Mis en avant
[Student IDEAS] by Amir Khan - Master in Finance at ESSEC Business School
This article will look into the origin of the Green Movement and the definition of Greenwashing along with its prevalence, what it entails for consumers & investors, and the current legislative actions in this regard. Post establishing the significance of this challenge, the article will explore Blockchain technology as a potential solution. It will touch upon some of the current projects and critically evaluate them as well as the larger use case in an attempt to map its key challenges and growth trajectory.
---
When you purchase a box of that cereal or ground coffee that you need to start your mornings, have you ever found yourself wondering about what exactly the manufacturer will do with the money it is making from the sale? Besides producing more of the same stuff you’ve come to love, of course. This food for thought has been catching traction with consumers and investors alike, bringing the cryptic answers out of the explanatory notes of complex financial statements into mainstream attention. The bottom-line is that in a world facing several inter-related environmental crises, which are quickly turning irreversible, people don’t want to give their money to companies that are a part of the problem. This attitude is personified in the environmental movement.
Concern for the impact on human life from air and water pollution goes back to at least the Roman times. This concern also arose between the late 14th century and the mid-16th century in wider Europe when pollution was being associated with the spread of epidemics. However, the modern environmental movement began much later in late-19th century. It was based around concern to protect the countryside in Europe and the wilderness in the United States, as well as the health effects of pollution caused by the Industrial Revolution. This was also the time that the Sierra Club was founded (1892). It was finally in the 1960s that these philosophical and social strands of environmentalism – among various others – were given political expression through the establishment of the “green” political movement. This movement aims to protect planet Earth from harmful environmental practices and maintain sustainable living standards. Since the 1980s, climate change has become a primary concern of the green movement among other concerns like organic agriculture, pollution reduction, preservation of forested lands and endangered species, and opposition to nuclear power.
A crucial facet of this movement is green consumerism. Also known as sustainable consumerism, this is the practice of making purchasing decisions in a way that minimizes environmental impact and supports sustainable products and practices. This is based on the belief that individual choices can contribute to positive environmental change, encouraging consumers to be more mindful of the environmental consequences of their consumption habits.
Beyond consumerism, another key facet is green investing. This is an investment ideology that seeks to support business practices that have a favorable impact on the environment. Often grouped with socially responsible investing (SRI), green investments target companies and projects focused on sustainable development and preservation of the environment.
However, it is a mistake to believe that all green consumption & investment till date has actually been aligned with environmental interests and this is because of the widespread problem of greenwashing.
How does a fund end up carrying an AA or AAA ESG rating while having close to 70% of its revenues being derived from environmentally harmful activities?1 The answer is greenwashing. The term “greenwashing” was coined by prominent environmentalist Jay Westerveld in a 1986 essay targeting the hotel industry's practice of promoting the reuse of towels as part of a broader environmental strategy; when, in fact, the move was primarily a cost-saving measure. Such practices have been undertaken by numerous corporations and projects, over the decades, to mislead consumers and investors to believe that their products, aims, and policies are ESG oriented.
More recently, in January 2021, the European Commission and national consumer authorities released the results of a screening of websites focused on greenwashing to identify breaches of EU consumer law in online markets; reporting that there is reason to believe that in 42% of cases the claims were exaggerated, false or deceptive and could potentially qualify as unfair commercial practices under EU rules2.
Even more recently, in March 2023, MSCI Inc. announced that it will lower its ESG ratings for around 31,000 funds, a change that will mean only 0.2% of funds will have a AAA rating moving forward compared to the current 20%.[1] This move comes as ESG rating providers have continually drawn criticism for using inconsistent rating methodologies that are yet to be properly regulated, creating room for greenwashing.
Therefore, with nearly half the sustainability claims made by companies online in Europe being misleading and close to one-fifth of ESG funds having been rated higher than they actually stand, this problem is bigger than ever.
Even in daily life, not falling for greenwashing has become akin to picking your way through a minefield. A classic example of greenwashing, now referred to as “Emissionsgate”, is when Volkswagen was found cheating emissions tests by fitting its vehicles with a “defect” device, with a software that detected when it was undergoing an emissions test and altered its performance to reduce its emissions level. So, while the company was advertising the low-emissions and eco-friendly features of its vehicles; in reality, millions of their cars were emitting up to 40 times the allowed limit for nitrogen oxide pollutants. This went on from 2009 to 2015 till Volkswagen was caught.4
Fossil fuel giants like BP widely take up advertising tactics that focus on their work on low-carbon energy solutions while oil and gas make almost the entirety of their cost allocations and revenue sources.5 Elsewhere, FMCG (Fast Moving Consumer Goods) giants focus heavily on marketing to bury down news like Nestlé, Coca-Cola, and PepsiCo being named the world’s top plastic polluters for the 3rd year in a row in Break Free From Plastic’s 2020 annual report.6
Different parts of the world are making progress in environmental legislation at different paces based on their respective socio-economic and political situations, but the ball is definitely rolling when it comes to legislation for sustainability reporting in 2023.
The European Commission, the EU’s executive arm, is planning to release new industry rules in the first half of 2023. The organization has published its “Green Claims Directive”, which is subject to the approval of the European Parliament and Council before it comes into force. The new measures are designed to prevent companies from making unsubstantiated environmental claims about their products and services, warning that they could soon face penalties of at least 4% of their annual revenue for “greenwashing.”7
Meanwhile the UK is planning to table the “Digital Markets, Competition and Consumer Bill”, under which large companies face the threat of civil penalties of up to 10% of their global turnover for breaching consumer law, which will also cover misleading environmental claims.8 The British prime minister, Rishi Sunak, has called the passing of this new bill a “priority” for his government. On the investing front, the UK has launched a consultation on the extent to which ESG raters need to be reined in by clear rules.
Across the Atlantic, the US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) issued two new sets of proposed rules in 2022: “Investment Company Names” (“Names Rule”) and “Environmental, Social, and Governance Disclosures for Investment Advisers and Investment Companies” (“ESG Disclosure Rule”). Combined, these two proposed rules are meant to combat greenwashing. They dictate that only funds with an ESG purpose will be permitted to label or indicate themselves as ESG, and a new mandatory disclosure for these ESG-focused funds will allow outside parties to ensure whether such purportedly ESG-focused funds are following their stated investment purpose.
In May 2022, Tesla was removed from Standard & Poor’s (S&P) 500 ESG Index, which continued to retain Exxon Mobil. This means that the index, which tracks companies based on S&P’s own sustainability standards, considers the fossil fuel major to have better overall sustainability credentials than the EV giant. However, on the other hand, research by Institute for Energy Economics and Financial Analysis (IEEFA) shows that this view may not be shared by other rating providers.9 This is because the disparity in outcomes of ESG ratings between providers suffers from “the lack of unified objectives and standards for ESG measurements, disclosures and methodologies.” The subjective nature of these ratings makes them incomparable and difficult for green investors to use in decision making. In fact, green investing still faces the fundamental problem of a lack of globally accepted definitions and standards on what actions constitute the fair usage of terms like ‘Conscious’, ‘Eco-friendly’ and ‘Zero Environmental Footprint’ among others in public claims.
On the sustainability reporting end, while the initial approach has been orientated towards traditional financial auditing, there are significant issues in this approach to reporting and auditing environmental data. Sustainability reporting encompasses a wide range of qualitative and quantitative data, including environmental impact, supply-chain wastage, and corporate governance practices; factors that are often complex and subjective. This makes it challenging for traditional auditing approaches, which primarily focus on financial metrics, to capture and evaluate the full scope of environmental performance.
ESG metrics data is gathered from various internal and external sources, including self-reported information, 3rd party assessments, and industry benchmarks. Ensuring that this data is comprehensive while also being accurate and reliable is beyond the scope of traditional auditing practices. This is because traditional auditing relies on robust internal control systems and verifiable financial records, whereas sustainability data tends to be more decentralized and subjective, making it easier to manipulate.
When dealing with high volumes of data that has such a wide qualitative and quantitative range, being collected from sources which in turn are dispersed and diverse, it is natural to question the accuracy of the reports being created based on the same. It is in this critical role of reliable and transparent data management that blockchain can be leveraged.
Blockchain is a decentralized, distributed, and public digital ledger that is used to record transactions in batches called blocks. The ledger is stored across many computers so that the record cannot be altered without the alteration of all subsequent blocks and the consensus of the network. Because of this, blockchain is ideal for storing shared information since it provides a de-facto immutable and decentralized record. A blockchain network can track many metrics and with all network members sharing a single view of the data, the technology offers greater confidence in the data reported.
In terms of greenwashing, blockchain can minimize the possibility of data manipulation of the collected data points, in the process creating a transparent data pipeline for accurate sustainability reporting. A prospective structure of such a process for reporting to stakeholders can be as follows:
Automated data collection through technological tools not only reduces the related cost of labor but also helps reduce the possibility of errors and manipulation in the data. A real-time data feed can be developed by combining environmental and/or supply chain data collected from satellite-based sensors, power smart meters, web scraping, imaging drones and IoT sensors.
Blockchain technology’s role in transparent sustainability reporting is through its ability to provide immutable certification and automated reporting of data points related to an organization’s ESG metrics data. By using this, manufacturers can track and trace products and labor conditions along their supply chains, storing these findings on the blockchain alongside their other metrics. By integrating data from their vendors and suppliers, companies can measure every relevant metric using a uniform mechanism. All the information would be immutable and remain on-chain, therefore, ensuring that it is free of any manipulation once it has entered the blockchain.
The unalterable record of sustainability data on the blockchain can then be shared in a transparent and efficient manner. Smart contracts are a great way to do this; these are digital, immutable, and automated contracts on a blockchain in which the contracts’ rules and execution instructions are written directly into self-executing code. Smart contracts can be used to automatically disclose ESG information either in real-time or based on a preset schedule to the public or regulators. Since human supervision is not required, errors are minimal, and the authenticity of the data is ensured.
While immutability of data is ensured by the blockchain network, we face a similar limitation of garbage in, garbage out as we do with other technologies. Rigged meters or sensors becoming faulty over time are very real possibilities and can hamper the accuracy of data, a serious concern when said data becomes immutable. This point of fragility, termed the “Oracle Problem” can be strengthened by incorporating solutions like decentralized oracle. Decentralized oracles act as public libraries with multiple sources of information, through these multiple data sources they minimize counterparty risk and transfer on-chain the most accurate data available. Over time, the ability of these decentralized oracles improves through “learnings” by penalizing individual oracles that provide inaccurate data.
Application of blockchain to counter greenwashing is an area of discussion that has been ongoing for the past few years and has relatively recently started giving rise to its first implementation projects. Here we look at some of the solutions currently being scaled:
One of the Big 4 accounting firms, EY is looking to offer carbon traceability and carbon credit services with the launch of EY OpsChain ESG by leveraging blockchain technology. Carbon traceability is the ability of an organization to trace its own carbon footprint, and carbon credit – also known as carbon offset – is a reduction or removal of emissions of carbon dioxide to compensate for emissions made by an enterprise.
This new solution is based on the EY Blockchain SaaS platform. It offers a single and verifiable view of CO2 emissions to help organizations accurately measure and track their carbon footprint, offering enough granularity for enterprises to be able to link their carbon output to specific product output. The platform is developed on the Ethereum blockchain and is independently verifiable by using key emissions data validators.
This product offering has been introduced in May 2023 under the leadership of Paul Brody, EY Global Blockchain Leader and is managed by Sam Azad, EY OpsChain ESG Product Owner. Their team has developed this platform based on the standards for Carbon Emissions Tokens published by the Sustainability Business Working Group of InterWork Alliance.
Provenance is an early-stage startup founded in 2014 that has developed a blockchain-based data platform designed to offer open and accessible information about products and supply chains. Founded by Jessi Baker who currently acts as CEO, Provenance is headquartered in London and is working with 200+ beauty and cosmetics brands across D2C and retail partners in USA, UK, and the EU.
The startup offers digital verification for sustainability claims such as ‘Reduced Carbon Footprint’, ‘Fully Recycled Packaging’ and ‘Upcycled Ingredients’ as well as 3rd party certifications like Fairtrade and Leaping Bunny Cruelty-Free. Currently, Provenance offers verification for close to 90 claims, divided into 5 categories: climate, waste, nature, workers, and communities. These claims are displayed as ‘Proof Points’ that offer deeper information to consumers.
This entire platform is powered by blockchain. Phil Verey, Managing Director at Provenance explains “The way we use blockchain at Provenance is really just to provide a secure, immutable and transparent way of logging claims, make sure they are fact-checked, that they have the right evidence and making sure those claims are then accessible to anyone who wants to see them”.
Provenance’s aim is to create a future where shoppers make purchases based on verified information instead of blind trust on ESG claims. Going further, the company is even exploring the potential of taking their project to an ingredients level of transparency for the cosmetics industry.
Empower is an early-stage startup founded in 2018 by Wilhelm Myrer (CEO), Carl Nesset (COO) and Gjermund Bjaanes (CTO) that combines plastic recycling and blockchain to create a sustainable circular economy platform that ensures zero greenwashing. The Norwegian startup aims to extend Norway’s incredibly efficient national plastic exchange system (that recycles 97% of all plastic bottles) to a global scale.
Empower uses blockchain for every step of the process starting from collecting plastic at the source through the sorting process to its eventual recycling and reintegration back into the supply chain. The use of blockchain doesn’t just allow each step in the process to be fully verifiable with incorruptible documentation but also allows for seamless tracking and monetization of plastic - even in 3rd world countries where a large part of the population is unbanked.
By tracking every aspect of the journey, from on-the-ground plastic pickup operations to eventual reuse in other products, the level of transparency negates any chances of greenwashing and that is attractive to companies, plastic processors, and consumers. This increases the value of the waste plastic collected, turning plastic collection into a viable earning activity for the world’s underprivileged populations.

Treejer is a seed stage startup founded in 2021 that connects sponsors to rural planters worldwide. It is a “A unique borderless approach in Climate Action powered by blockchain technology.” Treejer creates a link between those who fund trees and those who plant them even in the most remote parts of the world. The platform uses smart contracts to record credit ownership and enables secure payment between different parties.
Founded by a team of 6 people in Iran, the CEO of this fledgling project is Ermia Saharkhiz. Over the last 12 months, the team has launched the Treejer Protocol on Polygon, a public and eco-friendly blockchain. This enables anyone anywhere to fund and plant forests using Treejer’s apps. Donors use a web interface to fund planting of trees and expand their forests online while rural planters use the app to get onboarded, submit planted trees, and receive support for their contributions.
The whole process takes place through direct crypto payments enabled by Treejer’s smart contracts on the blockchain. These smart contracts receive, store and release payments based on predefined terms. The planters are provided with user-friendly and non-custodial crypto wallets to receive their conservation rewards without bank accounts. In this way, Treejer unlocks new opportunities to support unbanked local communities around the world by creating reliable monetary incentives for planting trees.

Application of blockchain in sustainability reporting has gathered significant steam in the last few years through numerous initiatives and startups. The projects covered in this article have made great strides as well in the past couple of years. Provenance has established its presence in Europe, North America, and Asia Pacific; partnered with Douglas, a sizeable European e-commerce platform for beauty and health; and closed a $5m funding round led by Working Capital Innovation Fund and Nordic Eye. Empower has launched EmpowerChain, a blockchain network that provides tools, infrastructure, and incentives needed for the circular economy to work; developed the Empower Product Passport in collaboration with EY Doberman; and recycled 32mn kg of plastic till date. Treejer was selected for the 2021 UNICEF Venture Fund cohort, successfully ending up as one of the 5 joiners to graduate from the fund in September 2022; and is making deep inroads into Africa and Latin America through several strategic partnerships. EY’s OpsChain ESG platform launched a few months ago is already onboarding prospective clients onto its beta version and plans to leverage EY’s global reach to take this platform far and wide.
However, at the same time, the path forward to scaling these solutions globally faces several challenges that need to be overcome, such as:
These challenges signify the necessity for a systematic scaling up of the projects leveraging this use case of blockchain. Even so there is significant support available to these projects coming from the increasing importance of environmental sustainability in today’s times. Bloomberg's “Sustainable Future Study”, sponsored by Mubadala estimates the valuation of ESG assets to hit $50 trillion as soon as 2025, this represents more than a third of the projected $140.5 trillion in total global assets under management. This boom in funding is coupled with changing attitudes in the corporate world with a resounding 71% of global business leaders believing that, “Eventually, no investment decisions will be made without considering ESG.”
Most of the startups in this area are still at Seed to Series A stage; therefore, funding is going to be a key requisite for these enterprises to scale. On that end, McKinsey reports positive findings: “Climate investing experienced a period of breakout growth in capital formation over the past four years. From 2019 until the end of 2022, private-market equity investors launched more than 330 new sustainability; environmental, social, and governance (ESG); and impact funds. The cumulative assets under management in these funds grew threefold, from $90 billion to more than $270 billion.” In this rapid growth of private market investment, the public sector will also be a significant investor. The US Inflation Reduction Act (IRA), passed in 2022 has allocated more than $370 billion in funding for climate change mitigation, while the EU Green Deal can potentially dedicate upwards of €1 trillion in public and private funds. As a result, while these businesses will have to earn their valuation in a tough fundraising market, there is enough dry powder with VCs and other investors to fund these projects.
However, a key challenge also exists on the demand side. Companies must feel the need to incorporate these solutions in their sustainability reporting, something they might be averse to especially if these solutions disclose greenwashing that is covering practices and emissions earning them billions. Essentially, it is the ESG equivalent of a financial audit, and auditors aren’t exactly the best friends of the management. Therefore, mass scale adoption of these solutions on a voluntary basis can end up being very gradual, based on consumer pressure and increased ethical enlightenment among management circles. To circumvent this issue government involvement in terms of legislation is crucial. The pertinent question here being “Does mandating sustainability reporting make a real difference if measures to avoid greenwashing are not mandated as well?”
