processes, there is always a danger that individuals might over-rely on them, progressively depending less on their abilities and unique value contributions. In this case, such a trend could lead to a reduced cultivation of both individual creativity and the essential skills relevant to creative production—be it mastering the use of a paintbrush, crafting a riveting narrative for a target audience, evaluating the aesthetics of a presentation deck, or steering a company brainstorming session. As AI takes up an increasing part of the creative process, our aptitude for ideation, improvisation, and critical thinking may begin to fade. 

Similarly, when individuals overestimate AI’s ability to generate value, there is also a tendency to bypass activities that cultivate our ability to generate the novel and useful. Examples include discussing our ideas with our colleagues (as opposed to just chatting with an LLM about them), engaging in exploratory learning, or improving the depth of our specific professional expertise. The ease of producing AI-generated outputs that, at first glance, might seem highly innovative and valuable, might also cause a drop in motivation to engage in creative work - i.e. the question: 'If AI can generate creative works with relative ease, why should I expend the effort?' People need to understand that the path is often an arduous, emotionally tumultuous one, and cases where new and useful products are developed with relative ease are very much the exception rather than the norm. Moreover, projecting into the future, if AI does advance to the extent that it eliminates the need for substantial post-processing work, several prompt iterations, inventive ways to combine different tools and knowledge inputs to produce a novel and useful work– and well, all the emotions that come with these– would that signal the demise of creativity? It definitely is a possibility. If co-creating with generative AI results in fewer problems that demand new and impactful solutions, then creativity may diminish simply because we would need less of it. But that is, by all means, a good problem to have. 

Conclusion

It is imperative that individuals learn to co-create with generative AI tools both responsibly and proficiently. The outlined risks to our creativity demands an understanding that these technologies are not replacements for our own cognitive ability and domain expertise. Neither are they supposed to be used as quick-fix mechanisms for producing content (e.g. essays, images, or sounds) with scant surprise or quality appeal. Instead, individuals should engage with these tools in ways that stimulate their critical thinking, challenge them to push the boundaries of convention, and inspire them to conceive ideas, products, artworks, or business processes that are not only distinct from predecessors but also more efficient, value-enhancing, and superior in quality. And all of this begins with understanding that the path to truly creative co-creation with generative AI is a painstaking, iterative, and exploratory process that requires novel ways to combine our cumulative human experiences, imaginative capacity, and knowledge with the current capabilities of these technologies. 

Such a paradigm shift necessitates substantial investment from organizations, educational institutions, and even governments in programs designed to enable and encourage these exploratory practices. Experimentation, after all, benefits from guidance and often comes at the cost of not getting traditional work or schooling done. But this should not be a cause of worry. We have already witnessed select groups of individuals and organizations leveraging generative AI in new and useful ways that showcase their unlocked creative potential. Business news feeds and popular technology sites such as TechCrunch, Product Hunt, and VentureBeat are filled with a rich variety of new use cases each week. Hence, it is conceivable that support for such endeavors are likely to come. And, as history has demonstrated, when the innovative use of AI enables select groups of people or organizations to excel in their niche, gain a competitive advantage, or simply overcome their peers, then others will emulate their strategies– fueling creativity and perpetuating the cycle of innovation.

Will AI spell creativity’s demise, or could it instead ignite a renaissance of sorts? If the concern lies in losing the humanity behind the creative process, then, so long as humans are involved in the creation process, and that problems and needs that require novel and useful solutions, approaches, or products continue to exist, then the more optimistic of the two scenarios is likely to materialize. In other words, AI may well just revolutionize creativity for the better. 

There are, however, a few other concerns that need to be accounted for, such as the lack of acceptance or understanding behind the value that these generative technologies bring. Particularly relevant as well is how increasing AI adoption inevitably creates higher standards for what is valuable, truly unique, and feasible to accomplish within a given period of time. The sequel to this article attempts to summarize all of these other concerns, building on the evidence and logical arguments presented in this first part to more robustly answer the tantalizing question behind AI’s impact on creativity. Importantly, this second installment will underscore the necessity to shift our focus. The imminent issue may not be a potential dwindling of our ingenuity, but rather a constellation of critical factors surrounding the perception and common understanding regarding what it takes to co-create ideas, processes, or products with AI that are truly novel and useful. There's also a pressing need to consider the protective measures extended to workers who are at the interface of AI's influence. For instance, while AI may not necessarily stifle overall creativity, it holds the potential to extinguish the arts if considerations around the valuation of artistic capabilities and the protection of artists' intellectual property are not meticulously examined. These will all be touched upon in the sequel of this two-part article series (see "The AI Creative Renaissance: the Impact of Co-Creating with AI on Creativity and the Future of Work").

References

[1] Teresa M. Amabile et al., Affect and Creativity at Work, Administrative Science Quarterly 50, no. 3 (September 1, 2005): 367–403, https://doi.org/10.2189/asqu.2005.50.3.367.

[2]  Teresa M. Amabile, The Social Psychology of Creativity: A Componential Conceptualization., Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 45, no. 2 (August 1983): 357–76, https://doi.org/10.1037/0022-3514.45.2.357.

[3]  Spencer Harrison et al., The Turn toward Creative Work, Academy of Management Collections 1, no. 1 (August 4, 2022), https://doi.org/10.5465/amc.2021.0003.

[4]  Richard Florida and Jim Goodnight, Managing for Creativity, Harvard Business Review, July 1, 2005, https://hbr.org/2005/07/managing-for-creativity.

[5]  Martin Reeves and Mike Deimler, Adaptability: The New Competitive Advantage, Harvard Business Review, July 1, 2011, https://hbr.org/2011/07/adaptability-the-new-competitive-advantage.

[6] content requires Twitter account to view.

Founded in 2020 by ESSEC Business School, The Institute for AI and Business for Artificial Intelligence, Data and Society helps organizations navigate and better understand the social, economic, cultural, and ethical impacts of AI and data

metalab@essec.edu

Learn more about the Institute for AI and Business

copyright © 2026 Institute for AI and Business

↓
Résumé de la politique de confidentialité

Ce site utilise des cookies afin que nous puissions vous fournir la meilleure expérience utilisateur possible. Les informations sur les cookies sont stockées dans votre navigateur et remplissent des fonctions telles que vous reconnaître lorsque vous revenez sur notre site Web et aider notre équipe à comprendre les sections du site que vous trouvez les plus intéressantes et utiles.