DATA AND AI ARE CHANGING THE WAY ORGANIZATIONS THINK, DECIDE, AND ORGANIZE. IT’S TIME HUMANITIES, MANAGEMENT AND SOCIAL SCIENCES GET INVOLVED.
Metalab

NEWS

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur. Excepteur sint occaecat cupidatat non proident, sunt in culpa qui officia deserunt mollit anim id est laborum.

EVENTS

[Student IDEAS] by Karen Taubenberger - Master in Management at ESSEC Business School

Abstract

This article discusses the rise of generative AI chatbots like Dr. ChatGPT in healthcare. The article explores the potential benefits and risks of this technology, and the challenges that need to be addressed for safe and effective use. It also highlights the need for new regulations to govern the use of generative AI in healthcare.

---

Accessing health information online has become common in today’s society, with half of European Union citizens actively seeking health information online.1 In addition to cheap, easy and quick access to medical information, online search empowers patients to actively participate in the diagnosis and treatment process.2 Publicly accessible chatbots like ChatGPT are poised to further revolutionize the way individuals seek answers to medical questions. But how reliable is the new ‘Dr. ChatGPT’?

The rise of ‘Dr. ChatGPT’

ChatGPT has elevated online search to unprecedented heights. Open AI’s chatbot operates on a foundation of a Large Language Model (LLM), a deep learning technique that can comprehend and generate human language text. In a recent study, ChatGPT (GPT-4) showed impressive performance compared to human doctors in symptom review, with the appropriate diagnosis listed within the top three results in 95% of cases.3 This vastly outperformed traditional symptom checkers such as the health website WebMD. 

Around 7% of Google searches are health-related, the equivalent of 70,000 searches per minute.4  Given the rapid user growth of ChatGPT, it is likely that ‘Dr. Google’ will soon be augmented or even substituted by ‘Dr. ChatGPT’. With nearly half of the European population showing low health literacy1, chatbots could significantly improve the consumer’s understanding of health-related information.

A direct comparison between ChatGPT and Google Search assessed their effectiveness in conveying the most relevant information for specific medical inquiries from a patient's viewpoint, while also evaluating patient education materials. While ChatGPT fared better when offering general medical knowledge, it scored worse when responding to questions seeking medical recommendations and guidance.5

Not only are consumers increasingly likely to use ‘Dr. ChatGPT’, the rise of generative AI may  also drastically change the way medical professionals work.

Opportunities – A new patient journey

Healthcare has traditionally been a sector heavily reliant on human-to-human interaction. However, with an estimated global shortage of 10 million health workers by 20306 and strained health system finances, healthcare delivery requires transformation. With the advancement of generative AI, there is potential to unlock a US$1 trillion improvement opportunity within the healthcare industry. 

Generative AI, a subset of machine learning, trains models on existing data patterns to generate new yet similar data. This technology is uniquely suited to unlocking the vast potential of healthcare's disparate, unstructured data—clinical notes, diagnostic images, medical charts, and more. Generative AI has multiple benefits in a healthcare setting over traditional machine learning techniques (discriminative models): Unsupervised learning allows to tap into this rich data pool without the need for expensive data labeling. Moreover, it opens up new use cases compared to traditional machine learning methods, enabling text synthesis and the generation of synthetic data sets. 

Use cases for medical professionals fall broadly into administrative and clinical applications (see Figure 1). Initially, the integration of generative AI is more inclined towards administrative tasks (such as clinic documentation and creating discharge summaries) due to their simpler implementation and lower associated risks. However, it's anticipated that generative AI will eventually be more extensively utilized in clinical applications (such as diagnosis) in later stages. With healthcare systems facing chronic staffing shortages, Generative AI could hold the key to significantly enhancing the quality of care delivery and transforming the entire patient journey.

1 Figure 1: Selected use cases of Generative AI in healthcare

Administrative tasks

Physicians devote around one-sixth of their working hours to administrative tasks.8 Digital health start-ups, like the Paris-based Nabla, offer solutions to reduce the paperwork burden. Their digital assistant, called Copilot, automatically transcribes consultations into the typically required document-based endpoints such as prescriptions, follow up appointment letters and consultation summaries. Nabla claims that doctors can save on average 2 hours a day using Copilot.9 Similarly Microsoft-owned Nuance Communications integrated GPT-4 into its medical note-taking tool. Not only will generative AI integration allow for process streamlining and cost reductions, lowering the administrative burden will also positively affect doctors’ job satisfaction.

This also creates room for new business model innovations. For example, Hippocratic AI recently introduced on-demand AI agents starting from USD 9 per hour. These task-specific generative AI healthcare agents offer various services, ranging from pre-op assistance to discharge assistance to chronic care check-ins. Healthcare providers, payors, and pharmaceutical firms can book the task-specialized agents on an hourly basis. The development, in close cooperation with NVIDIA, has overcome existing challenges of generative AI tools to connect with patients on a personal level. NVIDIA’s AI platform allows for super-low-latency conversational interactions, which are crucial for building empathy.10 According to Hippocratic AI’s own user research, every half-second improvement in inference speed increases the ability for patients to emotionally connect with AI healthcare agents by 5-10% or more. While NVIDIA brings the technology stack for speed and fluidity, as well as the deployment of the AI models, Hippocratic AI has developed leading safety-focused LLM models specifically designed for healthcare applications.

Clinical applications

Generative AI's application will not only be restricted to healthcare administration. Clinical application is an even bigger field ready for disruption, although most use cases are still pre-commercialization.

Medical Diagnosis - The ultimate deciding factor on whether generative AI will be the doctor of the future is whether LLM-powered systems are able to make reliable and accurate diagnoses. Google computer scientists developed Med-PaLM, a LLM powered chatbot fine-tuned for the healthcare industry. Med-PaLM was the first AI system to achieve a pass mark (>60%) in the U.S. Medical Licensing Examination (USMLE) style questions.11 The chatbot was further optimized for diagnostic dialogue based on real-world datasets such as transcribed medical conversations. According to an article published in Nature magazine, Med-PaLM matched or surpassed the doctor’s diagnostic accuracy across six medical specialities and the generated answers ranked even higher in terms of conversation quality.12 Despite the promising initial results, AI tools will likely only assist doctors in their diagnosis for a long time rather than make them redundant. In September, Copenhagen startup Corti raised USD 60 million in a Series B funding round to accelerate the development of their AI assistant, which supports clinicians with patient assessment in real-time.13 Features include analyzing patient interactions to guide decision-making and providing “second opinions.” Unlike other copilots, Corti has built its own models instead of relying on generic models such as GPT-3 from OpenAI. The product is currently used to assess 100 million patients a day, and Corti claims it results in 40% more accurate outcome predictions.14

Medical Technology - Generative AI also has the potential to be directly incorporated into medical products. For example, it can drastically improve the accuracy of the technical diagnostic capabilities of medical software. The end-to-end digital pathology solutions company Paige has recently released PRISM, an oncology-specialized foundation model. Pre-trained on a large-scale dataset of 587,000 whole-slide images and 195,000 clinical reports, the model aids pathologists in cancer detection by automatically generating diagnostic summary reports.15 Generative AI can also be directly integrated into medical devices. For example, Kaliber AI is currently developing a generative AI surgical operating system that provides real-time guidance during surgical workflows and surgeon feedback.16 However, integration into medical devices is still pending regulatory approval.