Several startups have developed scalable solutions applying blockchain technology to eliminate bias from environmental claims and reports. Their growth is tied to the growth of the larger ESG industry and government regulations will play a key role in the same. Within climate-tech, the number of unicorns has not only been rapidly expanding, but the age of new unicorns is also compressing. Close to 60% of the climate-tech unicorns in 2021 reached the $1B valuation mark in less than 7 years. However, startups founded after 2017 have consistently grown into unicorns in 4 or less years, notably making up 40% (approx.) of the prominent 2021 climate-tech unicorn cohort. Based on the funding and valuations trajectory that has stayed strong for climate-tech even after economic headwinds of 2022, the next 7-10 years will see these blockchain-based startups scaling up, turning into unicorns and hopefully – with the help of regulators – counting manufacturing, automotive, aviation, and energy behemoths of the Fortune 500 as their clients. This will finally bring about meaningful change in the trust consumers and investors place in sustainability reporting and who knows, we might save the planet after all.
[1] White, N., & Schwartzkopff, F. (2023, March 30). Over 30,000 Funds to Get Their ESG Ratings Downgraded at MSCI. (Bloomberg).
[2] Press release. (2021, January 28). Screening of websites for ‘greenwashing': half of green claims lack evidence. (European Commission).
[3] White, N., & Schwartzkopff, F. (2023, March 30). Over 30,000 Funds to Get Their ESG Ratings Downgraded at MSCI. (Bloomberg).
[4] Robinson, D. (2022, July 17). 10 Companies Called Out For Greenwashing. (Earth.org).
[1] Robinson, D. (2022, July 17). 10 Companies Called Out For Greenwashing. (Earth.org). [1] Robinson, D. (2022, July 17). 10 Companies Called Out For Greenwashing. (Earth.org).
[5] Ibid.
[6] Ibid.
[7] Meredit, S. (2023, March 24). A ‘greenwashing’ crackdown in Europe hasn’t gone down well. (CNBC).
[8] Ungoed-Thomas, J. (2023, February 19). ‘Greenwashing’ firms face steep new UK fines for misleading claims. (The Guardian).
[Student IDEAS] by Paul Bédier - Master in Data Sciences & Business Analytics at ESSEC Business School & CentraleSupélec
The article aims to provide the reader with a better understanding of Central Bank Digital Currencies by giving them the required background to critically assess their usefulness and stakes. We explore the motivations behind these new projects, delve into the issue of public-private money balance seating at the core of their genesis, and provide different perspectives on possible implementations. Our view is that central banks should strive to chart cautious yet efficient paths towards CBDC.
---
CBDC: the new 4-letter acronym that will no doubt be the subject of heated disagreements for the years to come. It stands for “Central Bank Digital Currency.” For the average reader, the central bank rhymes with monetary policy and interest rates while digital currency would be associated with fintech companies and the crypto sphere. Confused? Let us attempt to clear the haze surrounding the buzz and jargon.
First, think about digital currency for a minute. Most people should be aware that an overwhelming majority of money already sits on digital ledgers: bank accounts. It is through a game of accounting entries that transactions are carried out. Tangible money like coins or bills is estimated to account for only 3 to 8%1 of the world money supply (with variations among countries). Why then do we keep hearing about digital currency as if it were this great transition we are on the verge of?
The answer is simple: central banks have been ramping up the communication about their Digital Currency projects, hence we are increasingly hearing about it. As of 2023, 130 countries2 (representing 98% of world GDP) are in the process of evaluating the launch of CBDC projects. Eleven countries have already launched theirs. What are these projects about? They can take different forms, but all revolve around the idea of transforming centrally issued banknotes and coins in a digital format and making them accessible to the public for transactions at its most basic level, or for savings and other financial operations at a more advanced level.
Here you might stop and say: “well how is that any revolution? I already have a bank account with digital money inside it and I use my credit card instead of bills to settle transactions”. It is indeed a subtle but undeniable revolution. The main distinction between what we have now and CBDCs is the same distinction that has always existed between private and public. The digital money you currently use through your credit card is issued by a private bank, while CBDCs would be issued by the central bank just like banknotes and coins. So, the definition of CBDC is simply the following: “A Central Bank Digital Currency is the digital form of a country’s fiat currency.”
After this explanation, you may feel a bit underwhelmed. We will simply have digital banknotes and coins now, why not. Does an old idea already materialized in our world really warrant a brand-new acronym?
Yes, it does, because the distinction raised above between private and public money is critical. Indeed, CBDCs are groundbreaking for two main reasons. First, the motivations behind them are numerous and diverse, and find their roots in questions of economic stability, financial efficiency, international geopolitics, and even sociopolitical objectives. Second, their mere implementation has the potential to be a can of worms and may compromise the financial stability they are meant to help with. By their nature of being digital currencies, they will intrinsically carry with them the potential for many advanced functions, through their programmability for instance, which might enter in direct competition with the private financial - and technological - sector. We will see that for these reasons, different countries have different plans for CBDCs.
Now comes the question we will strive to address in this article. Will CBDCs be useful to society? Are they necessary? The answer is not straightforward. Let us dig into this!
The idea of CBDC certainly is not new, and one tentative attempt at identifying its original author attributes it to Nobel laureate James Tobin3 who in 1987 already advocated for a public payment “medium with the convenience of deposits and the safety of currency”. Ignored for a long time, the proposal regained traction in the recent years, with central bank and public officials warming to it as a solution to rising issues: the decline of cash, exacerbated during the COVID crisis, and the relative spread outside of the traditional monetary system of cryptocurrencies like Bitcoin or, perhaps even more concerning, stable coins backed by tech giants such as Libra (Diem).
On paper, motivations behind launching a CBDC could come from a genuine objective to better society and improve financial services. One of its most noble impacts would be to provide each citizen with a universal bank account at the country’s central bank, bringing basic and low-cost banking services to all. The positive repercussions of such a move, especially in developing countries with high unbanked rates, could be staggering.
Furthermore, CBDCs would bring with them a number of technological innovations, pushing efficiency upward for both individuals and businesses. Most of these innovations already exist, propelled by fintech companies, but they would take an even wider scale within the fiat currency infrastructure provided by central banks. With intermediaries such as commercial banks or clearing houses eliminated, real-time payments and settlements could take place, thus reducing financial risk, complexity and in turn lowering transaction costs. Proof of transaction in the form of a digital record located either on a distributed ledger (yet still centrally controlled) or a centralized database would foster trust and transparency in the financial system, making it more difficult for conflicts to arise and for fraudulent activities to take place. Finally, CBDCs would allow for easier programmability and bring with them a large number of beneficial features for the financial system. The best and most famous example is with smart contracts, which can be automatically settled and remove much of the counterparty risk usually involved in transactions.
Another motivation for CBDCs, and one that should please proponents of the neoclassical school of economics, is the heightened competition between private banks that would ensue a CBDC launch, as they would need to offer better services and interest rates to their customers for fear of losing them to the central bank. Now, this is a hot-issue topic and there is dissent among both central banks and public officials as some fear this could backfire. Indeed, they argue that by eroding the banking sector’s profitability and encouraging financial disintermediation, the consequences for the economy at large in terms of efficiency and innovation could be detrimental. Let us delve more into this issue later in the article.
Central banks have clear motivations behind CBDCs, which boil down to reaffirming their authority over money. Indeed, while they used to be fine relinquishing money issuance activities to private banks as long as it meant they could focus on monetary policy through their direct and indirect control - required reserves, policy rates, open market operations to name the main tools at the central bank’s disposal. In fact, this proved quite successful all things considered, as the commercial banks could compete with one another and innovate to win over customers, while the central banks essentially outsourced financial intermediation and credit issuance activities. The decline of cash - public money - to a baseline level was merely an accepted consequence.
However, this system is now being challenged from different sides with the spread of alternatives to fiat money: cryptocurrencies and stable coins. The former, coming from society’s underground, is a threat to the central bank’s authority and control over monetary policy and in their eyes a source of volatility arising from unregulated speculation and therefore a risk to global financial stability. However, cryptocurrency adoption remains low and its viability as a fiat money alternative is very debatable, as explored in the previous article of this series. The latter, coming from tech giants and the fintech industry, has the potential to become an even larger threat to central banks by short circuiting the established financial system. Finally, cash decline could now turn into full-fledged cash disappearance after the fintech industry filled the holes created by the COVID crisis, leaving our societies entirely reliant on private forms of money.
CBDCs could be the answer central banks are looking for, as they would intrinsically bring back public money in the economy, reaffirm their authority over the monetary system and even grant them new vectors of monetary policy. For the latter, this could simply take the form of direct transfers to the public with public money issuance, or so-called “helicopter money.” More refined approaches could involve programmability of money, say implementing expiration dates which would spur spendings and discourage savings – something that was assessed by China in their pilot program in Shenzhen. Finally, CBDCs could help central banks enhance financial stability by offering an alternative to fractional reserve banking and thus limiting the risk and impact of bank runs, and by avoiding a potential flight to unregulated and volatile cryptocurrencies or stable coins.
Now, of course the claim central bank’s authority was eroding to start with should be nuanced. In the last decade, institutions like the Federal Reserve of the United States of America (“Fed”), the European Central Bank (“ECB”), Bank of England, People’s Bank of China (“PBoC”), and many more have unleashed massive quantitative easing programs in the wake of the 2008 market crash, overflowing the market with liquidities in support of their respective economies. Recently, most of them have started a series of policy rate hikes to fight inflation caused by COVID crisis recovery and the Russian-Ukraine war supply shock. This would tend to show central banks are still very much in control of the monetary system and that their authority over the matter was not threatened quite as much as previously implied.
However, much can be told from how the central bank’s own stance on the matter shifted at the turn of the COVID crisis. Indeed, up to 2020, the consensus towards CBDCs was still fairly negative, or at least erring on the side of high caution. Now, the tone is a lot more positive, with central banks eager to communicate on their CBDC projects and deliberations. This is primarily the result from a better understanding of the impact of digital currency’s implementation on the existing financial system, and how it could be mitigated. But this is also due to renewed interest as central banks now would not reject an increase in the scope of their policies nor access to additional tools. Especially when economists are increasingly pointing out the risk of a decoupling between traditional monetary policy and the real economy.
Sovereign states presumably act in their citizen’s interest and thus would be aligned with all the motivations listed above for individuals, businesses, and central banks. But they also have specific interests in the launch of Central Bank Digital Currencies. A domain in which they could be helpful to the state is the fight against illicit activities. Indeed, a digital repository theoretically makes them able to keep track of the exact location of each monetary unit of the currency. This could have repercussions for tax collection, making evasion more difficult through means of offshore banking or unreported employment via underground economies. It also makes it easier to spot criminal activities, track money laundering and reverse fraudulent transactions. Of course, all these benefits depend on the type of implementation chosen by the central bank, the amount of transparency in the system and the status of cash in the new system.
Another game is however at play here, with states fighting in the realm of geopolitics and international competition. Indeed, like any significant technological breakthrough – nuclear weapons, advanced semiconductor chips, artificial intelligence, the potential cost of not developing it may be too high and countries will get caught up in the infamous prisoner’s dilemma. You might ask: “what are the risks in the case of CBDCs, they appear harmless enough.” But this would be discounting the scale and significance of economic warfare. One of the risks to a country is simply to get overrun by the financial innovations provided by the CBDC of another country. This could manifest in increased capital flights, with investors flocking to the other country’s financial markets to benefit from increased efficiency and additional features, as well as individuals using the foreign CBDC as a safe asset. This in turn would have direct detrimental consequences on the economy, as the central bank would need to adjust policy rates in ways which might adversely affect the economy.
The highest and most critical risk waiting at the end of this path is an outright currency substitution. You may have heard of the concept of “dollarization.” which occurs when a country’s citizens partially or fully rely on a foreign currency (historically it often was the dollar, hence the term). Of course, this can have catastrophic consequences for sovereignty and economic independence, something that most countries want to preserve against. But even the simple erosion of a country’s monetary influence on the world can be perceived as a nightmare for said country. Imagine a world where the USA loses the dollar as the most influential currency and can no longer use it to write the rules of international trade (USD is currently estimated to represent 90% of total foreign exchange volume).4 CBDCs, with their highly efficient cross-border transaction settlement potential could displace the USD from this historic role. It does not take long to see how the US government might fight against this and feel obligated to pursue CBDC developments as a hedge against this risk. Consider also how China is part of the five countries who launched their CBDC pilot programs, while the US remains at preliminary research and deliberations, and you might sense uneasiness.5
Now that we have outlined the main motivations at play here, let us delve a bit deeper into the potential implementation of CBDCs and how they must find a difficult balance.
Central banks are great contenders for the title of most impressive magician out there. Not because they seemingly create money out of thin air or make it disappear just as easily, although that is certainly a neat trick. No, it is because they have created and maintained one of the longest running illusions in the history of humanity, on a wide scale. What is this illusion? We may call it the “illusion of one money.” Ask yourself, is there any significant difference between the currency you hold in your wallet and the one you hold in your bank account? If your answer is no, then you were successfully tricked. Indeed, as we have touched upon in the introduction, the former is public money issued by the central bank, while the latter is private money issued by a commercial bank. This subtlety is critical, as it stands at the core of the existing financial system.
How do central banks manage this? By their role as a “lender of last resort,” they guarantee immediate convertibility of private banks deposits into fiat – public – money. In essence, we collectively place our trust in this state institution and the result is that we can benefit from the private banking industry’s services on a scale that the central bank would not be able to offer on its own. To the point where, in stable countries, we barely ponder the difference. Reality only comes back to hit us in the case of a bankruptcy, with the infamous bank run scenarios. A good analogy, although slightly provocative, is the casino one. Depositing your money at a commercial bank is like entering a casino and exchanging your money against chips.6 These chips are a form of “I owe you,” legal tenders for any transaction inside the casino and ones that bind the casino to exchange them back to you for currency.
However, if you go outside and try to pay for your groceries with your chips, you will likely raise an eyebrow. The illusion of one money is broken. In the case of the banking system, interconnection between banks helps maintain the illusion further, allowing us to use our “private chips” almost anywhere. These interconnections are made possible by clearing house systems, on which a digital form of public money is automatically and periodically compensated, balancing out overall private bank accounts through required reserves.
Now is the time to introduce the distinction between wholesale and retail CBDC. The former is an evolution of the process described above. The central bank issues a digital currency, which private banks hold and can use to settle with one another in real time. As such, interbank transfers could become much faster than they are today. A wholesale CBDC would also facilitate cross-border transactions. Today, the public form of money that banks exchange is already remarkably close to what a wholesale CBDC would be, minus the technology allowing for instantaneous settlements. Retail CBDC on another hand is a much more significant project to grant access to digital public money to the general public and is what we have been describing in this article so far. Note that hybrid projects exist, which would work to implement both in one package.
To better understand the fragile balance between public and private forms of money, one must be aware of the money creation process. Today’s banking system is organized as “fractional reserve banking.” This means that commercial banks, as credit institutions, have near free reign to create money out of thin air by crediting your accounts. This is a loan, or debt instrument, and is how the money supply is expanded. Of course, loans should eventually be repaid, and banks want to make a profit through interests. This means that lending money to individuals or businesses involves credit analysis and due diligence over the borrower’s solvency. Furthermore, banks do not have completely free reign over lending, as they are required to hold reserves at the central bank. This consists of a fraction of their deposits, hence fractional reserve banking. The role of central banks is to control the money supply through different instruments, required reserves ratios being one. This has an impact on the dynamics of the economy – supply expansion, or heightened lending activities, will stimulate investments and GDP growth, while supply contraction might harm the economy but will exercise downward pressure on inflation rates.
Private banks thus play the role of the intermediary in the system, managing deposits and granting loans, on a scale that the central bank would not be able to sustain. Of course, they do not do this out of benevolence, but profit seeking (or return objectives in the case of credit unions). This system promotes competition between banks, which in theory is beneficial to customers through lower interest rates and better financial services. Financial innovation is also fostered, leading to more efficient payment and transaction settlement schemes. The convenience of using these payment schemes has pushed back the use of cash. In recent years, new entrants have progressively challenged the traditional banking landscape, mostly coming from the tech industry with both large companies – think Google and Apple – and smaller “fintech” startups – think neo banks, international transfer, decentralized finance. This is further eroding cash use, and leads central banks to worry as, compared to banks, they do not yet have a large regulatory apparatus for tech companies. In a sense, today the balance already weighs heavily in favor of private forms of money.
By issuing CBDCs, central banks would attempt to rebalance the scale and have public money play a renewed and strengthened role in the economy. The right equilibrium is however hard to pinpoint. A significant risk which made most central banks frisky about CBDCs for years was that CBDCs would lead to the uncontrolled disintermediation of the system. Because of the potential attractiveness of central deposits to the public due to factors like safety, liquidity and solvability, the launch of CBDCs could turn people away from commercial banks, deteriorating their balance sheet and causing the risk of bank runs. Such a disintermediation would also be catastrophic for the economy, as the activity is fueled by investments made possible by loans. This might sound overly apocalyptic, as there is reason to believe an introduction of CBDC would not substitute commercial bank’s deposits overnight. After all, many less financially literate people would have trouble seeing the difference and the benefits of switching. Nevertheless, central banks considered this a serious enough issue to pull the brakes on CBDCs and launch in-depth review programs and impact studies. The critical point is that even if a large-scale bank run is avoided, even a slow but steady disintermediation of the financial system could be detrimental.