Personalized Medicine - Another clinical use case of generative AI lies in developing personalized treatment plans and improving medication adherence, which is estimated to be around 50% in the US.17 By creating tailored interventions and digital reminders, AI can help patients stay on track with their prescribed regimens, ultimately leading to better health outcomes. This opens the door to a range of new application fields. For example, the Canadian startup DiagnaMed is currently working on a brain health platform leveraging generative AI.18 The tool estimates brain age by collecting neural activity data with a low-cost headset and calculates a health score with a proprietary machine-learning model. The tool then provides actionable points for precision medicine and personalized treatment plans for mental health and neurodegenerative conditions powered by OpenAI’s GPT models.

Pain points and remedies

The successful integration of generative AI into clinical settings hinges on addressing the following concerns:

1. Inaccuracy

With more than 1 in 10 American healthcare professionals already using ChatGPT in their daily work14 and increasingly larger shares of the public turning to generative AI tools for medical advice, exercising caution is important. While results might be more accurate than a Google Search in the past, blindly placing trust in the medical advice by generative AI is not advisable. The WHO recently issued a warning urging for caution over the use of generative AI in healthcare.19  

While generative AI models have excelled in standardized medical examinations, their performance in real-world diagnostic settings has been less consistent. A recent study published in JAMA Pediatrics suggests that ChatGPT’s diagnosis for kids are especially inaccurate with an error rate of 83%.20 To improve diagnostic accuracy, LLM should be specifically trained on medical data, like in the case of Google’s Med-PaLM. 

New model architectures might also play a crucial role in developing more accurate generative AI tools for the healthcare industry. Hippocratic AI has taken a novel approach to improving the accuracy of their AI agents with a foundation model based on a one trillion parameter constellation architecture, called Polaris.21 Unlike a general large model, the constellation architecture breaks down into a primary agent that focuses on driving engaging conversations and several specialists (see Figure 2). 

The primary language model is optimized for conversational fluidity, rapport-building, and empathetic bedside manner, while specialized support models enhance medical accuracy and safety. Each safety-critical task is performed through cooperation between the primary model and the corresponding specialist agents. This redundancy ensures that if the primary model fails or misses a task for any reason, the specialist agent ensures that the system continues to operate correctly and safely.

2 Figure 2: High level overview of LLM constellation architecture Polaris 

The risk of AI hallucinations, where LLMs make up source data when faced with data gaps resulting in "unfounded diagnoses" can prove detrimental in a healthcare setting. Considering the high stakes in a healthcare environment, even a 5% error rate is not acceptable. Thus, generative AI should be integrated as a data augmentation tool under human supervision rather than operating in a fully automated manner. 

This human-generative AI collaboration would make the critical thinking skills of medical practitioners more important than ever. In other settings, studies have shown that the reliance on generative AI tools significantly increases with workload and time pressure.22 It is not far-fetched to imagine situations where healthcare professionals might be tempted to simplify their work by following the recommendations of generative AI tools without further investigation. Various precautions could help prevent such situations. One idea is to use AI tools only after an initial diagnosis by a doctor. Another idea is to design AI tools with features that encourage a healthy level of skepticism, such as using a "robotic" voice.

The risk of an inaccurate diagnosis by AI tools will never reach 0%—just as doctors can be fallible. One of the biggest questions will be who is liable if something goes wrong. Today, it is the healthcare provider, but with technological advancements, legal responsibilities might shift. This raises concerns about whether a shift in liability might lead to over trusting AI tools. Therefore, promoting a clear distinction of accountability between the tool and the medical professional is crucial.

2. Bias

The inherent biases in generative AI models' training datasets pose a significant threat to healthcare equity. Notably, gender bias remains a pervasive issue, as sex differences in cell physiology, symptom presentation, disease manifestation, and treatment response have been historically neglected. The availability and quality of sex-specific data are uneven, especially in lower-income countries. 

Consequently, closing the data gap is crucial for ensuring the development of generative AI models that produce reliable outcomes for both genders. Ignoring biased training data could lead to misdiagnosis in certain populations. Thus, implementing rigorous governance mechanisms is essential to proactively identify and mitigate potential biases throughout the AI development lifecycle.

Startups like Dandelion Health are providing bias checker solutions for developers of healthcare AI models. Data access is particularly challenging in the healthcare sector, where patient records are subject to strict privacy laws. Dandelion allows its users to cross-check performance across diverse types of patients by leveraging its massive, de-identified dataset from millions of patient records.23

3. Privacy

A 2023 Pew Research Center survey revealed that 60% of American adults would feel uncomfortable if their healthcare provider would rely on AI for their medical care.24 Safeguarding patient privacy remains paramount in healthcare, necessitating robust data security protocols and anonymization techniques to ensure information safety.

In this context, the utilization of synthetic data, which mimics the statistical relationships of  real-world data without revealing identifiable patient information, might allow for the protection of individuals' privacy. Generative AI models like GANs can synthesize electronic health record data by learning the underlying data distributions without revealing sensitive patient information. However, challenges with synthetic data remain, such as reproducing the biases of the underlying dataset and artificially inflating model performance due to data leakage.

Regulatory environment

Healthcare is one of the most strictly regulated industries. In Europe, the EMA (European Medicines Agency) acts as a reviewing body for member nations, while in the US the FDA (Food and Drug Administration) oversees the industry.

In the US, specific regulatory categories tailored exclusively for AI-based technologies are presently lacking. Generative AI falls in a grey area between medical information websites and medical devices. Medical websites like WebMD, which merely aggregate knowledge, are not FDA regulated. On the other hand, AI medical devices “that interpret patient information and make predictions in medium-to-high-risk domains”25 (also called, Software as a Medical Device - SaMD) require FDA approval. 

The European Parliament passed the AI Act on March 13, 2024, establishing the world’s first major law for regulating AI. This sector-spanning law introduces new requirements for developers and deployers of AI-enabled digital health tools. However, the concrete impact of the AI Act is still ambiguous, and details will only emerge later through associated guidance, standards, and member state laws and policies.26

Overall, the regulatory landscape for generative AI in the medical sphere is still in a nascent state. While existing frameworks cover general AI use cases, LLMs (large language models) significantly differ from prior deep learning methods. Addressing the regulation of generative AI’s adaptive algorithms and autodidactic functions remains an open task. To ensure the safe and effective implementation as well as commercialization of Large Language Models (LLMs) in the healthcare sector, new regulatory frameworks are imperative. These regulations should make a clear distinction between LLMs specifically trained on medical data and those designed for non-medical purposes. For the successful integration of generative AI in healthcare applications, regulatory focus should centre on overseeing individual companies rather than scrutinizing each individual iteration of LLMs.

One important component for future innovation, as envisaged in the new AI Act, will be “regulatory sandboxes”.27 These will allow businesses to explore and test new AI products and services in a controlled environment under a regulator's supervision.

Closing Thoughts

‘Dr. ChatGPT’ is rapidly gaining importance in the medical space and has significantly changed the way we search for medical information over the past year. To unlock further use cases for administrative and clinical applications, addressing pain points will be paramount. In the clinical space, models trained specifically on medical data such as Med-PaLM will play a more important role compared to general models such as ChatGPT. One thing is clear: Generative AI has the potential to significantly alter patients’ healthcare journey. The transformation potential in the healthcare industry is tremendous and expands even into the development of new drugs. 

References

  1. Baccolini, V., Rosso, A., Di Paolo, C., Isonne, C., Salerno, C., Migliara, G., Prencipe, G. P., Massimi, A., Marzuillo, C., De Vito, C., Villari, P., & Romano, F. (2021). What is the Prevalence of Low Health Literacy in European Union Member States? A Systematic Review and Meta-analysis. Journal of General Internal Medicine, 36(3), 753–761. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11606-020-06407-8
  2. Starcevic, V., & Berle, D. (2013). Cyberchondria: Towards a better understanding of excessive health-related Internet use. Expert Review of Neurotherapeutics, 13(2), 205–213. https://doi.org/10.1586/ern.12.162 
  3. Lyons, R. J., Arepalli, S. R., Fromal, O., Choi, J. D., & Jain, N. (2023). Artificial intelligence chatbot performance in triage of ophthalmic conditions. Canadian Journal of Ophthalmology, 0(0). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.jcjo.2023.07.016
  4. Murphy, M. (n.d.). Dr Google will see you now: Search giant wants to cash in on your medical queries. Retrieved March 31, 2024, from https://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/2019/03/10/google-sifting-one-billion-health-questions-day/
  5. Ayoub, N. F., Lee, Y.-J., Grimm, D., & Divi, V. (2023). Head-to-Head Comparison of ChatGPT Versus Google Search for Medical Knowledge Acquisition. Otolaryngology–Head and Neck Surgery, n/a(n/a). https://doi.org/10.1002/ohn.465 
  6. Health workforce. (n.d.). Retrieved March 31, 2024, from https://www.who.int/health-topics/health-workforce
  7. Bhasker, S., Bruce, D., Lamb, J., & Stein, G. (n.d.). Generative AI in healthcare: Emerging use for care. McKinsey. Retrieved March 31, 2024, from https://www.mckinsey.com/industries/healthcare/our-insights/tackling-healthcares-biggest-burdens-with-generative-ai
  8. Woolhandler, S., & Himmelstein, D. U. (2014). Administrative work consumes one-sixth of U.S. physicians’ working hours and lowers their career satisfaction. International Journal of Health Services: Planning, Administration, Evaluation, 44(4), 635–642. https://doi.org/10.2190/HS.44.4.a
  9. Nabla Copilot · Enjoy care again. (n.d.). Retrieved March 31, 2024, from https://www.nabla.com/
  10. Hippocratic AI Announces Collaboration with NVIDIA to Develop Super-Low-Latency “Empathy Inference” for One of the World’s First Generative AI-Powered Healthcare Agents. (2024, March 18). Yahoo Finance. https://finance.yahoo.com/news/hippocratic-ai-announces-collaboration-nvidia-220500189.html
  11. Med-PaLM: A Medical Large Language Model - Google Research. (n.d.). Google Research. Retrieved March 31, 2024, from https://sites.research.google/med-palm/
  12. Lenharo, M. (2024, January 12). Google AI has better bedside manner than human doctors—And makes better diagnoses. Nature. http://global.factiva.com/redir/default.aspx?P=sa&an=GNAA000020240113ek1c00002&cat=a&ep=ASE
  13. About Corti. (n.d.). Retrieved July 1, 2024, from https://corti.ai//company/about-corti Artificial intelligence act and regulatory sandboxes. (n.d.).
  14. Lunden, I. (2023, September 20). Corti, an AI “co-pilot” for healthcare clinicians, raises $60M. TechCrunch. https://techcrunch.com/2023/09/20/corti-an-ai-co-pilot-for-healthcare-clinicians-raises-60m/
  15. Paige Introduces PRISM, a Slide-Level Foundation Model to Empower the Next Era of Pathology & Cancer Treatment. (2024, May 21). Paige. https://paige.ai/paige-introduces-prism-a-slide-level-foundation-model-to-empower-the-next-era-of-pathology-cancer-treatment/
  16. Kaliber.AI. (n.d.). Kaliber Labs. Retrieved July 1, 2024, from https://www.kaliber.ai/solutions
  17. Neiman, A. B., Ruppar, T., Ho, M., Garber, L., Weidle, P. J., Hong, Y., George, M. G., & Thorpe, P. G. (2017). CDC Grand Rounds: Improving Medication Adherence for Chronic Disease Management — Innovations and Opportunities. Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, 66(45), 1248–1251. https://doi.org/10.15585/mmwr.mm6645a
  18. DiagnaMed Provides Update on CERVAITM, a Brain Health AI Platform Leveraging Generative AICERVAITM entering final development stage and readying for commercialization in Q4-2023. (n.d.). BioSpace. Retrieved July 1, 2024, from https://www.biospace.com/article/diagnamed-provides-update-on-cervai-a-brain-health-ai-platform-leveraging-generative-aicervai-entering-final-development-stage-and-readying-for-commercialization-in-q4-2023/
  19. WHO urges caution over generative AI in healthcare—Tech Monitor. (2023, May 16). https://techmonitor.ai/technology/ai-and-automation/ai-in-healthcare-who
  20. Barile, J., Margolis, A., Cason, G., Kim, R., Kalash, S., Tchaconas, A., & Milanaik, R. (2024). Diagnostic Accuracy of a Large Language Model in Pediatric Case Studies. JAMA Pediatrics, 178(3), 313–315. https://doi.org/10.1001/jamapediatrics.2023.5750
  21. Mukherjee, S., Gamble, P., Ausin, M. S., Kant, N., Aggarwal, K., Manjunath, N., Datta, D., Liu, Z., Ding, J., Busacca, S., Bianco, C., Sharma, S., Lasko, R., Voisard, M., Harneja, S., Filippova, D., Meixiong, G., Cha, K., Youssefi, A., … Miller, A. (2024). Polaris: A Safety-focused LLM Constellation Architecture for Healthcare (arXiv:2403.13313). arXiv. http://arxiv.org/abs/2403.13313
  22. Abbas, M., Jam, F. A., & Khan, T. I. (2024). Is it harmful or helpful? Examining the causes and consequences of generative AI usage among university students. International Journal of Educational Technology in Higher Education, 21(1), 10. https://doi.org/10.1186/s41239-024-00444-7
  23. Dandelion Health Is Using 10 Million Patient Records To Reduce AI Bias. (n.d.). Retrieved July 1, 2024, from https://www.forbes.com/sites/katiejennings/2023/12/21/how-this-startup-is-using-10-million-patient-records-to-reduce-bias-in-healthcare-ai/
  24. Funk, A. T., Giancarlo Pasquini, Alison Spencer and Cary. (2023, February 22). 60% of Americans Would Be Uncomfortable With Provider Relying on AI in Their Own Health Care. Pew Research Center Science & Society. https://www.pewresearch.org/science/2023/02/22/60-of-americans-would-be-uncomfortable-with-provider-relying-on-ai-in-their-own-health-care/
  25. Shryock, T. (2023). AI Special Report: What patients and doctors really think about AI in health care. 100. https://www.medicaleconomics.com/view/ai-special-report-what-patients-and-doctors-really-think-about-ai-in-health-care
  26. Gilbert, S. (2024). The EU passes the AI Act and its implications for digital medicine are unclear. Npj Digital Medicine, 7(1), 1–3. https://doi.org/10.1038/s41746-024-01116-6
  27. Madiega, T., & Van De Pol, A. L. (n.d.). Artificial intelligence act and regulatory sandboxes. European Parliamentary Research Service.