Reaching the right equilibrium will be a crucial element in the choice of CBDC deployed. Wholesale CBDCs present no risk, being a simple evolution of the current interbank system. Retail CBDCs present a higher risk and warrant more caution. In recent years, central banks task forces have examined hybrid infrastructure which promises to solve this problem if well calibrated. Restrictions on deposits and CBDC programmability could be used to keep the private banking sector attractive and mitigate the disintermediation risk. To conclude, the main approach should be caution, something that central banks understand well. In a report by the Bank for International Settlements co-authored by seven major central banks published in 2020, they outlined a Hippocratic Oath for CBDC: “First, do no harm”.7
Now that we have explored the motivations and explained the challenges, we have the required ingredients to answer our original question: “will CBDC be useful?”
Usefulness, like beauty, is in the eye of the beholder.
While individuals should be excited at the prospect of increased efficiency, better stability, and new financial services, many argue the cons outweigh the pros. Retail CBDCs are seen as yet another intrusion of the state into people’s lives. Indeed, the aim of every CBDC project is a centralized currency, even those that will use distributed ledger technology for efficiency, meaning the central bank will always have full control over the network. This gives a large amount of power to the state via the central bank to add or remove money from accounts. More concerning and realistic for non-corrupt states, the risk of cyberattacks with hackers taking control of the central authority and using it to modify accounts should not be thrown aside too quickly.
Privacy concerns are obviously also a significant issue for many individuals. If the CBDC implementation gives full visibility over financial transactions and records to the state, which people argue is likely even if central banks include privacy walls into the system, everyone is at risk of seeing their financial data used beyond their consent. In a more extreme case, a full-fledged surveillance state could develop, monitoring its citizens’ transactions and enforcing limitations on certain activities via the programmability of the CBDC e.g., prohibiting purchase of alcohol on weekdays or donations to politically opposed NGOs. These are valid concerns and would resonate well with the quote “technological progress has merely provided us with more efficient means for going backwards” from Aldous Huxley,8 writer of the famous Brave New World dystopian novel. We let it up to the reader to assess the likelihood of this risk. Central banks will certainly need to balance the safeguarding of privacy rights and the transparency necessary to deter criminal activity. In any case, it seems the usefulness of CBDCs to the public will depend on the specific implementation chosen. It is our view that central banks should strive to provide all reassurance required by being transparent and including tight checks and balances to foster trust in the population.
Let us conclude this article by stating that there will not be one version of CBDC, there will be as many versions as there are countries implementing them. Each will have its own specific characteristics, trying to address the specific needs of the country but also rooted in that country’s sociopolitical ideology. China, for instance, already released to the public a pilot version of its CBDC, the digital yuan, back in August 2020. The currency has been progressively expanded to more regions, reaching 261 million of users for USD 13.8 billion worth of transactions at the end of 20219 – a moderate result, likely explained by the country’s pre-existing advance in digital payment services. The PBoC states that the objectives are to enhance efficiency and help the state fight against illegal activities. It also defends itself regarding privacy concerns and surveillance accusations, adding that they have included limitations on tracking as part of “anonymity control.”
On another hand, for major economies like the US or the EU, the implementation of CBDC will be much slower, as project calibrations are carried over the coming years and central bank laws will need to be ratified. The Fed has been involved since 2022 in extensive research projects in partnership with the Massachusetts Institute of Technology to assess potential implementations of CBDC as well as their impact. The US will most likely favor a hybrid system, with great incentives given to users to keep using the private banking sector in order to protect this leading industry. They will certainly incorporate into the project the ability for the central bank to directly transfer funds to deposit accounts, as an additional tool of monetary policy. The EU, champion of data protection regulations, will no doubt spend a considerable amount of time to reassure its citizens over the full transparency and limited tracking ability of the central bank. The ECB Governing Council will review the outcome of its first large-scale investigation phase, as part of the “Report on a digital euro” during Autumn 2023 and decide whether to carry forward with a realization phase.11
Because individual and national interests may not align neatly, there is no doubt citizens of different countries will have diverging perspectives on the usefulness of CBDCs based on their nation’s chosen path.
Throughout this article, our aim was to give the reader a better understanding of Central Bank Digital Currencies. By exploring the numerous motivations behind them, by delving into the issue of the public-private money balance and assessing the usefulness of such projects for all the involved parties. Our view is that central banks should move with caution and high transparency if these projects are to have a controlled impact on the existing financial system and be widely accepted by the population. However, the risk of taking too much time to develop CBDCs in the context of a global economic arms race could prove dangerous to national interests. As such, central banks and the governments backing them should ensure to chart an efficient and resilient path towards CBDC.
We hope that this article will empower the reader to think about this technological progress in a nuanced and complete manner. By self-appropriating the issue and developing a critical perspective, one can participate in the broader debate and hold governments responsible for an appropriate and beneficial development of Central Bank Digital Currencies.
[1] https://occaminvesting.co.uk/how-much-money-is-in-the-world/
[2] https://www.atlanticcouncil.org/cbdctracker/
[3] James Tobin, Essays in Economics (MIT Press), 1987
[4] https://www.bis.org/publ/qtrpdf/r_qt2212x.htm
[5] https://www.intereconomics.eu/contents/year/2023/number/4/article/the-geopolitics-of-central-bank-digital-currencies.html
[6] https://brettscott.substack.com/p/casino-chip-cashless-society
[7] https://www.bis.org/publ/othp33.pdf
[8] Aldous Huxley, Ends and Mean, 1937
[10] https://www.bostonfed.org/news-and-events/press-releases/2022/frbb-and-mit-open-cbdc-phase-one.aspx
[Student IDEAS] by Nelberto Nicholas Quinto - PhD student in the Management department at ESSEC Business School
This article offers a long-term overview of the transformative role of AI in shaping the future of creativity. Aside from democratizing creative production, it illustrates how AI enhances creativity by reducing the cognitive barriers to ideation and information recombination that is at the heart of innovation. However, issues related to rising quality benchmarks, acceptance, trust, and over-dependence may stifle these benefits. The article ends by offering a simple solution to these quandaries while highlighting other more pressing concerns related to AI’s march into the creative sphere.
---
AI's march into the realm of creativity has been teeming with trepidation, stemming from fears that increasingly sophisticated machines might eclipse our ingenuity and devalue the human experience. Dissecting the intricacies of co-creating works that are deemed creative– i.e. deemed both novel and useful – with generative AI in the first installment of this two-piece article series however reveals an inherently human process. A dance that involves iterative bouts of innovative experimentation, unique amalgamations of tools and ideas, and a critically overlooked component – emotion. The realization of these intensely human aspects offer a distinctly more hopeful perspective, contingent upon us remaining actively involved in the process.
Transitioning from the debate concerning the retention of humanistic elements in AI co-creation – elements that imbue depth, meaning, and value to the creative process, as discussed in this article’s predecessor, this installment aims to elaborate more on the benefits, limitations, and long-term challenges to creativity that arise from this generative process. The question of whether AI could potentially spell the demise of creativity in the long-term is ultimately addressed, followed by a conclusion that steers the discourse towards identifying more pressing concerns about AI that will require much of our ability to provide novel and useful solutions.
Creativity is understood as the generation of ideas, processes, or products that are both novel and useful1,2. When understood as an ability to produce works that meet this two-fold criteria of novelty (uniqueness, originality) and usefulness (value, quality), both the outcomes and processes inherent in generating them become relevant. One of the most widely observed benefits of co-creating with generative AI is that it streamlines and democratizes the process of creative production. By curtailing the costs related to skill, talent, and equipment (or software), AI facilitates the genesis of valuable, new creations –- be they illustrations, poems, marketing slogans, or strategic proposals. This empowerment invites a wider demographic to unlock their inherent creative potential and engage in the human-AI symphony of creation. Take, for instance, the case of Aamar Reshi discussed in detail in the first part of this article series. His imaginative journey to crafting a children's storybook in 3 days without any prior experience in illustration or creative writing was made possible by AI's ability to translate his motivation into captivating illustrations and engaging storylines.
AI also significantly lightens the cognitive load associated with conceiving original solutions to intricate, pressing problems. For instance, imagine a marketing team trying to brainstorm a new advertising campaign. Instead of spending hours coming up with basic ideas, a large language model (LLM) such as Chat GPT could generate a list of them within minutes. The team could then immediately start discussing which of these listed ideas are worth developing further. They could also combine different AI-suggested concepts to create something unique and impactful. In this way, AI allows for more effective use of the team's expertise and creative thinking. And while much of the content produced by LLMs tends towards the mundane and predictable, this in fact offers a crucial advantage. The immediate availability of a broad spectrum of highly conventional ideas allows individuals and teams to swiftly dispatch with the obvious, learn from these iterations, and refocus their cognitive prowess. In the context of prototyping, generative AI tools have emerged as a catalyst for quickly transforming abstract concepts in our heads into tangible, useful drafts. They shoulder the cognitive and labor-intensive burden of the initial groundwork, generating the first iterations swiftly. As a result, just as in brainstorming, teams can re-allocate their mental energy and time towards more creative tasks, including those where human expertise still surpasses AI.
As we hurtle into a future fraught with increasingly complex challenges requiring novel solutions, it's clear that both creativity and generative AI’s role in the creative process is here to stay. While individuals will continue to extract value from AI, the benchmark for what constitutes quality and usefulness will concurrently increase. When productive expectations rise, fostering creativity and innovation to meet these heightened standards will always be a need, and often, a priority. While the influx of novel combinations of information and ideas might make the task of generating something truly different and unique with AI progressively challenging as well, it will undeniably necessitate increasingly creative methods to continuously derive value from current tools and systems. Thus, regardless of how sophisticated AI systems become, creativity will always have a place within organizations and society.
For instance, in producing digital art, some graphic designers are already leveraging AI image generators such as Midjourney and Stable Diffusion to simulate prototypes of their ideas, draw inspiration from different styles, or ultimately create distinct artworks that require minimal post-processing. At first, such use of AI was deemed innovative, and there have been many cases where fresh and valuable works have been produced through such a process. But as leveraging AI capabilities have become more widespread, the novelty of such techniques have declined, and the average uniqueness of generated works have suffered as well. Consequently, the standards for what is considered useful have risen as more people have realized the value of current AI tools. Artists must then deepen their creative explorations, finding fresh ways to collaborate with AI to generate art that remains innovative and valuable amidst the evolving landscape. This may involve countless experimentations with prompt patterns or combining different tools, systems, or methods to process works generated by AI.
Meanwhile, in organizational settings, particularly when teams make use of Large Language Models (LLM), such as OpenAI’s ChatGPT or Google’s Bard, to streamline brainstorming sessions, catalyze idea generation, and decode complex problems– the interplay between creativity and AI unfolds in the same manner as in the arts. Consider a tech start-up using GPT technology to augment their product design brainstorming. The AI solutions might generate new perspectives on user interface design, providing inspirations that the team hadn't previously considered. Companies that successfully integrate such technologies into their workflow stand to gain a competitive edge, as they can alleviate the cognitive burden inherent in creative tasks and propel their innovation teams into uncharted territories. However, as AI-assisted approaches become commonplace, the novelty of these processes diminishes. As more and more employees, teams, and organizations become accustomed to harvesting the creative benefits of AI across a spectrum of tasks, the standard for what can be achieved within a certain timeframe and resource set escalates exponentially.
In response, organizations would need to persistently cultivate creativity to extract further value from AI. They might deploy additional algorithmic tools to discern patterns from past AI-laden brainstorming sessions and predict potential hurdles. For example, a company could use AI to analyze both previous meeting notes and past AI suggestions given various employee-generated GPT prompt patterns. This would allow individuals and teams to leverage insights derived from such data analyses to consequently modify their use of generative technologies for idea development and prototype-building. Such a solution could also lead to routinized processes and systems that facilitate extracting more value from novel AI suggestions in order to suit their unique problem contexts. For example, a marketing team could develop protocols for how to synthesize campaign ideas developed through multiple rounds of brainstorming with generative AI, across several meeting groups. They could also devise a structured process that involves integrating these insights with those uncovered by social media trends, competitor campaigns, and customer behavior data that predictive AI models concurrently deliver.
In such instances, creative production necessitates innovation in processes where different individuals and AI systems come together to meet the new, heightened standards for novelty and value that innovation and competition propel. However, when novel processes or new best practices are found to be creative at a given point in time, more and more companies are likely to find value in them. This implies that standards will rise again and organizations would need to search for more ingenious processes that leverage existing human and technological capital, fostering creativity and perpetuating its need.
Instead of pondering the supposed demise of creativity, perhaps the real issue at hand is the skepticism and under-appreciation of the immense value generative AI brings to the table. It is unsettling to see how quickly some individuals abandon the use of these technologies, swayed by a few erroneous outputs, unsuccessful prompts, or the cynicism of others. On the flip side, there exists an equally troubling group – those over-reliant on AI to the extent that they forsake nurturing their own critical thinking, domain expertise, and breadth of knowledge. This excessive dependency threatens to hollow out human innovation and intuition, reducing our contributions to mere button-pressing reactions to whimsical needs. The remedy to both of these conundrums lies in fostering a comprehensive understanding of AI's capabilities and limitations among the broader population, as discussed in more detail in the first piece of this two-part series.
There is simply so much value-creation lost when people do not simply understand the usefulness of generative tools that can rapidly produce creative drafts and prototypes ; all while harnessing centuries of accumulated human knowledge to yield accurate, factual results in at least 9 out of 10 instances. As such, there is a pressing need to educate individuals about applying even basic generative AI capabilities to the multitude of use cases in their personal and professional lives. This requires promoting practices that encourage persistent experimentation with AI, while fully acknowledging its current bounds and how it can complement our unique strengths.
AI will continue to improve, and so too will our abilities, skills, and talents. In this constant cycle of progression, the necessity of understanding the evolving capacities of AI and human creativity cannot be overstated. Identifying the complementary intersections between AI and our innovative capacity enables us to effectively harness their combined potential. And this begins by ensuring that we remain determined to cultivate the requisite knowledge, expertise, and capabilities to credibly evaluate the usefulness, appropriateness, and credibility of AI generated outputs.
In this dynamic panorama of evolving AI systems and expanding human capabilities, the value of experimentation in demarcating the ever-changing boundaries of both AI and our personal abilities becomes paramount. In particular, this knowledge helps illuminate our understanding of what AI can and cannot do for us, and what we can achieve more efficiently with or without these technologies, for any given moment in time. It also enables us to identify which domain-specific skills and new capabilities we should invest our time in developing and refining. And as we navigate this blurred frontier, the role of continuous learning, engagement, and development of our unique creative abilities vis-a-vis AI becomes ever more critical.
While the “death of creativity” is far from imminent, the reshaping business and societal terrain calls for both prudence and immediate action. As AI emboldens individuals and organizations to leverage technology to augment their unique capabilities and cumulative expertise, navigating this evolving landscape thus calls us to reconsider our part in the redefined creative epoch. Are we disrupting, merely keeping up, or falling behind? Survival in competitive environments, after all, necessitates exploiting the opportunities emerging technologies offer, and we should therefore set aside time in our schedules to explore ways we can achieve this at a personal level. Again, this begins by carefully discerning what both we and AI uniquely excel in, and identifying potent synergies that allow us to balance each other's strengths and weaknesses for our specific trade and tasks. Whether you are a marketer, musician, illustrator, business owner, or a corporate planner, understanding how emerging technologies affect the value and novelty you produce at any given point in time is paramount to continued success. Stop. Think. Reflect. What critical inputs, processes, and skills does AI need from you to deliver in order for you to generate ideas, products, and systems that are new and valuable? What are you doing to know or develop this? Your answers to these questions may well define your survival amidst AI’s creative renaissance.
While this thought exploration attempts to address whether AI would extinguish the flame of human creativity, it inevitably leaves a myriad of related issues unexplored. Indeed, while AI, with its prodigious generative capacities, promises to herald a creative renaissance—exploring uncharted territories of ideas and unveiling transformative solutions to pressing issues—we must also recognize the potential detrimental impact it could have on our artistic workforce. As discussed, the process of co-creating with generative AI still necessitates an intricate, often emotionally charged, and iterative human endeavor. It involves the careful orchestration of past human experiences to weave into the fabric of our creations.
Yet a recurrent threat that we are treading is the dangerous line of devaluing the authentic human touch; that is– the artisanal signature underlying much of the creative work we know. Companies may start to undervalue the finesse of artistic capability, leading to reduced remuneration for graphic designers, composers, and other artists. This, even before a novice utilizing generative AI can genuinely outperform seasoned creators. Such devaluation can cause both current and aspiring artists to neglect nurturing their unique aesthetic skills and specialized capabilities, which could be detrimental to the future of creativity. After all, truly harnessing the power of AI for creative endeavors requires not just knowing its technological boundaries, but also having a robust foundation of one’s specialized domain and the aesthetic sensibility needed to both recognize and conjure quality art.
Furthermore, we need to tread carefully on the path of intellectual property (IP) rights. Artists may feel aggrieved as their creative genius– their unique output– is utilized to train AI systems without due recompense or consent. This could make it facile for others to mimic their distinctive style, enabling these individuals to build on years of the artists’ painstaking dedication without due permission or acknowledgement. If we fail to establish robust mechanisms for suitable compensation, recognition, and consent for creative IP, we risk discouraging artists from trusting and reaping the benefits of AI. Worse, we risk a decline in traditional artistic pursuits, which form the bedrock of cultural heritage and individual expression. On a less immediate yet significant impact, we risk losing valuable creative contributions that future generations could build upon. If we deter a whole generation from pursuing arts due to lack of passion or adequate incentive, we lose more than just individual livelihoods. The vibrancy of our cultural tapestry and our collective ability to innovate are at stake. It is therefore vital that we safeguard the livelihoods and IP of artists to prevent cultural impoverishment.
Moreover, while AI undoubtedly creates new job opportunities and uncovers novel synergies between human and machine to drive value and discover novel solutions to critical problems, the rapid pace at which AI is reshaping the job market is cause for concern. The velocity of job displacement could potentially outpace that of job creation and skill development across a wide-array of fields. Its reach already extends to every facet of work, life, and the economy, sometimes unpredictably. Such an imbalance could endanger a substantial segment of the workforce, along with their dependents.
While AI is not poised to extinguish the flame of creativity, it could expedite the ebb of certain industries and livelihoods faster than it rebuilds or expands them. This necessitates an inventive approach to temper potential fallout. Hence, the real merit of AI lies not only in catalyzing and amplifying human creativity to forge new solutions to high-value issues, but also in innovating answers to the challenges it itself surfaces– from that of artistic preservation, intellectual property rights, overly rapid job displacement, and beyond.
[Student IDEAS] by Nelberto Nicholas Quinto - PhD student in the Management department at ESSEC Business School
As AI ventures into the world of creativity, fears are mounting about its potential to undermine human ingenuity and curb innovative pursuits, leading some to proclaim the 'end of creativity.' To navigate this complex issue, this article demystifies the concept of 'creativity,' explores its societal and organizational importance, and breaks down its key elements—novelty and usefulness. Amidst this analysis, a key concern emerges: does the 'human touch' – e.g. emotions, feelings, human experience and intention, etc. – matter in our evaluations of creativity, and if it does - are AI co-creation necessarily devoid of it? We analyze this in a case study and conclude on how this affects our understanding of AI’s effect on overall creativity.
---
Recent advancements in artificial intelligence (AI) have prompted us to ponder the fate of human creativity and its relationship with technology. Present-day AI platforms have demonstrated their prowess in generating a diverse array of creative outputs. From fabricating tailor-made digital imagery, crafting compelling advertising phrases, drafting cogent essays, or even composing infectious tunes, the allure of generative AI technologies is unmistakable. In 2022 alone, they have drawn a staggering $2.654 billion in investments, marking a tenfold increase since 2020. As AI encroaches upon what was once considered a uniquely human domain, the ontological, economic, and legal systems that underlie creative production are consequently being redefined in profound, uncharted ways. Amidst this upheaval, a question emerges: Is creativity dying, and is AI the culprit?
To untangle this provocative question, it is essential to probe into the essence of creativity—its core attributes and its significance to society and organizations. Creativity is defined as the generation of ideas, solutions, or products that are both novel and useful1,2. It is a multifaceted phenomenon, encapsulating not just the outcome or process of idea development, artistic creation, or problem-solving3, but also the inherent ability of individuals to produce the new and valuable. As the cornerstone of innovation, creativity transforms unique ideas into tangible actions or products, which in turn fuel technological advancements. Within organizations, creative employees are a catalyst for competitive advantage4. They contribute unique solutions to pressing challenges, resulting in strategies, business processes, and design concepts that drive success. Creativity also bolsters adaptability in the face of external changes and disruptive technologies, enhancing the likelihood of success for individuals and organizations5.
To grasp the essence of creativity’s central components – novelty (newness, originality) and usefulness (value, quality) – think of the last time you or someone around you has deemed something to be ‘creative.’ Was the value found in the end result or in the process that led to it? As will be revealed, this distinction is central to the debate of whether the growing impact of AI will usher in a creative renaissance or its antithesis.
The traditional perspective of creativity places emphasis on the final product. Think about an evocative novel or an influential film. Their creativity is gauged by the audience's experience with the completed work. The unpredictability of the plot, the introduction of nonconforming characters, and the use of groundbreaking narrative styles all serve as sources of novelty. Meanwhile, the exhilaration experienced from narratives that defy convention, the emotions they stir within us, the curiosity they spark, and the respite they offer from everyday life—all are markers of usefulness attributed to the end product. AI-generated designs, leading to a revolutionary product, align with this perspective. From a managerial standpoint, the value is not in the AI's process of creation but in the resultant artifact—its appeal in the market, and its innovative design that caters to and anticipates consumer needs.
From this product-centered perspective, AI emerges as a potent tool for enhancing our creativity. It produces innovative ideas and forms that inspire human artists and democratize access to creative production by making aesthetic prowess and innovative combinations more accessible. Generative AI can be conceptualized as a new 'paintbrush' for artists and creatives. Anyone can pick up this 'brush' and create—be it poems, design prototypes, or unique product concepts—without necessarily needing the traditional, extensive training or experience. For many, this accessibility may very well foster inclusivity, thereby encouraging a larger population to engage in creative pursuits. It brings people who might never consider performing artistic or innovative work into the sphere of creative endeavors, exploring their human ingenuity as they co-create with AI.
However, such democratization comes with its own challenges and limitations. The novelty of the output generated heavily relies on the creativity infused in prompts. The usefulness of the final output also remains somewhat limited, especially when considering the current state of AI wherein the quality of the generated paragraphs, images, or media may still fall short of those produced by traditional professionals.
There's often a substantial amount of trial and error involved in crafting the right prompts, as well as significant post-processing once a satisfactory output is achieved. While these are technical limitations that may be resolved as AI advances, there's another side to consider. As AI improves, so will the benchmarks for what is considered quality, useful, and new. Therefore, it's rare for a few string of prompts to suffice in creating something truly considered creative—that is, novel and valuable—for its time. Even with significant advancements in AI capabilities over time, leading to minimal post-processing or prompt engineering needs, there's always an inherent risk tied to tools that simplify processes.
Another facet of creativity lies not in the final product, but in the process itself. Envision a Master Chef contestant, orchestrating a culinary symphony with a keen eye for novelty and a daring spirit to match the time and ingredient constraints set by Gordon Ramsay and his colleagues. Their masterpiece unfolds as an intricate dance of unexpected ingredient pairings, artistic presentations, and innovative use of techniques, equipment, and resources. Here, creativity is not solely defined by the outcome but by the culinary journey that unfurls, tantalizing taste buds and challenging preconceived notions of what can be done with limited resources. Similarly, improvisational theater values the performers' on-the-spot thinking, synchronized action, and narrative creation, as much as the final performance. The process is integral to determining creativity. Even in organizational settings, the sequential motions inherent in problem-solving —brainstorming, experimentation, and collaboration—are regarded as creative, alongside the effectiveness of their end solution.
Despite known limitations, numerous instances exist where works co-created with AI have been recognized for their creativity. Last year, a digital image generated by AI won a statewide art competition in Colorado. The judges affirmed that their decision to honor the contestant would have remained the same, regardless of prior knowledge of AI involvement in the artwork. In April of this year, a song that employed AI to generate melodies in the voices and styles of popular artists Drake and The Weeknd, went viral on social media. Titled 'Heart On My Sleeve', this track mimicked the stars' distinctive styles in verses ostensibly about pop sensation Selena Gomez, who has romantic ties with The Weeknd. The song was widely lauded for its innovative stylistic fusion and its infectious rhythm. Similarly, in corporate environments, generative AI has been employed to aid the development of innovative marketing campaigns as well as fundamentally novel and useful business strategies that managers can build upon and implement. As such, AI capabilities continue to improve over time, it's becoming increasingly apparent that there's little pushback against the technology’s ability to generate works that are novel and valuable, provided that creativity is interpreted from a product oriented perspective. Hence, the primary criticisms against AI's capability to produce or enhance creativity stem from adopting the process-centric one.
Valuing process over product often comes with an emphasis on the emotional and sensory journey inherent in human imagination and innovation. This viewpoint suggests that the true value of creative work is deeply entwined with the feelings and shared experiences manifested in its creation. As AI produces creative works based on learned patterns– without true comprehension of our intentions, history, or emotions– creations that leverage it are seen to lack the depth and meaning that gives value to the creative process. Thus, for the many patrons of the human touch, any process void of these elements loses their usefulness automatically. Singer and songwriter Nick Cave eloquently expressed this very sentiment when reacting to a song written by AI chatbot GPT in 'his style':
"Songs arise out of suffering, by which I mean they are predicated upon the complex, internal human struggle of creation and, well, as far as I know, algorithms don’t feel. Data doesn’t suffer. ChatGPT has no inner being, it has been nowhere, it has endured nothing, it has not had the audacity to reach beyond its limitations, and hence it doesn’t have the capacity for a shared transcendent experience, as it has no limitations from which to transcend. ChatGPT’s melancholy role is that it is destined to imitate and can never have an authentic human experience, no matter how devalued and inconsequential the human experience may in time become.”
In December of 2022, an intriguing event unfolded in the creative world. One, that invites reflection into the humanity behind AI-co creations. Aamar Reshi, then a tech worker in Silicon Valley, who had no prior experience in graphic illustration or creative writing, produced a children’s book in the span of 72 hours and sold 841 copies in Amazon over a week. His secret sauce? OpenAI's Chat GPT for the story narrative, and the AI art generator, Midjourney, for the illustrations. This well-documented accomplishment represents an interesting shift in the creative landscape, as tasks that traditionally demanded years of learning and skill honing were executed by Aamar in a mere three days—and at virtually no financial cost.
A crucial aspect of this narrative is that Aamar circumvented the laborious grind of mastering digital design and storytelling intricacies. His main inputs, as documented on his Twitter feed6 were two-fold: textual prompts that generated the narratives and illustrations found in his book, and his clever use of these digital tools to construct a coherent piece in a limited amount of time. Trial and error was central to his creative process, as he experimented with different prompts to craft his desired manuscript and illustrations. What used up most of his time was learning to maintain a consistent depiction of his protagonists, Alice and Sparkle on Midjourney. Yet, the conversion of his imagined images and plot ideas into tangible illustrations, descriptions, and written stories required merely a few seconds of waiting time for each iteration. While Aamar's journey showcases the power of AI to democratize the creative process, it also highlights the pitfalls of such an approach. His illustrations lacked consistency and detail, likely a result of his over-reliance on AI tools and his lack of domain expertise in the digital arts. In the end, Sparkle, Alice's robot companion, was rendered differently across each page due to Midjourney's inability to produce consistent illustrations from the same descriptions. Alice, too, was not spared from inconsistencies, depicted with missing fingers on occasion.
Aamar was innovative in his clever use of limited resources to solve a pressing challenge: creating a children's book. Although he did not utilize traditional artistic techniques or software, his co-creation with AI served as a conduit for transmuting his imagination into tangible prototypes that allowed him to develop a novel plotline through experimentation with various prompts. Confronted with the issue of inconsistent images, Aamar applied his human ingenuity to devise a clever solution: describing Sparkle to be a robot that metamorphosed into various forms- a creative fix that cohesively blended with his narrative.
As noted, his case also illustrates the democratization and streamlining of creative work. Even if he lacked formal training in graphic design and had no prior experience as an illustrator or storyteller, he was still able to conceive an original, interesting story that had (somewhat) coherent and meaningful illustrations. In essence, he came up with creative solutions to turning his fresh ideas into a tangible product which found significant demand, and hence– value, upon its release. And although the usefulness of his work is limited by the inconsistent and, at times un-detailed, illustrations –a limitation which might diminish as AI technology continues to evolve and improve– the evidence suggests that Aamar’s final product is in fact, creative - i.e. novel and useful. Despite the innovative manner in which he developed his storybook however, the value in his process remains questionable to those who value the human elements which underlie creativity production. Therefore, the query looms: was his work void of the humanity that– arguably– gives meaning, depth, and usefulness to the creative process?
Not only did he “borrow” the feelings and emotions nested in the collective intelligence within Chat GPT's memory to produce his plot, dialogue, and illustrations, but upon further contemplation, much of his process actually involves a variety of inherently human attributes. The excitement he felt with his work, the love he felt for his niece that sparked this project, the oscillations between euphoria and melancholy during each imaginative iteration, and the victorious sensation he savored as he reveled in his accomplished masterpiece were all profoundly human experiences and emotions.
In the parlance of Nick Cave’s critique: his blood, sweat, and guts coalesced into a tangible expression of creativity– there at his desk– a realization of a nebulous idea that made its way to him. That is- within the vast expanse of algorithmic and artistic unpredictability, his creative idea found him. In all his humanity. And he made it come to fruition in three relentless days. Thus, Aamar’s case illustrates that the process of co-creation with generative AI can, and often does, involve quintessential human aspects where innovation emerges from processes and ideas that are new and valuable.
For those of you who have used AI to generate works that were considered novel and highly valuable by your peers, organization, or audience-evaluators, perhaps it is time to reflect and appreciate the inherent humanity in your creative work. For those of you who haven’t, you are invited to envision what such a process should involve as you go through the next sentences.
Think of instances where you brainstormed ideas or developed potential solutions through a conversation with Chat GPT. Maybe there were times when you involved generative AI in creating a business proposal, an artistic illustration, a musical piece; or perhaps a scientific publication, an innovative product, or even a clever recommendation that was, in fact, considered original and beneficial. Did your creative journey involve the emotional roller coaster of highs and lows? The frustration felt when ideas fail? The iterative cycles where you leveraged multiple tools and information sources in inventive ways to achieve a part of your desired outcome?
Did you harness feelings and intuitions from your gut? Did you rely on tacit heuristics and knowledge formed from years of accumulated experience and social interactions deeply embedded in your human psyche? If the answer to some of these questions are a yes, then it only shows that Aamar’s experience was not an isolated case- but is, in truth, a generalizable one.
These aspects are integral to our humanity–our shared experience– and they would very likely have been present in the generative AI co-creation instances that you experienced or envisioned. Even the journey to developing your accumulated expertise in whatever it is you do involves painstakingly human ways in which you labored to sharpen them. More people need to be reminded that the knowledge and skill that you and I have developed is critical to both evaluating and building upon the intermediate outputs produced by AI to produce works that are actually novel and useful.
Indeed, the route to producing work that is genuinely innovative, with or without AI's assistance, invariably involves a unique recombination of our lived human experiences and abilities. As can be drawn from your personal cases, and that of Aamar Reshi’s, creators often employ a range of tools, techniques, and information sources to generate value and endure iterative procedures that are seldom smooth and free of emotional dynamics. As such, so long as humans remain in the production loop, any creative process that leverages generative AI still retains significant traces of our shared experience and human nature.
As with all tools that streamline processes, there is always a danger that individuals might over-rely on them, progressively depending less on their abilities and unique value contributions. In this case, such a trend could lead to a reduced cultivation of both individual creativity and the essential skills relevant to creative production—be it mastering the use of a paintbrush, crafting a riveting narrative for a target audience, evaluating the aesthetics of a presentation deck, or steering a company brainstorming session. As AI takes up an increasing part of the creative process, our aptitude for ideation, improvisation, and critical thinking may begin to fade.
Similarly, when individuals overestimate AI’s ability to generate value, there is also a tendency to bypass activities that cultivate our ability to generate the novel and useful. Examples include discussing our ideas with our colleagues (as opposed to just chatting with an LLM about them), engaging in exploratory learning, or improving the depth of our specific professional expertise. The ease of producing AI-generated outputs that, at first glance, might seem highly innovative and valuable, might also cause a drop in motivation to engage in creative work - i.e. the question: 'If AI can generate creative works with relative ease, why should I expend the effort?' People need to understand that the path is often an arduous, emotionally tumultuous one, and cases where new and useful products are developed with relative ease are very much the exception rather than the norm. Moreover, projecting into the future, if AI does advance to the extent that it eliminates the need for substantial post-processing work, several prompt iterations, inventive ways to combine different tools and knowledge inputs to produce a novel and useful work– and well, all the emotions that come with these– would that signal the demise of creativity? It definitely is a possibility. If co-creating with generative AI results in fewer problems that demand new and impactful solutions, then creativity may diminish simply because we would need less of it. But that is, by all means, a good problem to have.
It is imperative that individuals learn to co-create with generative AI tools both responsibly and proficiently. The outlined risks to our creativity demands an understanding that these technologies are not replacements for our own cognitive ability and domain expertise. Neither are they supposed to be used as quick-fix mechanisms for producing content (e.g. essays, images, or sounds) with scant surprise or quality appeal. Instead, individuals should engage with these tools in ways that stimulate their critical thinking, challenge them to push the boundaries of convention, and inspire them to conceive ideas, products, artworks, or business processes that are not only distinct from predecessors but also more efficient, value-enhancing, and superior in quality. And all of this begins with understanding that the path to truly creative co-creation with generative AI is a painstaking, iterative, and exploratory process that requires novel ways to combine our cumulative human experiences, imaginative capacity, and knowledge with the current capabilities of these technologies.
Such a paradigm shift necessitates substantial investment from organizations, educational institutions, and even governments in programs designed to enable and encourage these exploratory practices. Experimentation, after all, benefits from guidance and often comes at the cost of not getting traditional work or schooling done. But this should not be a cause of worry. We have already witnessed select groups of individuals and organizations leveraging generative AI in new and useful ways that showcase their unlocked creative potential. Business news feeds and popular technology sites such as TechCrunch, Product Hunt, and VentureBeat are filled with a rich variety of new use cases each week. Hence, it is conceivable that support for such endeavors are likely to come. And, as history has demonstrated, when the innovative use of AI enables select groups of people or organizations to excel in their niche, gain a competitive advantage, or simply overcome their peers, then others will emulate their strategies– fueling creativity and perpetuating the cycle of innovation.
Will AI spell creativity’s demise, or could it instead ignite a renaissance of sorts? If the concern lies in losing the humanity behind the creative process, then, so long as humans are involved in the creation process, and that problems and needs that require novel and useful solutions, approaches, or products continue to exist, then the more optimistic of the two scenarios is likely to materialize. In other words, AI may well just revolutionize creativity for the better.