[Student IDEAS] by Céline Viévard - Global BBA at ESSEC Business School

Is greed really good? Milton Friedman’s statement (1970) that profit maximization is the sole responsibility of companies has recently been up for debate. With the repeating tech titans’ data privacy scandals, a stark reality lays bare: people can come second to profit. In parallel to these giants' rise in influence, consumers are increasingly concerned regarding the societal impact of companies (Lewis, 2021) - they are now more than ever put under the microscope. Amidst the constant pursuit of “what’s next?”, a crucial question now arises: what is the purpose of driving this innovation?

Considering the fast nature of such an industry, are short-termism initiatives for profit maximization the most appropriate for survival? Is incorporating purpose going beyond their core mandate? Are profit maximization and purpose mutually exclusive? How could purpose be adopted in such a turbulent environment? 

The why of tech

But what even is purpose? Corporate purpose, once synonymous with Friedman’s shareholder primacy, now encompasses all stakeholders and involves broader societal considerations (Business Roundtable, 2019). This new definition aligns with the concept of the Triple Bottom Line (TBL), which emphasizes that a company's purpose should consider not just its financial performance (Profit), but also its social impact (People) and environmental impact (Planet). Delivered in the form of environmental, social and governance (ESG) initiatives, purpose is a company’s commitment to:

  • Provide value to customers
  • Invest in employees;
  • Deal fairly and ethically with suppliers;
  • Support communities;
  • Generate long-term shareholder value.

Considering the range of stakeholders tech companies hold, with 91% of organizations undergoing digital transformation (Gartner, 2020) and over 5.35 million people globally using the Internet (DataReportal, 2024), purpose is a crucial force. On one hand, while 65% of employees feel their leaders overlook the societal impact of digital initiatives (Bannister et al., 2020), defining the ethical use and purpose of technology reduces risks like data privacy breaches, algorithmic biases, cybersecurity threats and others. On the other hand, as 68% of consumers believe companies need to drive positive social and environmental impact (Lewis, 2021), tech companies can leverage their resources to create value exceeding that of a product or service by contributing to causes for the communities they serve. 

While most tech companies have adopted a purpose, many fail in their design or application (Kennedy et al., 2022b). This incongruence, known as the purpose gap, reflects a lack of alignment between the stated purpose and the company’s strengths, stakeholders and activities. Bridging this gap, aligning business with broader societal concerns while preserving company identity, is a complex dance. Yet, an achievable one when the following moves were respected.

First, define purpose with all stakeholders

At the heart of the purpose gap lies a lack of communication. For purpose to truly echo within and outside an organization, all stakeholders need to identify with it. What better way to find a purpose that all stakeholders are aligned with than directly discussing it with them? 

Regarding top teams, many admit purpose is a subject they want to address but fear is not considered a top priority (Gast et al, 2020). The consequence? The Abilene Paradox, where silence is misinterpreted as agreement. The solution? Starting the dialogue. A way to ease into such a discussion is through an ‘ESG teardown’ - a strategic assessment of a company's existing ESG initiatives. This surfaces which key issues are being addressed and why - were they related to the key strength of the company? Or was it mimicking a competitor? You may also notice if there is an imbalance in the rigor of certain letters of ESG. Think of questioning whether ESG is reflected within operations - and if not, why? Completing this by evaluating your performance to your competitors will lay out a first draft of initiatives to introduce, keep, improve and remove.

Next are stakeholders - those who experience or perceive the company’s purpose. Their voices are crucial during its design and implementation. Employees, for example, face the dilemma between purpose and profit on a daily basis. For alignment, surveys like the Inclusion Index by Microsoft (McIntyre, 2023) alongside questioning what they value and where they find value in work is recommended. Assigning “purpose ambassadors" to champion employees’ desired purpose is also favorable. They could gather employee stories where your company truly lived its purpose, a powerful tool for later the integration phase. Such surveys can also be sent to consumers or investors to define what they seek in the company’s purpose and what they believe are its strengths and weaknesses.

With this range of potential purpose initiatives at hand comes the time to prioritize. The most suitable must match the company’s strengths: what unique value do you provide? How does it relate to purpose? How can it create value? They also need to generate stakeholder impact: what is the tangible impact? Metrics such as how much wage increases boost purchasing power or how much solar panels reduce greenhouse gases are examples. The long-term shareholder value must also be considered: what were the financial gains? Ideally, this should be in monetary terms like increased revenue or cost reduction. Some of these will not have monetized value, in that case, asking stakeholders to rank the initiatives or looking at what other organizations do may help guide your choice. Once selected, commit with a timeline and objectives for credibility but also to measure your success in the future.  

Then, integrate purpose

For purpose to be more than a marketing campaign, it needs to initiate change within the organization. 

There will be opportunities to go against your purpose, sometimes unknowingly. It’s important to keep in mind that nonmanagers are actually more likely than leaders to face this tension (Gast et al., 2020). Projecting possible scenarios of friction will help set a framework to guide them when the time comes. This can be done by making them test the purpose on their activities and communicate how it influences decisions and if there are any tensions. Through this feedback, you can refine your purpose statement and set a toolkit on how employees can demonstrate purpose daily.