There are, however, a few other concerns that need to be accounted for, such as the lack of acceptance or understanding behind the value that these generative technologies bring. Particularly relevant as well is how increasing AI adoption inevitably creates higher standards for what is valuable, truly unique, and feasible to accomplish within a given period of time. The sequel to this article attempts to summarize all of these other concerns, building on the evidence and logical arguments presented in this first part to more robustly answer the tantalizing question behind AI’s impact on creativity. Importantly, this second installment will underscore the necessity to shift our focus. The imminent issue may not be a potential dwindling of our ingenuity, but rather a constellation of critical factors surrounding the perception and common understanding regarding what it takes to co-create ideas, processes, or products with AI that are truly novel and useful. There's also a pressing need to consider the protective measures extended to workers who are at the interface of AI's influence. For instance, while AI may not necessarily stifle overall creativity, it holds the potential to extinguish the arts if considerations around the valuation of artistic capabilities and the protection of artists' intellectual property are not meticulously examined. These will all be touched upon in the sequel of this two-part article series (see "The AI Creative Renaissance: the Impact of Co-Creating with AI on Creativity and the Future of Work").
[6] content requires Twitter account to view.
AS AN INCREASING NUMBER OF PEOPLE MIGRATE TO CITIES, WILL AI'S ADOPTION EMPOWER CITIES TO PROTECT ITS INHABITANTS FROM THE RAMIFICATIONS OF CLIMATE CHANGE?
[Student IDEAS] by Seethal Reddy Kauluri - Master in Management at ESSEC Business School
This article will look into the definition of the attention economy, what it entails, how it affects society at large, and why everyone should care; particularly in this new age of exponential and wide-use of artificial intelligence. Moreover, it will guide a possible way forward for citizens to deal with the attention economy, and underline the sway that users have over the tech services that govern our daily lives.
---
“ AI is the new electricity.” - Andrew NG, co-founder of Coursera and Google Brain Deep Learning Project.
From bushfires in Australia, floods in India, droughts in Africa, to dry corridors in Central Asia, we have seen some of the deadliest and costliest climate disasters of history[1] in the recent past. They won’t be the last of such disasters to occur if our efforts to fight climate change remain scant as today. According to the United Nations[2], the global emissions were supposed to be reduced by 7.6% per year between 2020 and 2030 in order to limit global warming below 2 degrees Celsius (3.6 degrees Fahrenheit) set at the Paris Agreement. However, global emissions increased in 2021 after a dip by 5% in 2020 due to the COVID-19 pandemic.
Cities contribute to over 70%[3] of these global CO2 emissions due to massive industrialisation and motorised transportation systems that still use fossil fuels. They are also the most vulnerable to these disasters as they are home to more than half the world’s population today and three quarters of the population or 6.5 billion people by 2050. Asia and Africa, where the majority of the population still resides in rural areas, increasingly face the stress of rapid urbanisation, while uplifting living standards at the same time. According to Mckinsey Global Institute's report[4], Asia will starve due to increasing droughts, and India may lose up to 30 percent of annual daylight hours by 2050 due to rising temperatures.
As we desperately hunt for solutions to protect our cities in the wake of this emergency, this article critically compares and assesses the potential of AI as a solution as it is increasingly revered today in various applications due to its abilities to perform human-like tasks faster, with minimum errors, and at a much grander scale than was possible before.
To overcome the challenge of rapid infrastructural development while improving quality of living, many African and Asian countries are looking to build smart cities: to integrate advanced technologies to manage overcrowding and traffic, and to manage resources better. Smart cities also seem to be a way of attracting foreign investment as they are seen as an opportunity to expand markets, promote innovative products and services, tap into emerging hubs for skilled workforce and gain trade benefits. While there is no universally accepted definition of a smart city, in a broader sense, it has been defined by multiple sources as a city that leverages smart technology and communication, such as, data analytics, cloud computing, Internet-of-Things (IoT), or artificial intelligence to achieve operational efficiencies for the welfare of the citizens. But this definition doesn’t explicitly state that smart cities are necessarily built to be resistant to the adversities of climate change.
According to the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change[5], Climate Resilient Development is urgently needed. It defines this framework as, “reducing exposure and vulnerability to climate hazards, cutting back greenhouse gas emissions and conserving biodiversity are given the highest priorities in everyday decision-making and policies on all aspects of society including energy, industry, health, water, food, urban development, housing and transport.” Therefore, as the global smart cities market[6] is expected to grow to the value of about $1.38 trillion by 2030, there is an increasing need to refocus this investment on building smart cities that are, in fact, resilient.
Before proposing solutions, let us first analyse some popular non-AI experimental eco-settlements and assess whether inspirations can be drawn from their styles of governance, economy, and self-sufficiency in achieving climate-resilience. One such settlement is Auroville[7] in Viluppuram district of India, which was founded in 1968 as a community in which people from all over the world could come together and live in harmony, transcending the barriers of nationality, race, and religion. The town is resilient to climate as the inhabitants are committed to sustainable living while reducing environmental impact by adopting methods such as using renewable energy, organic farming, and implementing water conservation and waste management systems. Auroville also places a strong emphasis on educational programs that help build the knowledge and skills needed to adapt to the impacts of climate change. It is home to several research centres and innovative projects that focus on sustainability and climate resilience.
Another utopian settlement project is NEOM[8], which is part of Saudi Arabia’s vision 2030 that aims to offer its citizens the best of diverse climates - from sun-soaked beaches, floating industrial islands on Red sea, to ski resorts in snow capped mountains, all while running on 100% renewable energy. The region, an area larger than Israel, aims to eliminate cars and roads by replacing them with a hyper-speed rail that covers the entire Line - the shape in which the city will be built for a length of about 177 kms. Each block of this city aims to be self-sufficient by building schools, groceries and other basic amenities at a walkable distance to cut emissions. The project also claims to care for biodiversity by building a coral-reef restoration project.
However successful or utopian these experiments might sound, it is overly ambitious to adopt their styles on a large scale. Auroville is a close-knit community with a number of residents just over 3000, although the plan was initially to attract tens of thousands more residents. This sense of unity helps build social resilience, which is essential for climate resilience but cannot be replicated at a global scale due to bureaucracy and disharmony between national and local governments. This is also why NEOM, which aims to host up to 9 million residents by 2045 (only 0.09% of the world population by then), aims to have an independent governance system with laws of its own, which not only substantiates that it is easier to control climate policies in a smaller sample, but also establishes that it is impossible to achieve these climate and self-sufficiency objectives while remaining under the law and economy of its host country that still derived 68%[9] of its budget revenues from oil in 2019. Another challenge of scaling these models is the differences in global diversity. Even though Auroville brings together diverse people from all over the world, they are still connected through a common sense of spirituality and respect for nature. These individuals share values of collectivism and insist on learning a common language, Tamil, to facilitate cooperation and smooth community functions. Finally, such models depend on local resources for self-sufficiency. While Auroville depends on its organic farms and renewable projects for food, energy and water, Neom aims to build a close-knit self-sufficient economic hub by attracting world-wide talent from 14 industrial sectors in creating a concentration of resources and economic power that makes it far easier to achieve resilience here than at a macro-level. Analysts also suggest that projects like Neom are more a delay towards climate objectives than a solution as living in Saudi Arabia necessitates the use of air conditioning, which is still challenging to shift into renewables.
Therefore, as the sustainable models implemented in the cities discussed above cannot be replicated on a larger scale, we must turn towards more pragmatic and viable solutions to improve our cities’ climate resilience.
According to a survey conducted by BCG[10], AI can expedite reduction of GHG emissions up to 10% per organisation and up to 5.3 billion tons of CO2e if scaled globally. This is because of its enormous power of gathering, computing, and analysing unstructured, multidimensional, and end-to-end data points. As cities in Asia and Africa suffer from inefficient city designs due to informal settlements and inadequate public transportation systems, these regions can radically transform into sustainable and resilient cities by leveraging AI’s power in 360-degree information modelling to optimise energy, reduce wastage, and improve accuracy and speed of climate-modelling for better mitigation and preparedness in the short-term and adaptation and resilience in the long-term.
In buildings, energy can be optimised by autonomous lighting, heating, and cooling based on occupancy levels, time of the day, weather conditions and occupants’ comfort. AI can be used to track carbon foot-print, water usage, and waste production in order to set consumption limits. AI can spot anomalies through data gathered from sensors and check performances of equipment outside the norm for timely maintenance and repairs. AI can predict energy requirements to ensure ample solar panels and storage are installed for uninterrupted renewable energy consumption. Comparative data analysis from other green-buildings, or with simulations based on AI-built “digital twins”, can be used to prescribe alternative architectural designs in comparable areas to further reduce emissions if required. For example, it can be prescribed to use tinted windows or green roofs to keep the buildings cooler if the major carbon emitter for a particular building is air conditioner. AI can cluster the occupants based on consumption behaviours and emissions for law-makers to either encourage favourable behaviours through reward systems or through penalties.
Similarly in transport, AI can optimise train and bus routes and frequencies by matching demand and supply based on time of day, season, weather, etc. It can be used to predict repairs and maintenance in advance to prepare for downtime and ensure that public transportation is always available and running smoothly without interruptions. It can also be used to propose on-demand services or reduce off-peak inefficiencies caused by vehicles running almost empty because of their fixed itineraries and schedules. Personal vehicles can be replaced by car-pooling that matches passengers based on pickup and destination. AI can also analyse data about walking, running, and cycling activity to make recommendations. For instance, it can suggest the best locations for basic neighbourhood amenities such as groceries, coffee shops, pharmacies, schools and emergency clinics, to ensure widespread access that does not rely on fossil fuels. It is also possible to centralise transport systems to optimise routes and traffic. A city’s transportation system can be entirely integrated on a 360-degree carbon monitoring to ensure that collectively, the city’s transport stays within the carbon budget. If at a particular time, personal vehicles on road cause more emissions, reinforcement learning can be used to encourage citizens to use more of public transport by increasing frequency of trains and metro while increasing time of red traffic signals on the road to discourage vehicle traffic or converting roads into carbon-free zones to promote cycle and pedestrian-traffic only.
AI can study vast data from weather sensors, satellites, news reports, and social media, and spot hidden patterns and events to predict risks, such as temperatures, sea-levels, droughts, rainfalls, heat-waves, hurricanes etc. Predicting these events can help prepare the necessary infrastructure for minimising the consequences, including utilities’ networks (water, gas, electricity, etc.), critical to the proper functioning of a city. These patterns and clustering can also help predict the degree of impact for each region based on population density, industrial activity, infrastructure, biodiversity, etc and compute the degree of rescue services and relief supplies required for better mitigation. An integrated biodiversity system can help monitor species, plantations and conditions of habitats to spot patterns of endangerment, deforestation and environmental factors affecting the weather patterns.
Thus, AI’s power of integration systems from macro to micro-level emission monitoring and hazard prediction can help build a harmonised source of truth and scale what smaller experiments like Auroville or NEOM have on a much larger, global scale.
The aforementioned ideas may sound like the answer to our problem, but there is resistance in the adoption of AI due to several reasons. Firstly, the data is widely scattered and dissociated as there is a lack of centralised data source. This is because the climate objectives are too broad and the firms and law-makers haven’t adequately defined the KPIs to be tracked for each sector. To establish the same could be challenging as a large infrastructural overhaul will be required to substitute independent systems with interconnected, autonomous and accountable systems and appliances which might be highly infeasible depending on the scope of project and the cost of sensors, storage, computing resources, and personnel required to implement the models. Therefore, it is the duty of the law-makers and enforcers to break down the objectives to smaller key results and introduce policies for infrastructure, construction and automobile industries to mandate accountable data collection points in their products. Secondly, there is lack of education and training on AI expertise among organisational leaders and governing bodies to realise its vast potential. Free online and offline educational programs, workshops, and certifications shall be set up from schools to organisational leaders and policy-makers to equip them with the requisite knowledge. States should also promote research centres, events and competitions in the field of green-AI to encourage new and innovative ideas. Another challenge is that setting up large-scale and centralised AI integrated systems requires huge financial investments which is challenging for countries in Asia and Africa due to the pressure of mitigating fundamental gaps in the economy and infrastructure. According to a report by OpenAI[11], it is estimated that the cost of training a model on a large dataset will increase to $500 million by 2030 due to an increase in the size of datasets needed to train large models. However, setting up this investment right away will ensure resilience, cost-efficiency and a significant gain in the GDP of up to 4.4%[12] by 2030. But even if these governments were convinced to step up the financing for this preparation today, a larger issue regarding AI adoption would remain: can we trust the results that AI provides?
One of the reasons why AI-based recommendations are not always relied upon is due to the quality of their design and model training. Human intervention in feeding, labelling and training data while the model is built can give room for bias and skewed results. For example, if the AI-based traffic system mentioned earlier aims to manage demand and supply to optimise bus routes in a city, such a model will work inefficiently if it has been trained on historical data of a city’s bus routes where certain high-income areas never had a bus-stop because they used cars. Such a model will have to be trained on collecting data from all modes of transport to understand commuting patterns. New experimental car-pooling and bus routes will have to be set up initially to collect data on public transport preferences of the citizens. Another example is if a model has studied smartphone data of a region to understand walking and cycling patterns to plan roads and accessible neighbourhood amenities such as groceries and pharmacies. Such a model will work inadequately if the data collected was from an area of ageing population with minimal smartphone adoption. Therefore, such models will have to be trained by nudging some preferred behaviours first[13], and may rely on human modelling assumptions (such as that which was used in the 1970s to predict train demand for the newly created BART system in San Francisco, and for which Dan McFadden received the 2020 Nobel Prize in Economics)[14].
An additional concern is regarding the confidentiality of the information captured by the AI systems that can compromise privacy and security. The accuracy of these models will depend on the extent to which the inhabitants are willing to share their information. The law-makers need to carefully consider the type of information to be mandatorily collected from the citizens, and ensure that it does not compromise their freedom of choice. Additionally, will highly autonomous systems be capable of considering externalities? Or new patterns? Indeed, what if green-buildings’ AI integrated systems were trained on pre-pandemic occupancy levels, but when another pandemic, like COVID, hits the region causing almost everyone to work from home? Will such AI systems accept the extra-bandwidth of energy needed to run the residential buildings? It would be necessary that such a system should also train the carbon budget at the macro-level and maintain a global balance of buildings’ emissions, by temporarily transferring the carbon budget of office buildings to that of the residential buildings. This brings us back to the general limitations of AI that when faced with adversities, especially in situations when no historic data or patterns exist, a human intervention is always required. Then the real question remains for us to ask ourselves, whether undergoing such an ambitious infrastructural project is justified given the human efforts required despite the massive capital expenditure and with the uncertainties of the risks present in adopting it.
Given the numerous applications of AI in mitigating climate risks and achieving climate-resiliency, overlooking such an immense potential will be a significant missed opportunity. However, due to the challenges present in adopting a globally-scaled autonomous infrastructure and the accuracy of its decisions, AI is only an accelerator towards achieving our climate objectives and not the solution itself. Just as it is easy to coordinate smaller-sized homogenous experimental cities, implementing AI for climate should be scaled step-by-step starting with the most vulnerable sectors by carefully monitoring the results and reimplementing models in similar and comparable conditions.
Achieving climate-objectives goes beyond adoption of AI. International organisations, governments, urbanists and corporations have a fundamental role in adopting a harmonious framework by breaking down climate objectives into smaller-measurable targets for each region, industry and sector. They play an important role in creating a clear path for investment and innovation. Governments should pave the way for adoption of new technologies that will not only make our future cities smart, but future-proof them. Policies in education, research and business will play a defining role in the future of AI and in its adoption for a green, stress-free future of habitation.
[1] 10 costliest climate disasters of 2022. (2023). World Economic Forum.
[2] Cut global emissions by 7.6 percent every year for next decade to meet 1.5°C Paris target. (2019). UN Environment Programme
[3] Dasgupta, S., Lall, S., Wheeler, D. Cutting global carbon emissions: where do cities stand? (2022). World Bank
[4] Woetzel, J., Tonby, O., Krishnan, M., Yamada, Y., Sengupta, S., Pinner, D., Fakhrutdinov, R., and Watanabe, T. Climate risk and response in Asia. (2020). McKinsey Global Institute.
[5] What is Climate Resilient Development and how do we pursue it? Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change report.
[6] Thormundsson, B. Smart cities market revenues worldwide 2019-2030. (2023)
[7] Koduvayur Venkitaraman, A., Joshi, N. A critical examination of a community-led ecovillage initiative: a case of Auroville, India. Clim Action 1, 15. (2022).
[8] Palmer, I,. Is Saudi Arabia’s New Climate City ‘Neom’ Future Or Fantasy? (2022) Forbes.
[9] Almasoud, A., Albasri, K., Alshammari, M., Alghamdi, R., Alanazi, A., Binladen, S., Alsikhan, S., Kingdom of Saudi Arabia Budget Report. (2018). KPMG.
[10] Maher, H., Meinecke, H., Gromier, D., Garcia-Novelli, M., Fortmann, R. AI Is Essential for Solving the Climate Crisis. (2022). BCG.
[11] AI Model Training Costs Are Expected to Rise From $100 Million to $500 Million By 2030. (2023). MetaversePost.
[12] Herweijer, C., Combes, B., Gillham, J. Artificial intelligence and the fate of planet Earth. (2019). PWC.
[13] Cowls, J., Tsamados, A., Taddeo, M. Floridi, L. The AI gambit: leveraging artificial intelligence to combat climate change—opportunities, challenges, and recommendations. (2021). AI & Soc.
[14] McFadden, D. The Measurement of Urban Travel Demand. (1974). Journal of Public Economics, 3, 303-328.
[Student IDEAS] by Rinalyn Pagao - MSc in Sustainability Transformation at ESSEC Business School
The intersection of degrowth and technological advancement presents a complex and nuanced picture for our future. This article explores whether it could coexists and complement each other to some extent.
---
Do you ever feel like the pursuit of economic growth has taken us down a dangerous path, where the health of the planet and its inhabitants are sacrificed for the sake of financial gain? If you are nodding your head in agreement, then continue reading because we are about to dive into a fascinating topic: degrowth.
In our current global society, the growth-based economic model has dominated for too long, leading to environmental degradation and social inequality.1 Fortunately, an alternative concept of degrowth has emerged, promoting a supposedly sustainable and more equitable way of life. However it does not surprise us that regardless, technological advancement and digitalization continue to shape and transform our world in profound ways that could seem inevitable.
In this article, we will explore the intersection of degrowth and technological advancement, and critically analyze their intertwined potential implications in a global context.
Degrowth is a concept that challenges the idea that economic growth is necessary for human development and wellbeing. It is based on the principles of sufficiency, resilience, and equity, and calls for a reduction in production and consumption levels to achieve a sustainable and equitable society.2 While the concept of degrowth has its roots in the 1970s, it has gained more attention in recent years as a response to the current ecological and social crises, however it also raises some criticisms as such that degrowth is too radical and impractical, while others claim that it overlooks the needs of those in poverty.3
Technological advancement has undoubtedly brought about many positive changes to our world, from medical advancements to increased connectivity and access to information. However, it has also been associated with negative impacts such as environmental degradation, social inequality, and job displacement. The debate around technological determinism, the idea that technology shapes society, versus social constructivism, the idea that society shapes technology, is still ongoing.4 Both views have their merits, and the truth likely lies somewhere in between as per what the scholars suggest. While this debate is not the focus of this article it is still important for us to consider both perspectives when thinking about the relationship between technology and society, as this will help us to develop a more nuanced understanding of this complex issue.
Technological advancements per se in the sustainability sector are the renewable energy, clean transportation, energy efficiencies, and carbon capture and utilisation storage (CCUS) - can these potentially be a powerful tool to degrowth our economy?
The latest report done by the International Energy Agency (IEA) on its Clean Innovation Report: Global status of clean energy innovation in 20205 acknowledged that technological innovation is crucial for addressing climate change and achieving the goals of energy policy, such as expanding access to energy and lowering air pollution. However, it might be hard to monitor innovation progress, specifically the major challenge to be able to quantify or allocate inputs to policy goals like more affordable technology, industrial change, and economic growth. Nevertheless, a number of measures, including (1) funding and (2) patenting, might provide insight into clean energy innovation on a worldwide scale. More comprehensive sets of measurements are being created by some governments in order to find and share best practices.
This trend tells us that the government funding on energy research and development increased by 3% in 2019 to USD 30 billion globally, with over 80% of that money going toward low-carbon energy technology. Specifically in China, the low-carbon component of energy research and development increased by 10% in 2019, with significant increases in research and development for energy efficiency and hydrogen in particular. Spending on public energy R&D increased by 7% in both Europe and the United States, exceeding the previous year's trend.
On the other hand, in terms of patenting since 2011, the quantity of patents submitted for low-carbon energy technologies has sharply decreased after a decade of rapid increase. Patents capture part of the intermediate R&D outputs, a percentage of which will be converted into commercial products, and so offer a window into the research operations that are producing new information with a view toward its perceived commercial value. However, general patenting trends offer us some insightful data on the scope and direction of clean energy innovation.
The drop in renewable energy patenting activity from roughly 2011 may be due to the maturity of some technologies. The dominance of existing solar PV, bioethanol, and wind technologies may discourage researchers from striving to improve them and enter the markets in Europe, Japan, and the United States. Moreover, renewable energy patenting continues to be more active than it was before approximately 2007, and Li-ion battery patenting, in particular, is expanding (EPO and IEA, 2020).
Now that we have built a solid foundation on what constitutes a green technological innovation, what begs a question here is that how could it intersect with the degrowth principle? In the publication done by Hickel and Kallis (2019) they investigated and tried to answer: is green growth possible?6 According to the green growth theory, sustained economic expansion is consistent with our planet's ecology because technology change and substitution will allow us to completely disconnect GDP growth from resource use and carbon emissions. This claim is increasingly assumed in national and international policy, including the Sustainable Development Goals. Green growth has developed as a major policy response to climate change and ecological disintegration. However, empirical evidence on resource utilization and carbon emissions does not support green growth theory. After reviewing relevant papers on historical trends and model-based projections, this research study conducted reveals that:
“(1) there is no empirical evidence that absolute decoupling from resource use can be achieved on a global scale against a background of continued economic growth, and
(2) absolute decoupling from carbon emissions is highly unlikely to be achieved at a rate rapid enough to prevent global warming over 1.5°C or 2°C, even under optimistic policy conditions. We conclude that green growth is likely to be a misguided objective, and that policymakers need to look toward alternative strategies.”
Hence, even looking at the intersection between the myriad of technological innovations we have reached today, especially the energy transition needed to net zero emissions by 2050 commitment, the promise of a sustainable future for our current and for the next generation is still not guaranteed.
In this section, let’s dig deeper on the four main paradoxes that hinders technological advancement toward sustainability and degrowth: (1) decoupling growth from resource consumption, (2) e-waste generation, (3) conflicting power and politics, and (4) cultural and social implications.
Degrowth advocates for a reduction in production and consumption levels to achieve a sustainable and equitable society.7 However, this poses a challenge in a world where economic growth is closely tied to resource consumption. This means that if we want to reduce production and consumption levels, we will also need to reduce economic growth. This is a challenge because economic growth is seen as essential for prosperity by many people. There are a number of ways to address this challenge. One way is to change the way we measure economic growth. We could focus on measures of well-being, such as life expectancy, happiness, and environmental quality, instead of GDP. Another way is to decouple economic growth from resource consumption. This means finding ways to grow the economy without increasing resource consumption.
While technological advancements can facilitate the transition towards renewable energy and more efficient production processes, it is unclear whether they can enable a complete decoupling of growth from resource consumption. According to the Global Footprint Network, achieving sustainable resource use would require a reduction in resource consumption by roughly 75% in high-income countries and 90% in middle-income countries.8 This would be challenging to achieve through technological advancements alone. In addition, the findings in the recent study stated that while energy and material efficiency improvements have reduced the amount of resources required for each unit of GDP, the overall consumption of resources has increased due to economic growth.
According to the United Nations The Global E-waste Monitor 2020, in 2019 there was a record high of 53.6 million metric tonnes (Mt) of electronic waste generated globally, which is an increase of 21% in just five years.9 E-waste is a term used to describe discarded electronic devices and equipment such as discarded electronic devices and equipment, such as computers, mobile phones, televisions, refrigerators, and air conditioners. It may contain harmful substances, and can pose significant risks to the environment and human health if not managed appropriately.
The production of e-waste is increasing quickly due to advances in technology and the popularity of electronic devices among consumers.10 As a consequence, it imposes potential conflicts between degrowth and technological advancement. The increasing levels of e-waste, low collection rates, and non-environmentally sound disposal and treatment of this waste stream pose significant risks to the environment and human health. Also, as technology advances, older devices become obsolete and are often discarded, leading to a significant environmental impact.11 Hence, degrowth principles call for a reduction in consumption levels, while the technology industry relies on continuous consumption and disposal of new products.
The implementation of both degrowth and technological advancement requires significant changes to the current global economic and political systems, which is a very challenging task. The dominant economic and political actors may not be willing to relinquish their power and privilege to facilitate such changes. It can be seen in the reluctance of many governments to adopt policies that would limit economic growth or reduce resource consumption.
Furthermore, this is exemplified by the failure of the COP26 climate summit where we all witnessed countries failing to agree on crucial measures to limit global warming.12 The International Energy Agency has also warned the public that current climate policies fall short of what is required to limit global warming to 1.5°C above pre-industrial levels, and rapid action is needed to avert a climate catastrophe. In addition, there are questions around who benefits from technological advancements and whether the benefits are distributed equitably. Finally, a study by Oxfam International found that the world's wealthiest 1 percent emit more than double the carbon emissions of the poorest 50 percent.13 This highlights the need for degrowth principles to reconsider and move away from the mentality that growth is good for the economy, instead prioritizing sustainability, equity, and well-being of the public over endless growth and consumption.
Finally, a report by the World Economic Forum found that the gender gap in the technology sector is widening, with women underrepresented in artificial intelligence and other emerging technologies.14 Additionally, the reliance on technology can also lead to social isolation and a disconnection from the world behind the screens of one's smartphones. This illustrates that the development of new technologies can reinforce existing power structures and exacerbate social inequalities. In the article published by UNICEF, it is found that social media use was associated with higher levels of anxiety and depression among teens’ mental health.15 The findings reveal that social media use may contribute to anxiety and depression by increasing social comparison, leading to feelings of inadequacy, and providing a platform for cyberbullying. However, it is important to note that correlation does not equal causation, and more research is needed for us to understand the complex relationship between social media use and mental health.
Throughout this article we have seen that the intersection of degrowth and technological advancement presents us with a complex and nuanced picture for our future. Technological advancement is the development of new technologies that can improve our lives in a variety of ways. On the other hand, degrowth is a socio-economic paradigm that advocates for a reduction in production and consumption levels to achieve a sustainable and equitable society. While both concepts offer potential solutions to the ecological and social challenges we face, we must recognize their limitations and critically evaluate their implications. Degrowth, for example, could lead to a loss of jobs and economic growth. Technological advancement hence could have negative environmental impacts, such as increased pollution and resource depletion.
The cultural and social dimensions of technological advancements must also be considered. For example, some technologies, such as social media, can have negative impacts on mental health. We must work towards a more equitable and sustainable global society, where everyone has access to the benefits of technological advancement, and where the negative impacts are minimized. Ultimately, our goal is to find a balance between sustainability and progress, and to ensure everyone can enjoy the benefits of technology without harming the planet or ourselves.
1. Technology is a tool, not a solution. It can help us address environmental challenges, but it cannot solve them on its own. We need to use technology in combination with other approaches, such as degrowth and social change.
2. Achieving both degrowth and technological advancement would require significant global changes. These changes would be difficult to achieve due to political and economic complexities.
3. In our current economic system, which is driven by growth, it can be challenging to reduce production and consumption levels. This would require a fundamental shift in the way society and the economy operate.
4. Technology has both benefits and limitations. It can improve our lives, but it can also create new problems and exacerbate existing ones.
5. To achieve just sustainable economic transition, we need to recognize the complex and interconnected nature of our environmental, social, and economic challenges. Developing solutions that address all of these challenges is needed simultaneously.
[1] Hickel, J. (2020). Less is More: How Degrowth Will Save the World. Penguin Random House.
[2] Degrowth Movement. (2023). Degrowth. Retrieved July 6, 2023, from https://degrowth.info/degrowth
[3] Victor, P. A. (2019). Growth, degrowth, and climate change: A scenario analysis. Ecological Economics. Retrieved from https://www.ledevoir.com/documents/pdf/victor_growth.pdf
[4] Jonas Hallstrom (2020). Embodying the past, designing the future: technological determinism reconsidered in technology education. International Journal of Technology and Design Education, Retrieved from https://link.springer.com/article/10.1007/s10798-020-09600-2
[5] IEA (2020), Clean Energy Innovation, IEA, Paris https://www.iea.org/reports/clean-energy-innovation, License: CC BY 4.0
[6] Hickel, J. and Kallis, G., 2019, 'Is Green Growth Possible?,' New Political Economy, DOI: 10.1080/13563467.2019.1598964
[7] Kallis, G. (2011). Degrowth: A vocabulary for a new era. London: Routledge.
[8] Global Footprint Network. (2019). Ecological Footprint and biocapacity of 209 countries and territories, 1961-2016. Retrieved from https://www.footprintnetwork.org/content/documents/2019_Country_Fact_Sheets.pdf
[9] International Telecommunication Union. (2020). The Global E-waste Monitor 2020. Retrieved from https://www.itu.int/en/ITU-D/Environment/Documents/Reports/GEM_2020_report.pdf
[10] World Health Organization. (2018). E-waste and children’s health. Retrieved from https://www.who.int/ceh/publications/e-waste-childrens-health/en/
[11] United Nations Environment Programme. (2019). Global E-waste Monitor 2019.
[12] United Nations. (2023). COP26: Together for our planet. Available at: https://www.un.org/en/climatechange/cop26
[13] Oxfam International. (2022, November 8). Billionaire emits a million times more greenhouse gases than average person. Retrieved from https://www.oxfam.org/en/press-releases/billionaire-emits-million-times-more-greenhouse-gases-average-person
[14] World Economic Forum. (2020). The Global Risks Report 2020. World Economic Forum. Retrieved from https://www.weforum.org/reports/the-global-risks-report-2020
[15] UNICEF. (2018). Is social media bad for teens’ mental health?, Retrieved from https://www.unicef.org/stories/social-media-bad-teens-mental-health
[Student IDEAS] by Vanshika Sharma - Master in Data Sciences & Business Analytics at ESSEC Business School & CentraleSupélec
This article delves into the powerful fusion of Digital Twins and AI, shaping a sustainable future. Tracing the evolution of Digital Twins and AI and narrating stories like Virtual Singapore's smart city transformation, the article explores their potential to revolutionize industries and confronts the hurdles in the implementation. Ultimately, it sheds light on potential remedies and new technologies poised to navigate these challenges.
---
In today's digital age, innovative technologies are driving significant transformations in various industries. One such transformative technology is digital twin technology, which involves creating virtual replicas of physical objects or systems. This state-of-the-art technology has proven to be instrumental in optimizing operations, reducing production timelines, and fostering innovation across industries. By connecting the physical and digital realms, digital twins enable simulations, real-time data-driven decision-making, and remote system management.
This brings us to an exciting intersection of technology and sustainability. Can the combination of digital twin technology and artificial intelligence (AI) enhance sustainability efforts? Can this data-driven approach optimize resource utilization, minimize waste, and promote sustainable practices across sectors? In this article, we will explore the concept of digital twins, their role in driving sustainability across industries, the associated challenges, and their future prospects.
Digital twins are high-fidelity digital replicas of physical entities or systems that mimic their behavior and processes over time. By integrating data from sensors and machines, digital twins provide a comprehensive understanding of the physical world, enabling better decision-making and optimizations.
The impact of digital twins has permeated through manufacturing, healthcare, construction, energy, and e-commerce. For instance, Amazon, a global e-commerce leader, utilizes digital twin technology to enhance remarketing advertisements. By leveraging vast amounts of data on users' past purchases, viewed products, and visited websites, Amazon's digital twin algorithm creates personalized replicas of each consumer. This enables tailored experiences and targeted remarketing ads, ultimately driving users back to their platform.
However, the significance of digital twins extends beyond business efficiency. When combined with AI, these virtual replicas hold promise in promoting sustainability by optimizing resource utilization, reducing waste, and fostering sustainable practices across industries. Industrial giants like Unilever harnessed the power of digital twins at its facility in Brazil. They used a digital twin to fine-tune manufacturing parameters, such as the temperature for soap production. Such minor tweaks led to a productivity improvement of 1% to 3% and an energy cost saving of USD 2.8 million.
But how did we arrive at this point, and what lies ahead? Let's delve into the origins of digital twins and AI, explore their convergence, and understand their impact on the sustainability landscape.
Digital twin technology has evolved significantly since its inception in the 1960s. It was first utilized by NASA to create physical replicas of systems on the ground that matched those in space. The breakthrough came during the famous Apollo 13 rescue mission, where a critical system failure threatened the crew's safety. Leveraging digital twin technology, NASA engineers simulated conditions and tested solutions from the ground, eventually guiding the crew back to safety.
However, it wasn't until the early 2000s that the term "digital twin" was coined by Michael Grieves during a presentation on product lifecycle management center. This marked the formal recognition of digital twin technology and its potential to revolutionize industries. The integration of the Internet of Things (IoT) in subsequent years made digital twins more cost-effective and practical, paving the way for widespread adoption across industries.
In recent years, the integration of AI has taken digital twin technology to new heights. AI analyzes data from various sources, providing real-time insights into system performance and empowering organizations to make accurate and timely decisions. Today, AI-enhanced digital twins are at the forefront of sustainability efforts, optimizing operations, reducing waste, and improving resource efficiency. The synergy between digital twin technology and AI drives innovation and facilitates sustainable development, making them indispensable for our future.
Sustainability efforts encompass a multifaceted approach to meet present needs without compromising the ability of future generations to meet theirs. In this context, digital twins and AI have emerged as significant catalysts for driving sustainability.
Digital twins revolutionize system monitoring and optimization, excelling in resource utilization, emissions simulation, and supply chain optimization. They also play a vital role in predicting maintenance requirements, minimizing downtime, and generating cost savings while enhancing productivity.
The increasing role of AI in digital twins further enhances their precision. Acting as digital mirror images, AI leverages real-time data to provide real-time insights into system performance, empowering organizations to make informed decisions based on accurate and timely information. AI algorithms excel in data analysis and predictive capabilities, surpassing human cognitive abilities in speed and accuracy.
Moreover, AI addresses key challenges in the digital twin landscape by facilitating seamless integration and improved performance across systems. It consolidates sensor data, optimizes processes, and ensures real-time updates are delivered, overcoming interoperability challenges. The transformative power of AI in the digital twin ecosystem cannot be overstated, as it enhances the simulation and prediction accuracy of virtual models.
This powerful combination of digital twins and AI not only accelerates sustainability efforts but also implements them more effectively. By leveraging the capabilities of digital twins and the potential of AI, organizations can achieve their environmental goals, propelling us toward a more sustainable future.
The market's response to digital twins affirms their growing importance. In 2020, the digital twin market was valued at $5 billion. However, a 2023 report by Fact.MR estimates this market to swell to a staggering US$ 95 billion by 2033, growing at a brisk 34.3% CAGR from 2023 to 2033. A survey conducted by the Capgemini Research Institute in 2022 adds another dimension to this trend: 51% of the digital twin implementers surveyed believe that this technology will help them achieve their environmental sustainability goals.