It is important to set an ethical policy and culture reflecting your purpose. To do so, introducing and involving new key players like a chief ethical and humane officer as done by Salesforce (n.d.) or an AI and Ethics Research Committee like Microsoft (2018) has proven to be efficient. Such positions can assist in building a framework, ensuring its flexibility and monitoring or addressing any issues. Including non-financial stakeholders on the board can also help represent purpose during decision-making and embed such a culture. 

With all of this set, it’s important to share with all stakeholders how purpose is now a part of your organization. For impact, this needs to be more than just communicating plans, you need story-telling to inspire (London Business Forum, 2016). Sharing the stories collected by the purpose ambassadors on value creation through work or the feedback on how purpose has guided decision-making are examples. Sharing will not only assist in its adoption but also push employees and decision-makers to take accountability and acknowledge the impact they have.

Finally, measure your impact 

Although it will take years to truly impact society, it is essential to communicate goals, progress and setbacks. Not only does this push for accountability but will also highlight the quality of your impact and its returns, motivating all stakeholders.

There exists a wide range of reporting standards with varying levels of rigor for reference such as:

  • The StakeHolder Capitalism Metrics by The World Economic Forum (2021) 
  • The EU Non-financial Reporting Directive (European Commission, 2014) and Corporate Sustainability Reporting Directive (European Commission, 2023)
  • The United Nations’ Sustainable Development Goals (n.d.)
  • The Global Reporting Initiative framework (n.d.)

It is essential for the reporting to be adapted to your purpose and your initiatives. It may even be relevant to introduce new metrics to best measure your impact. Ask yourself: What data is crucial in understanding the performance of your impact? Have your current metrics given insight on how to improve your purpose? Is anything not being measured on your societal impact? Including metrics of the five dimensions of stakeholder impact may guide and ensure the completeness of your measures.

  • Financial impact, improving your stakeholders' long-term financial well-being.
  • Environmental impact, how your activities affect environmental health. 
  • Health, improving the organizations’ and stakeholders’ health. 
  • Capability-building, improving stakeholders’ abilities and skills.
  • Satisfaction impact, improving your stakeholders’ experience with your company or its products and services.

By tracking these comprehensive impact metrics, companies gain valuable insights. These metrics not only guide decisions about which initiatives to maintain, improve, or discontinue but they can also be used to incentivize employees by linking their compensation to long-term value creation. This aligns with current trends, as research shows that linking compensation with purpose enhances stakeholder outcomes (Sutherland & Falk, 2021). Such a data-driven approach to purpose can ensure company efforts translate into real-world improvements for all stakeholders.

And repeat

The tech landscape is constantly evolving and the frameworks chosen today may be obsolete tomorrow. This is why the processes chosen need to be highly flexible to adapt to any potential changes. Through your measures you may also see there are still some inconsistencies and points of improvements on your purpose statement. Purpose is not just a subject you address once and never go back, it’s a daily matter. 

The Purpose Imperative: Beyond Profitability

Purpose is becoming not only a fruitful asset across all industries but its adoption requires resources, analysis and patience. Without respecting the careful steps for its implementation, there are high risks of falling in the purpose gap. Through a careful design process integrating all stakeholders, embedded within all operations and regular measurement and refining, purpose can shine within and without the organization's walls and set an example for other players across industries. As stakeholders progressively become focused on impact, with the rise of ethical consumerism and growing investor expectations regarding ESG principles, purpose could become the ultimate competitive edge, even trumping innovation.

Key takeaways

  • Purpose is gaining an increasing amount of importance to all business stakeholders across all industries. 
  • For purpose to be fruitful, it needs to be aligned with the company’s strengths, activities and stakeholders. This lack of alignment, the purpose gap, is the reason behind the failure of most purpose statements today. 
  • The definition process of purpose within a company needs to include and be based on all stakeholders. 
  • Purpose should translate into real-world changes through policies, additional expertise and communication.
  • For accountability and improvement, purpose needs goals and monitoring through a set of chosen metrics.

References

[1] Friedman M. 1970. The social responsibility of business is to increase its profits. New York Times Magazine, September 13.

[2] Lewis, S. (2021, July 7). How to realize the full potential of ESG+. https://www.ey.com/en_fi/sustainability/realize-potential-esg-plus

[3] Business Roundtable. (2019). Business Roundtable Redefines the Purpose of a Corporation to Promote ‘An Economy That Serves All Americans’. https://www.businessroundtable.org/business-roundtable-redefines-the-purpose-of-a-corporation-to-promote-an-economy-that-serves-all-americans

[4] Bannister, C. et al. (2020). Ethical tech. Making ethics a priority in today’s digital organization. Deloitte Insights. https://www2.deloitte.com/us/en/insights/topics/digital-transformation/make-ethical-technology-a-priority.html 

[5] Gartner (2020). Digitalisation Strategy for Business Transformation. https://www.gartner.co.uk/en/information-technology/insights/digitalization

[6] DataReportal, Meltwater, We Are Social. (2024). Number of internet and social media users worldwide as of January 2024 (in billions). Statista. Statista Inc.. Accessed: March 30, 2024. https://www-statista-com.essec.idm.oclc.org/statistics/617136/digital-population-worldwide/

[7] Kennedy, D. et al. (2022) Solving the tech industry’s purpose problem. https://www.bcg.com/publications/2019/solving-tech-industry-purpose-problem.

[8] Gast, A., Probst, N., & Simpson, B. (2020, December 3). Purpose, not platitudes: A personal challenge for top executives. McKinsey & Company. https://www.mckinsey.com/capabilities/people-and-organizational-performance/our-insights/purpose-not-platitudes-a-personal-challenge-for-top-executives

[9] McIntyre, L. (2023, November 2). Microsoft’s 2023 Diversity and Inclusion Report: A decade of transparency, commitment and progress - The Official Microsoft Blog. The Official Microsoft Blog. https://blogs.microsoft.com/blog/2023/11/01/microsofts-2023-diversity-and-inclusion-report-a-decade-of-transparency-commitment-and-progress/

[10] Salesforce (n.d). Ethical and humane use. https://www.salesforce.com/company/intentional-innovation/

[11] Microsoft News Center. (2018, March 29). Satya Nadella email to employees: Embracing our future: Intelligent Cloud and Intelligent Edge - Stories. Stories. https://news.microsoft.com/2018/03/29/satya-nadella-email-to-employees-embracing-our-future-intelligent-cloud-and-intelligent-edge/

[12] London Business Forum. (2016, March 11). David Pearl - Storytelling [Video]. YouTube. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4C0bbDAql_A

[13] World Economic Forum. Explore the metrics. (2021, September 20). https://www.weforum.org/stakeholdercapitalism/our-metrics/

[14] European Commission (2014). EU non-financial reporting directive (NFRD): Directive 2014/95/EU, European Commission, October 22, 2014, https://eur-lex.europa.eu/eli/dir/2014/95/oj. 