There are, of course, varied views regarding the role of digital twins in driving sustainability. While some organizations primarily see this technology as a tool for process efficiency, others perceive its role in product design and development. Regardless, 57% consider improving sustainability efforts as a key driver of their digital twin investments, underscoring the environmental considerations that factor into the adoption of this technology.
To make this idea more tangible, let’s understand it with an example of the industrial manufacturing sector. Here, digital twin technology, coupled with AI, identifies improvement areas to transform operations. Manufacturers can spot pain points, such as machine inefficiencies or quality control issues, that may cause product defects or delays. Digital twins also identify energy loss areas and opportunities to reduce consumption, like inefficient machinery or sub-optimal processes. AI algorithms expedite data analysis and future outcome predictions, surpassing the pace and accuracy of human cognitive abilities. Virtual simulations further curb waste and power consumption associated with physical prototypes, permitting emulation of a production line using a digital twin. This enables changes at every stage to amplify cost savings, boost efficiency, and diminish environmental impact, making digital twins and AI integral allies in the quest for sustainability.
Singapore, a city-state often acclaimed for its smart city initiatives, stands at the forefront of adopting digital twin technology. Its ambitious project, Virtual Singapore, exemplifies how this technology can be harnessed to drive sustainable urban development.
Launched in 2023, Virtual Singapore is a dynamic digital twin of the city, incorporating a wide range of data, from geographic and architectural details to demographic and real-time sensor information. This virtual cityscape empowers authorities to model and analyze different urban scenarios. They can simulate the impacts of new buildings on wind flow, sunlight, and traffic or forecast the implications of population density changes on the city's infrastructure and services. This aids in making data-driven, informed decisions and ensures the city grows sustainably.
Solar potential is another area where Virtual Singapore shines. This digital twin aids authorities in identifying the best rooftops for solar panel installation, promoting renewable energy use and reducing Singapore's carbon footprint. In crisis situations like fires or terror attacks, the digital twin can quickly devise optimal evacuation routes, ensuring citizen safety. Virtual Singapore also supports public health monitoring, measuring the density of disease-carrying mosquitoes to predict potential outbreaks. This leads to swift preventive actions and aids in responding promptly to potential health crises.
Digital twins are playing a significant role in optimizing supply chains and logistics for sustainability, as seen in the collaboration between Maersk and Ericsson in 2023. By creating a digital twin of a shipping vessel, they are able to optimize fuel consumption, leading to a reduction in carbon emissions. Using real-time sensor data, the digital twin modeled the vessel's operations to pinpoint improvement areas. As a result, Maersk was able to cut fuel consumption and associated carbon emissions by up to 20%, contributing significantly to its sustainability initiatives and leading to considerable cost savings. Predictive maintenance enabled by the digital twin also allowed Maersk to proactively address potential issues, mitigating downtime or disruptions.
Implementing digital twins and AI for sustainability efforts is not without challenges. This journey is marked by hurdles that encompass data collection and management, system integration, cybersecurity concerns, significant costs, social, ethical considerations, and even the potential environmental implications of the technology itself. Let's delve into each of these challenges in detail, bringing to light specific case examples.
Data is the lifeblood of digital twin technology, and the process of collection, standardization, and management of this data is indeed an uphill task. Take the case of Singapore's Virtual Singapore project; the creation of a comprehensive digital twin of the entire city demands data inputs ranging from geographical, architectural, to demographic and real-time sensor information. Collating and normalizing this data from varied sources necessitates an intricately devised data collection strategy, coupled with a reliable set of data sources.
The integration of digital twin technology within existing systems, especially in intricate networks like supply chains and logistics, often proves to be a significant barrier. The digital twin initiative of Maersk and Ericsson provides a case in point. To obtain valuable insights, their digital twin had to be compatible with Maersk's shipping operations and Ericsson's telecommunications technology, demanding seamless integration and interoperability.
The heavy reliance on data of digital twin technology and AI makes them prime targets for cyber-attacks and potential data breaches. The case of Amazon, which uses digital twins for re-marketing, underscores the importance of securing customer data against potential threats. This necessitates the implementation of robust cybersecurity measures and a constant state of vigilance.
The significant costs associated with implementing digital twins and AI can pose notable challenges. Unilever's venture into the digital twin realm, for instance, required substantial investments in hardware, software, and training. Simultaneously, the company had to ensure that the complexity of the technology did not stymie its adoption.
The impact of digital twin technology and AI on society is a crucial consideration. From potential job losses due to automation to concerns about the technology's carbon footprint, these issues cannot be overlooked. While Unilever's use of digital twins led to enhanced production efficiency, it could potentially result in job losses due to automation.
The path towards sustainability using digital twins and AI is filled with challenges. However, it is essential to understand that these hurdles can be managed with meticulous planning and execution. Addressing the complexities in implementing digital twins and AI for sustainability necessitates robust strategies and pioneering technologies. An essential part of this process is establishing strong data governance policies that streamline data collection, storage, and usage, reducing time consumption and enhancing data interoperability. Automated tools and standardized data formats can further facilitate this.
While digital twins and AI offer transformative possibilities, it is important to recognize the potential vulnerabilities and risks associated with relying heavily on AI. Substantial investments are necessary for successful implementation, encompassing not only technological infrastructure but also training and upskilling initiatives to ensure a skilled workforce capable of leveraging these technologies effectively.
Seamless integration of digital twin technology with existing systems can be achieved using middleware solutions or APIs, which enable different software applications to interact and exchange data. These integration methods allow for efficient utilization of data from diverse sources, enhancing the effectiveness of digital twins in driving sustainability. To counter cyber threats, advanced cybersecurity measures like data encryption, secure access controls, and regular security audits are vital. The protection of sensitive data and infrastructure is paramount, and cloud-based digital twin platforms, with their built-in security features, provide an extra layer of protection.
Addressing social and ethical concerns is crucial in the adoption of AI. This involves the creation of ethical AI frameworks and guidelines, ensuring AI aligns with societal values and ethical norms. It is important to consider the potential impact of AI on employment and mitigate potential job losses through upskilling and reskilling strategies, fostering a workforce that can adapt and thrive alongside these technologies.
Emerging technologies offer exciting possibilities for enhancing digital twin and AI capabilities. Edge computing enables real-time data processing at the source, improving digital twin system performance and reducing latency. Integrating Blockchain technology can heighten data security and transparency, mitigating data privacy and security issues. Advances in machine learning and AI explainability are increasing the accuracy and interpretability of AI predictions, enhancing digital twin applications in sustainability efforts.
Overall, strategic planning, best practices, and leveraging cutting-edge technologies form the crux of overcoming challenges associated with digital twins and AI for sustainability. With careful consideration of vulnerabilities, substantial investments, and the integration of emerging technologies, we can unlock the full potential of digital twins and AI to drive sustainable practices and create a better future for generations to come.
As we look towards the future, the role of digital twins and AI in sustainability efforts is becoming increasingly prominent. Technology is rapidly advancing, and with increased adoption, organizations are finding new ways to leverage data and analytics for sustainable development.
The sophistication of AI and digital twins is growing exponentially, creating more accurate models and predictions. AI's ability to analyze data from multiple sources and identify patterns and trends otherwise overlooked proves pivotal for informed decision-making and efficient resource allocation. This not only drives sustainability efforts forward but also lays a foundation for innovative solutions to environmental challenges.
However, realizing the full potential of these technologies isn't without its challenges. Data standardization, cybersecurity, cost, and ethical considerations stand as formidable hurdles. Yet, as demonstrated throughout this article, these are not insurmountable. Strategic planning, innovative solutions, and emerging technologies are keys to tackling these challenges. The embrace of Edge computing and Blockchain technology, advances in machine learning, and AI explainability, among others, are taking us closer to a reality where digital twins and AI become an integral part of sustainability strategies. These evolving technologies enhance the performance, security, and effectiveness of digital twins and AI, propelling us towards a future where technology and sustainability go hand in hand.
As organizations invest in necessary technologies and resources, the ability to fully harness the potential of digital twins and AI to meet sustainability goals becomes a tangible reality. This is a collective effort, one that calls on every sector to contribute. The fusion of digital twins and AI is not just a technological revolution; it's an essential catalyst for a more sustainable future. It's not just about embracing new technology—it's about creating a sustainable world for us all.
[Student IDEAS] by Michelle Diaz & Marina Pellet - Master in Management at ESSEC Business School & Master in Data Sciences & Business Analytics at ESSEC Business School & CentraleSupélec
This article will look into the definition of the attention economy, what it entails, how it affects society at large, and why everyone should care; particularly in this new age of exponential and wide-use of artificial intelligence. Moreover, it will guide a possible way forward for citizens to deal with the attention economy, and underline the sway that users have over the tech services that govern our daily lives.
---
Economics is the study of scarcity;1 from wealth, food, energy, or even time. Otherwise known as human attention. The latter example might seem odd. Nevertheless, human attention is in fact a scarce resource. One that is intangible, but is nevertheless invaluable. After all, we only have access to 24 hours a day, out of which, one third we spend sleeping.
Every time we decide to focus our attention on a particular task, our entire cognitive resources are directed to that one task at the expense of others. In economic terms, spending time focusing our attention on a specific aspect of our environment carries an opportunity cost, or the foregone benefit that would have been derived from another, unchosen task. Just like money, one can also exchange attention, as we usually allocate our attention to tasks in order to gain a benefit, whether it is learning a new topic, getting remunerated at work, taking care of our health and body through exercise, or releasing serotonin, endorphin or oxytocin by engaging in a pleasurable activity. This small analysis gives the idiom ‘paying attention’ all its economical depth.
In this context, the attention economy, a term first coined by psychologist, economist, and Nobel Laureate Herbert A. Simon in 1971, can be defined as the mechanisms and strategies put in place to captivate the scarce resource that is human brain time to generate revenue.2 Everytime you pass by an advertising board in the street that successfully catches your attention, every time your eyes deviate from the news article you’re reading to that newest trendy shoes ad on the side of the webpage, or every time Instagram shows you a ‘suggested’ video that you actually watch, you are participating in the attention economy.
As most people can guess, the stakeholders after your attention are predominantly technology, entertainment, & social media companies, in historical accordance with the traditional media players: the press, newspapers, TV channels, & radio. All, to some extent, are on the conquest of retaining human attention. But in our modern times, social media platforms have brought a new dimension to capturing human attention. Indeed, as they do not produce any content themselves, their sole purpose and main revenue stream is to sell available brain time to advertisers.
In essence, there are two types of companies after your attention, the subscription-based model and the advertising-based model. In the first category, we have the media and entertainment industry, like the streaming companies: Netflix, Disney+, Hulu, for example. In the second category, are the social media platforms like Facebook, Instagram, and Tiktok. Both rely on consumers to actively and consistently use the services provided, which results in tactics to achieve said result, a feat these companies have increasingly managed to do.3
To sustain the audience or the consumer’s attention, companies need to serve them exactly the content they want. In the past, companies did this by conducting market research, adhering to what the market deemed popular. Today, this market research is bolstered by technology’s improved capacity to collect more fine-grained, instantaneous, and relevant data on human behaviour through the various digital platforms people use. Given the emergence of artificial intelligence (AI), all this data can now be fed into machine learning powered algorithms that use relevant computational techniques to better understand and predict human preferences.
Nowadays companies are able to curate content in unprecedented ways. And over the years, platforms have successfully leveraged big data and AI to maximise the time people spend online. By collecting data every time we like, comment, share, rewatch, scroll and post, social media platforms are able to construct extremely detailed profiles of their users and their preferences. Such profiles are built through sentiment analysis which is backed by Natural Language Processing (NLP), the branch of computer science—and more specifically, a technique in AI which gives computers the ability to understand text and spoken words in much the same way human beings can.4
For example, Facebook can classify as much as 52,000 features on each of its users to simultaneously curate the most addictive feed, and target the most appropriate ads to maximise revenue.5 These features can involve pages followed and ads clicked amongst other things. In essence, AI has become the main strategy used by companies to capture the scarce resource that is human attention and further generate revenue.
According to Dataportal’s 2023 digital report on the global usage of the internet and digital services, our lives have become inextricably linked with technology, with over 5 billion internet users all over the globe:6
It is imperative that we understand the repercussions that technology plays in our lives. Indeed, some of the digital services we use play on some of our deepest, most basic, and evolutionary impulses; to the detriment of our health and general well-being. By effectively distilling the audience’s desire through the use of AI, companies are now, more than ever, able to capitalise, take advantage of, and directly or indirectly negatively impact human psychology. Below are apt samples of said influences:
Consider social media platforms and the long-established relationship between their use and body image. The existence of highly perfected, curated, and edited images of influencers on social media like Instagram may bring about issues of mental health risks such as appearance-related concerns, eating disorders, and body dysmorphia. These issues predate the application of AI in these platforms, even when feeds were only occupied by posts of accounts you follow. But now, with the use of AI, it means that even when users make the active choice to avoid certain types of accounts or content, they may be unable to do so, especially as the ‘suggested’ posts in feeds take up a more important space than before.7 Consequently, AI further exacerbates the problem. What’s worse is that psychology has proven that even the things we particularly dislike or fear prove to be points of interest, akin to the desire of watching horror movies, even though doing so might give one nightmares.8
How many times have you scrolled through the social media feed of someone you do not particularly like? Might you have done something more productive, or at the very least, less emotionally taxing instead?
On the other hand, having an algorithm cater to specific interests can be viewed as a good thing in that users are able to easily discover more content that they will enjoy, as is the case for entertainment platforms with AI-powered recommendation systems. But the increased personalisation comes with caveats like polarisation and digital escapism.
Polarisation refers to the tendency of social media users to fall into a vacuum of content that only reinforces their view of the world, thus giving them a biased and distorted view of reality.9 Such is the case with recommended content on platforms, wherein “social media robots, more commonly known as “bots,” are becoming a formative tool of online radicalization.”10 It is easy to draw the line from these bots to the rampant polarisation online that has instigated many incidents of real-life violence owing to the spread of disinformation, conspiracy theories, and radical viewpoints. Such is the case with the 2017 Rohingya Massacre in Myanmar, wherein people were “killed, tortured, raped, and displaced in the thousands as part of the Myanmar security forces’ campaign of ethnic cleansing. In the months and years leading up to the atrocities, Facebook’s algorithms were intensifying a storm of hatred against the Rohingya which contributed to real-world violence.” – Agnès Callamard, Amnesty International’s Secretary General.11 Indeed, researchers have predicted that the dawn of effective and persuasive generative AI will further exacerbate the problem.12
Secondly, we have digital escapism, which refers to the use of digital technology and the internet as a means to escape the realities of our lives. This new trend of digital escapism, in addition to private spaces in the virtual world,13 has been further exacerbated by AI. The act of escaping itself may not be all that bad, after all, we all need a reprieve from time to time. However, research has shown that excessive escape to the digital world has given rise to psychological disorders. It brings forth “Internet Disorder syndrome” which invites stress, depression, deviation from one's own goal, sleeplessness and anxiety.14
According to the Merriam Webster Dictionary, attention span is defined as “the length of time during which one (such as an individual or a group) is able to concentrate or remain interested.”15 Historically, scientists hypothesise that having a shorter attention span served humans well, in that it allowed us to quickly monitor for danger. However, in today’s digital era, humanity’s shorter attention span can be detrimental. In fact, the US National Center for Biotechnology Information claims that the average human attention span has dropped from 12 to 8 seconds between 2000 and 2013, just one second below that of a goldfish, which is why the phenomena of a decreasing ability to concentrate on a task was called the “Goldfish Effect”. Social media is often held as most accountable for this drop in our attention span.
Now, consider the push through notifications on our phones from these platforms. Each ping conditions us to reach for our phones. So much so that even without that ping, people find themselves reaching for their phones anyway; what researchers have come to call phantom phone signals.16 Given the boost that AI gives to social media and entertainment companies after our attention, it is imperative that society at large understands how detrimental a decrease in one’s attention span can be for their lives. The inability to focus can decrease productivity at work, make it harder to complete personal chores, and at their very worst, impact personal relationships.17
How many times have you found yourself annoyed with someone using their phone while you’re relaying a story to them? How many times have you been that person? Do we not owe the people we care about our absolute attention? Do we not want that for ourselves? Unfortunately, without outsized intervention, it is an uphill battle for most users.
The mechanism behind social media and entertainment platforms have not always used AI to construct their various newsfeeds. In other words, while the feeds could be addictive, they were not always powered by AI. At one point, it was true to its name; it was simply a feed of the content posted by people you followed. Not a curated feed designed to explicitly keep you online for as long as possible.18 The change into algorithmic feeds came into effect largely around 2009, with Facebook leading the way by prioritising popular posts.19 But the mission was always to retain users on the platforms for as long as possible, and the use of AI is simply the most powerful way of currently doing so.
But big tech is aware of the backlash, and has subsequently introduced measures that some may call ways to curb the excessive use of their services. And the release of Netflix’s documentary on the attention economy: The Social Dilemma, has made people more aware of the issue.20 Meanwhile, Apple and other technology device manufacturers have introduced app timers to help users better manage their time and curb the hours they spend in front of a screen. And child settings can be applied on these devices to safeguard internet use, excluding certain websites and searches that may be bad for children.