[15] European Commission (2023). Corporate sustainability reporting. Finance. https://finance.ec.europa.eu/capital-markets-union-and-financial-markets/company-reporting-and-auditing/company-reporting/corporate-sustainability-reporting_en

[16] United Nations, Department of Economic and Social Affairs. (n.d.). THE 17 GOALS | Sustainable Development. (n.d.). https://sdgs.un.org/goals 

[17] Global Reporting Initiave. (n.d.) GRI - Standards. https://www.globalreporting.org/standards/

[18] Sutherland, S., & Falk, B. (2021, March 26). How a purpose-led strategy can help boards prioritize stakeholders. EY Finland. https://www.ey.com/en_fi/board-matters/how-a-purpose-led-strategy-can-help-boards-prioritize-stakeholders

[Student IDEAS] by Michelle Diaz - Master in Management at ESSEC Business School

Very few things are as malleable and rule-stricken as language, composition, and rhetoric. In 2022 alone, Merriam-Webster added 370 new words to the English dictionary. But certain grammatical rules have been in place for centuries. Perhaps it is this contradictory, confounding, and ever-evolving nature of language that allows trained writers to still overwrite artificial intelligence (AI). However, a recent paper suggests that even writing-intensive professions are exposed to AI, with 80-100% of the US workforce affected (Eloundou et al., 2023).

But what does this mean for academia? Should academic institutions hurry to shift assessment standards, create safeguards, and implement fraud-detection measures? Most say yes; others insist it is a threat to education like no other, while some tout it as a wondrous opportunity. AI is all of this and more: a chance for a wider array of students to understand, appreciate, and learn the art of composition—to consider the skill as something they would like to possess. Rather than outsource to AI-powered chatbots, simply because they can.

Reaction to ChatGPT – a lot of old rhetoric?

The reaction to the release of ChatGPT, an AI-powered chatbot developed by Open AI has been wide-reaching. The reception can be found in almost every sector, from business to healthcare, law, and entertainment to name a few. But in no sector is the reception more mixed and controversial than that of academia, the common denominator of almost every sector. Every prospective CEO, health professional, lawyer, screenwriter, and professor must, in one way or another, prepare for their career through some level of education.

The bombardment of headlines ranged from the optimistic, “AI Could Be Great for College Essays” (Lametti, 2022), to a nuanced analysis, “The Brilliance and Weirdness of ChatGPT” (Roose, 2022), and the proactive response, “How to Use ChatGPT and Still Be a Good Person” (Chen, 2022). The timeline of these headlines was early in the launch of ChatGPT. But the headlines since the release of ChatGPT-3.5 and GPT-4 have in large part reflected the same flurry of mixed emotions, with “The Chatbots Are Here, and the Internet Industry Is in a Tizzy” (Mickle et al., 2023) and “‘Let 1,000 Flowers Bloom’: A.I. Funding Frenzy Escalates” (Griffith et al., 2023), and the op-ed of the esteemed father of modern linguistics, “Noam Chomsky: The False Promise of ChatGPT” (Chomsky et al., 2023).

Irrespective of the views on ChatGPT, one thing is clear: a paradigm shift is needed. The repercussions of ChatGPT’s very existence mean the technology will only get better given the historical rate of technological innovation and competition within the market. On March 21, 2023, Google launched its Bard chatbot, the tech giant’s bid to rival Open AI’s ChatGPT. While Baidu, the Chinese search giant, released their own chatbot, Ernie, earlier in March 2023, (Murgia, 2023). In essence, a proactive approach is required to handle the effect on academic integrity.

Defining Academic Integrity

What exactly is academic integrity? And how do chatbots like ChatGPT, Bard, and Ernie threaten it? Moreover, how might we leverage these chatbots to improve education instead of sending teachers, schools, professors, and universities into a frenzy of concern over academic fraud? According to Donald McCabe, the founding father of research into ethical policy in academia, “the term involves the avoidance of plagiarism, cheating, and other behaviours of misconduct” (McCabe et al., 2016).  The speed at which detective measures have sprouted is commensurate with the capacity of the technology. Indeed, the benchmarks done by Open AI for GPT-4 reveal that the model can perform exceedingly well in a simulation of exams originally designed for humans:

(Open AI, 2023)

Hence, it comes as no surprise that, not three months since ChatGPT’s release, Edward Tian, an undergraduate student at Princeton University, created GPTZero, a bot to detect a text written by ChatGPT (Bowman, 2023). Similarly, Eric Mitchell, a graduate student at Stanford University, is working on DetectGPT, yet another means to distinguish between human and large language model (LLM)-generated text (Mitchell et al., 2023).

In effect, many of the metrics that society at large measures academic performance can be gamed by AI. Like essay assessments that require no oversight at the time of writing. But there has always been a case to mitigate academic misconduct, even before AI: “In the past, students could hire a ghost writer through widely available and easily accessible essay mills to write an assignment. Now with ChatGPT, they can instruct artificial intelligence (AI) instead of a person, at no cost…” (Harte et al, 2023). The qualifying difference is the ease with which students may now cheat.

AI: The Skill of Writing & the Real Conundrum

Interestingly, the one area in which GPT-4 has performed less admirably is the skill of writing. It showed no significant improvement from the last two versions for AP English Language, Literature, and the writing portion of the GRE (Open AI, 2023). Consequently, one must distinguish between subjects wherein equal weight is put on a text’s content and the quality of the writing itself. One can argue that assessment standards should be modified to require the high clarity, concision, and eloquence that is often demanded of students studying subjects like creative writing, literature, or philosophy. Or else, the mode of assessment be modified, or a reliable means of detecting AI-written text made widely available.

In early 2023, The New York Times published an article wherein more than 30 professors, students, and university administrators were interviewed on how to adopt to ChatGPT. Together, they outlined three ways to address the issue: require a higher standard of writing, modify assessment, and create a detector for AI-written text. One professor claimed that the “imagination, creativity, and innovation of analysis that we usually deem an A paper needs to be trickling down into the B-range papers.” Another professor now requires students to write their first drafts in the classroom. Lastly, the article underlines how more than 6,000 professors from Harvard University, among other tertiary institutions, have signed up for Edward Tian’s GPTZero (Huang, 2023).  

In any case, one thing is clear: the real conundrum is the ease with which students will willingly use ChatGPT for their academic assessments. Indeed, therein lies the potential of AI to either be beneficial or detrimental. If a student can save time, effort, and learn better with ChatGPT, then academia is better served by ensuring that students are more inclined to use it without forgoing academic integrity; to act based on an intrinsic preservation of integrity, rather than the avoidance of negative extrinsic repercussions of misconduct. And certainly, the uses of AI to improve academic practice are abundant, from providing a personalized learning experience to helping students brainstorm ideas to curating relevant resources (Hamdan, 2023).

Opportunity Amidst Chaos

Considering the dilemmas ChatGPT raises about academic integrity, it is prime time to refocus on a core issue that predates AI: the perception on the necessity of learning to write well. In 2002, Petelin coined the terms, “working writers and writing worker to distinguish between professionally trained writers (career writers) and those who are not necessarily trained as professional writers but whose jobs require them to write.” The former refers to journalists, playwrights, poets, etc. While the latter refers to lawyers, managers, engineers, architects, etc. (Petelin, 2022). The perception is that certain occupations require less training in writing, and indeed, not every individual must aim to write to the degree that career writers do. After all, a medical student is better prepared by spending more time on the sciences.

However, instilling students with the desire to learn writing beyond the requisite level to pass their courses is an investment that is unquestionably worthwhile. As Oscar Wilde once said, “If you cannot write well, you cannot think well; if you cannot think well, others will do your thinking for you.” Likewise, Joan Didion, a celebrated American writer mirrored this sentiment: “Had I been blessed with even limited access to my own mind, there would have been no reason to write.” While Stephen King notes that “writing is refined thinking” (King, 2000). These writers, whether they knew it at the time or not, were talking about the writing-thinking-learning connection, a relationship that language scholars have long since studied. Essentially, writing about something allows one to understand and learn it better, thus exploiting the connection between the three acts (Petelin, 2022).

Moreover, research shows a high correlation between writing and speaking. A study done in 2022 revealed that “student achievement in learning writing skills can predict achievement in learning speaking skills, and vice versa. If a student has good writing skills, it is almost certain that he will have good speaking skills as well” (Rahman et al, 2022). And speaking well is indubitably beneficial across different careers. Furthermore, a meta-analysis on the effects of writing on learning in science, social studies, and mathematics concluded that teachers in these subjects “can reasonably expect that asking their students to write about content material will enhance learning” (Graham et al, 2020). Not to mention the capacity of writing to be therapeutic and beneficial for mental health (Bergqvist et al, 2020). Value is found in the act of writing itself, exclusive of the output produced; value that is forgone by heavily relying on AI.

A Comprehensive Approach

To effectively capitalize on AI while preserving academic integrity, intervention can be divided into two categories: changing academic practices and student attitudes toward the importance of writing well. For the former, we have the tactics outlined by professors, like modifying assessments and creating GPTZero. While the latter category requires a stronger push. But combined, the two interventions provide intrinsic and extrinsic motivation and are thus a better way forward for students and academic institutions alike.

But what does changing student attitudes toward writing well look like? As it stands, the way that we teach students to write differs too much across disciplines, and some students inherently find the act of writing cumbersome. Instead of an enjoyable, empowering, and powerful skill for any career – “Its importance in organisations often goes unnoticed until there’s a document-related crisis” (Petelin, 2022). Furthermore, in most “Australian and British universities, writing is under-taught, under-valued, and under-researched” (Petelin, 2022). In contrast to American universities, where there is a long and strong tradition of rhetoric at the undergraduate level (Petelin, 2022).

Exposure to Inspire – Room for Improvement

Good rhetoric and composition speak for themselves. Often, the challenge is exposure to quality writing that inspires; to strings of words that entice not only with their content but with an eloquence that arrests. Sentences that speak not only about desire, but is desire embodied—obsessively, incessantly, and with a maddening hunger whose tendrils worm their way into a reader’s mind. No. The kind of writing found in required texts for subjects outside of the arts and humanities is far too often dry. Texts that read more like an instruction manual than anything else. How often do people read the instruction manual? Only when the table, despite all the tinkering, cannot be trusted to hold itself together. Now, perhaps the last couple of sentences sparked in you a defiance, a sort of stubbornness that proclaims: I always read the instruction manual! Or, most plausibly: not all writing needs to be creative writing! Indeed. I concur.

But all writing can benefit from amelioration. At the time of Dr. King’s illustrious I Have a Dream speech, he was scarcely the only man who dreamt of the “unalienable rights of life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness for all men” (King, 1963). But he was one of the most eloquent. And while eloquence by itself does not a great leader make, it is a common denominator. From Dr. King to former president Barack Obama and to Professor Richard Feynman, notable not only for his contribution to physics but also for his ability to teach well.

Ergo, a solution might be to initiate introductory classes on literature and composition for academic departments like the hard sciences, healthcare, and business; make the skill more accessible. In this way, students learn early the supremacy of good writing, heightening the likelihood that they willingly invest time in the craft. Despite the presence of technologies that can write for them. Or else, more universities could adopt the practice of many American universities, where students must take classes on rhetoric and composition. Regardless of their chosen major (Petelin, 2022). If done correctly, swiftly, and universally, AI may very well bring about a resurgence in the art of rhetoric and composition—to the benefit of society at large.

[ESSEC Knowledge] by Veronica Casarin - Professor at ESSEC Business School

Organizations often face conflicting values and challenges in defining success. The author proposes here a new framework to tackle this.

Her research introduces "calculative frames," a model that captures different perspectives on value within an organization. This helps understand how organizations navigate conflicting priorities, like social good vs. financial sustainability.

By analyzing how these perspectives are balanced through key metrics, Veronica Casarin reveals how organizations reach compromise. This research offers valuable insights for any organization facing diverse stakeholder demands and complex value measurements.

[To read the full article please follow this link.]

[CURATED CONTENT] This paper was first published on Le Monde and is available here (in French).

by Guillaume Chevillon and Julien Malaurent, Institute for AI & Business Academic Co-Directors

Dec. 15, 2023

Abstract

Studies show that AI will augment human tasks rather than substitute them, with human oversight remaining crucial due to AI's limitations. The authors stress the importance of human intuition and behavioural skills, advocating for a balanced approach where AI complements human work, and they warn against short-sighted corporate strategies that undervalue human capital.

[CURATED CONTENT] This paper was first published on L'Obs and is available here (in French).

by Guillaume Chevillon, Institute for AI & Business Academic Co-Director

Dec. 17, 2023

Abstract

In this article, Guillaume Chevillon talks about the use of Generative AI and its implications for students and the teaching profession. AI not only promises to revolutionize the world of work, it is also changing the relationship between teachers and students, both in the way knowledge is imparted and in assessment methods.

Institute for AI & Business IDEAS newsletter #9 has just been released!

If you would like to read interesting articles on artificial trees capable of generating green electricity, or a revolutionary AI model for weather forecasting, check out the content below!