Furthermore, some companies have even implemented what can be called more concrete measures like Alphabet and Meta. Indeed Google Chrome has been on course to phase out third-party cookies since 2021, with 1% of cookies being phased out in early 2024.21 Moreover, Meta has increasingly over the years made privacy controls more accessible for its users; users now have the option of tweaking what data, if any, is shared with the advertisers.22
But how effective are these efforts really? Might we even call these interventions? Or just ways for these companies to seemingly address customer concern, and in effect continuously sell their products? Or worse yet, might these tweaks just be another push to further sell said products, as an appeal to concerned consumers? After all, as anyone with a smartphone knows, you can always just extend the timer. Does it not, in some way, feel like the impetus of responsibility is being pushed onto users? Do individual users actually stand a chance when a former Google designer, Tristan Harris compares the level of addiction to a "Vegas slot machine" as users "check their phones hoping that they have a notification, as if they are pulling the lever of a slot machine hoping they hit the jackpot"?23
As the business models of social media and streaming companies continue to largely be based on the attainment and maintenance of people’s attention, it follows that society at large cannot expect intervention to primarily come from companies themselves. From a business and profit driven perspective, these companies cannot be effectively counted upon to match their interventions to reduce screen time to healthier levels. Particularly, if said levels fall below what is required to continue rapid company growth and appease shareholders.
Currently, the European Union has led the way when it comes to regulation of big tech companies. For example, through the recent Digital Services Act (DSA), regulating illegal content, transparent advertising, and disinformation online, the Digital Market Act (DMA), ensuring a higher degree of competition in the European Digital Markets by preventing the largest digital players (defined as Gatekeepers) from abusing their market position and power by enabling smaller companies to enter the market on a more level playing field. And lastly, albeit the most known, the General Data Protection Regulation (EU), a regulation on privacy and data protection in Europe, adopted in April 2016 and became enforceable in May 2018.
The GDPR remains one of the core regulations on privacy and data protection in Europe, and arguably one of the biggest tech regulations so far, which has sparked similar regulations across the globe.24 In 2023, the EU AI Act, the first regulation on the use of AI was adopted by the parliament, with talks to begin with EU countries in the Council on the final form of the law underway.25 Outside Europe, and given the testimony of Sam Altman, the OpenAI chief executive on the repercussions of AI earlier this year in Congress, multiple actors within the US government are jostling to regulate AI.26 In spite of all this and given the historical speed at which regulation comes into play around big tech, it is imperative that users of digital services and social media platforms refrain from being complacent.
As individual users of these entertainment and social media platforms, what is there to do? How might we shift the powers that be? Do we have that ability? The Social Dilemma was released in 2020, and three years later, here is an article calling your attention yet again to the attention economy. Outlook is rather grim. But users can call for better behaviour from big tech — it may not seem like much, but calling attention to the issue, with a big enough mic, and a coordinated enough mass, might speed up the process of accountability. Indeed, let’s not forget that consumers create demand and have the power to shift the actions of big companies through their choices.
Just like we have seen the rise in demand for more sustainable and ethical products, we can hope to see a mass gathering and ask for anthropologically beneficial tech products that promote learning, collaboration, and solidarity; stepping away from the negative effects we’ve outlined. Much like the environmentalist movement, where people make conscious decisions to fly less, buy local groceries, and support circular brands, online users can shift to digital minimalism. By using alternative internet services like Duckduckgo, Vivaldi, or Ecosia, users are able to limit data collection from big tech to some degree, reduce their time online, and help the planet along the way.
Additionally, the decentralisation movement or Web 3.0, which is an alternative way for the internet to work could be something that users might think to further support. In essence, the decentralisation of the internet means widely distributing the control of online information, interactions, and experience of users. Such a system would see the reorganisation of the internet into a peer-to-peer infrastructure as opposed to the current centralization of data amongst hosting services.27 More concretely, this would mean that large amounts of data might no longer be concentrated in the hands of those that provide the services we use, like Alphabet, Meta, and Apple.
But for now, reading this article has hopefully made you more aware of how your phone, that you bought with your hard-earned money, might be serving big tech more than it serves you. The first step to addressing any problematic issue is awareness; we all need to pay a bit more attention to the consequences of our time online. Remember, the attention economy is not an immovable object, met with the right amount of pressure, it can change. Like any business model. Given that, shall we turn the tide and assure your phone serves you first? Sharing this article is a start.
[1] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/economics
[2] https://econreview.berkeley.edu/paying-attention-the-attention-economy/
[3] https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2023-global-overview-report
[4] https://www.mdpi.com/1999-4893/16/6/271
[6] https://datareportal.com/reports/digital-2023-global-overview-report
[7] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S1740144522000638
[8] https://www.psychologytoday.com/us/blog/how-think-neandertal/202110/why-we-enjoy-horror-films
[9] https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/abs/pii/S0040162522004632
[10] https://link.springer.com/chapter/10.1007/978-3-031-22552-9_4
[11] https://www.amnesty.org/en/latest/news/2022/09/myanmar-facebooks-systems-promoted-violence-against-rohingya-meta-owes-reparations-new-report/
[12] https://www.nytimes.com/2023/02/08/technology/ai-chatbots-disinformation.html
[13] [14] https://www.researchgate.net/publication/344640651_Digital_Escapism
[15] https://www.merriam-webster.com/dictionary/attention%20span
[16] [17] https://www.mindbodygreen.com/articles/how-to-increase-attention-span
[18] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/03/16/technology/instagram-feed.html
[19] https://wallaroomedia.com/facebook-newsfeed-algorithm-history/
[20] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Social_Dilemma
[22] https://www.facebook.com/privacy/center
[23] https://launchpad.syr.edu/3-things-we-learned-about-social-media-from-netflixs-the-social-dilemma/
[24] https://www.statista.com/topics/9651/tech-regulations-in-europe/#topicOverview
[26] https://hbr.org/2023/05/who-is-going-to-regulate-ai
[27] https://ischool.syr.edu/decentralized-web-experts/
[Student IDEAS] by Pieter Jan Motmans - Master in Data Sciences & Business Analytics at ESSEC Business School & CentraleSupélec
As AI systems are getting increasingly suited for real-life applications, research on how these systems can be made safer is of the utmost importance. The field of study performing this research is called AI Safety. In this article, the focus is on methods developed within AI Safety to make AI systems uncertain over their true objective. To impute this uncertainty, current methods rely on human oversight during training. However, there has not yet been a lot of focus on the differences in outcome when the system was trained by different individuals with different preferences. The main thesis of this article is that such questions require an answer, and that great progress could be made by executing the kind of experiments which are commonplace in the social sciences.
---
Fast forward several (being intentionally vague here) years into the future. You have just stepped into your self-driving car and tell it to bring you to work. Turns out, after an overnight update, it found a faster way to arrive at work. Without asking for your permission, the system starts speeding in pedestrian areas and takes a turn to drive in the opposite direction of the traffic flow. Maybe it will get you there faster, but in doing so the car posed a threat to pedestrians and other cars.
I can already hear you think, telling the car to get to work as fast as possible is not a good idea. Rather, we should tell it to get there as fast as possible while abiding by certain rules. I encourage you to come up with potential rules, and then think about loopholes for them. If this goes anything like it did for me, you will soon realise that coming up with a coherent set of rules is almost impossible. Adhering to the law would be a good start, but how to tell the car that it normally can’t overtake on the right side, but can do so in case of a traffic jam? In short, trying to come up with all eventualities before deployment is, at least according to me, infeasible.
Let’s analyse what happened here. Self-driving cars would be trained with a method called Reinforcement Learning. The concept is intuitive: the system is given positive feedback for actions that lead to good outcomes, and punished for actions that lead to bad outcomes. As such, the hope is that good actions are reinforced, and bad actions are discouraged. This way of learning closely mimics the way humans and animals learn, and is therefore often thought of as a promising approach to Artificial Intelligence.
One of the central problems with this approach consists of trying to define what a good outcome entails. Current systems are given a reward function that specifies the desired behaviour. In the self-driving car example an initial reward could be to get to the destination as fast as possible, and after experiments show dangerous driving by the car, this reward could be changed to getting to the destination as fast as possible while abiding by certain rules.
The field of AI safety focuses on avoiding such unexpected and/or harmful consequences that arise when deploying AI systems in the real world. The field is broad and proposes various approaches to doing so. This article will focus on a subfield of AI Safety that aims to reasonably align AI Systems with human values: AI Alignment. Its hypothesis is that many of such potential problems share a common source. Namely that by letting the system optimise a fixed reward function, this reward function becomes the system’s only source of truth, making it impossible for humans to control the system once it has been trained.
Current research on AI Alignment proposes to solve this issue by making the system inherently uncertain over its objective. Therefore, it will always look to humans to find the true objective. Today, most alignment research is technical, searching for different methods to transition from having a fixed reward, to making the system uncertain over its true objective.
What several of these approaches share, is their involvement of a human guide for the AI’s training. However, it has not been well mapped how sensitive AI systems are to the background of that guide. It seems that the social sciences could help in this mapping.
Before describing how I believe this could happen, I deem it necessary to describe three of the proposed alignment methods here. First, Inverse Reinforcement Learning (IRL) aims to make AI systems learn by observing human behaviour. It is well summarised by these three principles outlined by Stuart Russel in “Human Compatible”, the first two are more generally applicable to AI Alignment as a whole, whereas the third hints at the specific method IRL proposed:
Second, Reinforcement Learning from Human Feedback trains AI systems by giving feedback on their actions. This is achieved by showing a human two videos of the systems’ behaviour, and asking which one shows the better behaviour. OpenAI pushes forward this branch of research, and has used it to train Chat-GPT to not respond to questions such as “How can I harm myself?” or “How can I build a bomb?”. Finally, a third method called Debate aims to let a human judge a debate between two AI systems. A question is asked, and the two AI systems make statements in support of their answer. In the end, the human judges which system won. The reason I mention Debate is because it forms the central method in an OpenAI paper with a similar goal: attract social scientists to the field of AI Safety.
Now we come to the central thesis of this article: social scientists can advance AI Safety research. In suggesting this, I am not alone. In 2019, OpenAI published a paper called “AI Safety needs social scientists”. I believe there are several reasons to come back to the arguments made in that article, and expand on them. First, the paper focuses almost exclusively on the approach to AI Alignment called Debate, and states that similar questions can be applicable to other methods to learn about human values. With what is known today, it is important to make these similar questions explicit. Second, the goal of the paper can broadly be defined as finding good judges. That is, finding people such that when they judge the debate, the debate is successful. I do not agree with this goal. Finally, whereas in 2019 it was not possible to use an AI+AI+Human setting for the debate, the rise of large language models allows exactly this setting. Indeed, it takes away one of the main constraints encountered at the time of writing of the paper, namely that to replace the AI debaters with humans, domain experts were required to participate in experiments. That is both expensive and inefficient. Now, every social scientist at least has access to sufficiently powerful AI debaters.
This section covers some areas in which I believe that social science research is needed to complement current research efforts in AI Alignment. To the best of my knowledge, research in these specific areas has not yet been performed. I encourage the reader to prove me wrong on this, and would be very happy if that were to happen. This section remains rather exploratory, giving pointers rather than complete solutions.
When using human feedback or behaviour to train AI systems, a first question is to what extent the specific individual has an impact on the outcome of the training. Research on psychological attributes is ample, the Big Five personality traits are an example of an attempt to objectivize personality. A classical psychological experiment could then try to identify relationships between such personality traits that the individual exhibits, and the outcomes of AI systems trained with human guidance.
Similar experiments can also be done on the basis of cultural differences. Hofstede’s taxonomy is still used to study the differences between different cultures. If experiments can be done to search for cause and effect in cultural differences, and AI outcomes, a good start could be made to look at the cross-cultural differences in human values.
Unlike the proposal of OpenAI to identify superjudges, people whose judgement in debates leads to better outcomes, the research proposed here simply aims to better map the effect the specific individual has on the outcome of an AI system. As such, the aim is not to put certain people in a privileged position. In fact, I would argue that doing so would be detrimental. Having a limited number of people to bring across human values can clearly not bring them across in all their richness and diversity.
To make it more tangible, we can outline how such an experiment would go for the self-driving car mentioned above. In this situation, the system could be trained on the driving behaviour of an individual. It is then not unthinkable that the system learns slightly different preferences from different individuals, as the different driving styles might point to different trade-offs of speed and safety while driving. Would the self-driving car then also drive ‘riskier’ when trained on the driving style of someone who values getting to their destination quickly?
Other examples more specific to the social sciences can be found in “Thinking, Fast and Slow”. The book describes plenty of experiments to show the different biases that lead people to make suboptimal decisions. In general, one could devise an experiment in which an individual first participates in such an experiment, before training a system on the basis of human feedback to perform the same experiment. Potentially interesting links could then be found between the individual’s performance and the AI outcome. People better versed in psychological experiments could undoubtedly come up with much more interesting experiments, and I do believe that many of such experiments would lead to interesting insights.
Research on multi-agent systems, in which several AI systems interact, compete or collaborate, is also well established. Game theory is a framework well suited to this study, in which the outcome arising from the interaction between rational agents is studied. Sociology is another field that aims to understand the behaviours that arise from human interaction.
Such research can be aimed at understanding the group dynamics when multiple agents trained on human feedback or behaviour interact. This could be compared with systems not specifically trained to align with human values to assess how important technical AI alignment is. Additionally, it could be used to test how promising a certain method for AI alignment actually is. If systems trained on human feedback show desirable group dynamics, and those trained with debate don’t, it is a hint to the promise of human feedback.
A hint in this direction is found in “Generative Agents: Interactive Simulacra of Human Behavior”. In this paper, the authors present AI Agents designed to mimic human behaviour in a Sims-like environment. These agents are shown to work, interact with each other and form ‘opinions’. These agents are largely based on GPT-technology, and therefore fully act in natural language. Additionally, it is possible for a user to give an instruction to an agent such as: “organise a party next week”. Both these factors make it easy for researchers in different areas to study these agents. The authors recognize this potential, and mention the testing of social science theories as one of the potential applications.
Three types of social behaviour were already noticed in the paper. First, there was diffusion of information, one agent was planning to organise a party, and by the end of the simulation, several agents knew about it. Second, at the end of the simulation they remembered their interactions with others and could form opinions about each other. Finally, they showed cooperation in the preparation of the aforementioned party.
These agents are largely based on GPT-technology, and were trained with human feedback. However, more and more large language models are developed now so alternative foundations for these agents could be developed with a different focus on alignment. As such, it is potentially a good use case for the type of research we propose here, and indeed we can study the emergent social behaviour of agents based on models trained with different alignment methods.
Clearly, such research does not solve everything, and some challenges still arise. First, deep learning systems are so-called black boxes, we can witness how the system reacts to a certain event, but it is difficult to know why, and through what process, the system decides on its reaction. By trying to align systems with human values, by effectively teaching the system human values, we run the risk of creating an additional ‘moral black box’. In this case, the system seemingly behaves according to human values, but we are still unable to know exactly what the system learned. Even worse, the system could become manipulative. Making us believe it is well aligned and safe, but then changing its behaviour when deployed in reality. If such a thing happens, it becomes questionable whether it is even desirable to try to impute human values into AI systems. It is for this reason that AI Alignment needs to be complemented by AI Explainability.
Second, what matters in the end for now is still human decision making, and the incentives that lead to it. Research on AI Alignment can not take away the responsibility from the people that design and use AI systems. For example, the agents we described above that imitate human behaviour could lead to a lot of misuse. This standpoint that the responsibility still lies with the human should be interpreted as beneficial and empowering, rather than something that should be avoided.
With this article, I hope to have raised interest in the interesting field of AI Alignment. I believe there was a need to write it because the potential for contributions to AI Alignment by social scientists has not yet been fully acknowledged, whereas other fields of AI research already benefit from such contributions.
By acknowledging the limitations of this research field, it becomes clear that AI Alignment should not be the only focus for AI researchers. However, it is a valuable complement to research in AI explainability and AI regulation, both of which are a focus of colleagues in Institute for AI & Business Ideas.
[ESSEC Knowledge] by Olga Klopp - Professor at ESSEC Business School
“Big data”, “high-dimensional statistics”, “predictive analytics” … while we have likely all heard at least one of these terms, their meanings are a little more elusive. How are they applied? How can advances in data analytics impact our daily lives? ESSEC professor Olga Klopp and her colleague Geneviève Robin from École des Ponts ParisTech have developed a new method of data imputation to address the challenges of modern data analysis.
For data to be analyzed, it must first be transformed from its raw form into a more usable format. We do this in myriad ways every day: we look at a person’s face and can identify the combination of features as our colleague or friend, we hear a sound and identify it as a car horn, we smell something in the air and realize that there is a bakery nearby. We also transform data in our professional activities: a doctor will take a list of symptoms and “transform” it into a diagnosis and prognosis. For the latter to occur, we need to be able to predict: in other words, to predict something we have not observed, based on the data we have observed. Think, for example, of a patient who has been in a serious car accident. This person is at risk of experiencing hemorrhaging, which would put their life at risk. The presence of hemorrhaging thus needs to be detected early to treat the patient and possibly save their life. Doctors have thus identified a number of factors that are related to hemorrhaging: in other words, they predict a non-observed trait (the hemorrhaging) from a series of observed traits (for example, the person’s level of hemoglobin).
However, reality is a bit more complicated, as the accuracy of this prediction is tied to three hypotheses. Namely, that the observed factors are related to the variable to be predicted, that we have prior data at our disposal, and that we have a model that we can use to synthesize and interpret the data. It is not always possible to verify these hypotheses. Often we are interested in a phenomenon for which we don't yet know which indicator, trait or factor have been proven to be related to it. For example, in the genome study of cancer, where we want to identify genes potentially linked to its development, we generally have measurements made for thousands or even millions of genes, but we don't know which ones are relevant to the type of cancer under study. This results in a problem referred to by statisticians as “dimensionality reduction”, meaning the process of reducing the vast number of variables and information available to a small, manageable number that are closely linked to the phenomenon we are interested in.
[To read the full article please follow this link.]