HOW MIGHT AI PLAYERS DRIVE SUSTAINABLE INITIATIVES?

[Student IDEAS] by Qinglan Huang & Yiyang Zhao - Master in Management at ESSEC Business School

Abstract

The article discusses the relationship between AI and environmental sustainability, emphasizing the need for "Green AI" to reduce AI's carbon and resource footprint. It covers strategies to improve energy efficiency in data centers, shifting to cloud and edge computing, optimizing algorithms, and ensuring the circularity of AI hardware components. It highlights the importance of regulations, transparency, and incentives to promote sustainable AI practices and the role of the EU in governing the green AI sector. The ultimate goal is to make environmentally friendly AI the industry standard.

---

When you think about “Artificial Intelligence” and “Green”, what connection could you make between these two fields? You may probably consider Artificial Intelligence (AI) and machine learning (ML) as a powerful tool to combat climate change. Indeed, AI has been used by governments, industries, and companies for collecting and computing data to prepare for change. However, with such unprecedented impact, it is imperative to examine the negative effect that massive AI adoption might have on the environment and climate in particular. While the potential of AI is frequently highlighted as a gamechanger for the transition in areas such as agriculture, building and mobility, the energy and resource consumption associated with AI computing is skyrocketing, along with a surge in estimated carbon emissions. What can it take to reduce this impact? And how might Multinational Companies (MNC), Small and Medium Enterprises (SME), and other AI players are working upon this green AI issue?

What is green AI and how is it governed?

Green AI is an emerging field to tackle environmental sustainability for the use of Artificial Intelligence. Its primary objective is to develop tools and techniques to mitigate the carbon and resource usage of AI adoption. The document “A role of Artificial Intelligence in the European Green Deal”, led by the European Parliament, illustrated the urgent needs for regulation and governance to manage the dynamics related to AI in implementing environmental objectives. Various sectors are actively working towards creating suitable regulatory instruments for assessing and integrating the evaluation of AI's environmental impacts within the current European regulatory framework.

A role of Artificial Intelligence in the European Green Deal. Source: European Parliament

In addition to the incoming assessments and regulations around AI sustainability, numerous programmes and initiatives have also been implemented to incentivise sustainable business applications and create more market opportunities. Incentives like loans aligned with the future EU taxonomy or targeted ‘green’ adjustments to public procurement law have accelerated the empowerment of specific actors and the implementation of sustainable AI.

AI emissions are core to the tech sector, entailing stronger strategies

There is no secret that the use of AI requires vast amounts of energy, along with their life cycle emissions rather than just training data. For companies dependent on AI technology, the carbon emissions resulting from AI operations have become a significant and growing concern.

Training a machine learning system, for example, needs to simulate millions of scenarios and perform statistical analyses on them. These processes can go on for weeks and even months, consuming a lot of computing power. The MIT Technology Review reported that training one large AI model can emit more than 626,000 pounds of carbon dioxide equivalent - nearly five times the lifetime emissions of the average American car.

Chart: MIT Technology Review. Source: Strubell et al

However, to accurately measure the footprint of AI is difficult. One has to determine first its power usage, which mostly funnels into the data centers that provide computational power to process, analyze and store vast amounts of datasets. In addition to the power for data center’s own use, cooling systems, such as air conditioning and liquid cooling, also require substantial energy consumption to prevent overheating caused by continuous operation of servers, storage systems, networking equipment, and maintaining optimal operating conditions. 

Emissions related to data centers are mainly categorized as Scope 2 emissions for tech companies, meaning emissions from purchased electricity by the organizations. According to the International Energy Agency (IEA), data centers and data transmission networks alone account for about 1-1.5% of global electricity consumption. This percentage is expected to rise at a surprising speed as more organizations and industries adopt AI technologies.

Another big part of the emissions of AI usage is coming from the life cycle of hardware used. AI models run on hardware - computers that incorporate resources such as processors, memory, and networks. The embedded carbon emissions arise because there are energy uses in each of the life cycles of hardware used by AI, including extraction of materials, manufacturing, upstream transportation, and disposal. 

The rise of AI emissions has been crucial for the tech sector to combat their carbon emissions, requiring them to develop a holistic and robust approach around green AI. In the subsequent study, we will identify the key pathways for green AI practices and the low-hanging fruit for companies to see impacts immediately.

Improve the energy efficiency of data centers

One way of abating carbon emissions of AI usage is to adopt next-generation infrastructure more efficiently. A simple approach is to improve the power usage effectiveness (PUE)1 of data centers used. This can be done by incrementally increasing current data centers or by replacing and adding data centers with the latest practices. One example is to shut down “zombie servers” - those that use electricity but no longer have workloads or data on them - consolidating workloads so that there are more per server, which reduces the number of servers and in turn enhances the utilization of a single server. 

For large deployments, it is also feasible to implement advanced cooling systems that host the servers and data centers. Enterprises are able to simply move data centers to cooler locations or invest in new cooling technology, but this could be expensive. This has been implemented by Microsoft. They have built a Thermal Energy Center and developed a more efficient cooling system by leveraging the temperature difference between sub-ground soil, which remains constant year-round, and that of ambient air, which changes with seasons. This system is expected to reduce energy consumption by more than 50% of a typical utility plant. 

Waste heat recycling of data centers could be another upgraded option. Microsoft's new data center in the Helsinki metropolitan area, which will use 100% emission-free electricity, is able to capture the excess heat generated from itself and send the clean heat for multiple use. Fortum, a power company in Helsinki, helps transfer the clean heat from the server to homes, businesses and public buildings that are connected to the local heating system. It reduces about 400,000 tonnes of CO2 emissions annually and brings an upgrade of community heating networks in Finland. 

Source: Microsoft data center collaborated with Fortum in Helsinki. Source: Microsoft

Shifting to cloud & edge AI computing might be more effective and less costly

Improving the efficiency of data centers may sound glorious, but in fact, it is expensive and results in limited carbon decrease. A company would cut carbon emissions by only 15-20% by doubling their investment on existing infrastructure and cloud to reduce PUE, according to a Mckinsey analysis. 

It is suggested that for most AI adopters, compared with improving their on-premise data centers, a much more efficient approach is to shift their business directly on cloud infrastructures. Hyperscalers (also known as cloud service providers) and co-locators have already invested massively in ultra-efficient data centers with PUEs of 1.4, 1.3 or even as low as 1.1 on occasion, whereas the current industry average is 1.57 for an on-premise data center. In recent surveys, researchers even found that running business applications on cloud infrastructure, rather than in on-premises enterprise data centers in Europe, could reduce associated energy usage by nearly 80%. Public cloud services providers such as Microsoft, Google, Amazon are generally much more efficient than those enterprise-operated servers in terms of their data center usage. However, for those small deployments that exist for a particular reason and cannot easily be shifted to the public cloud, it is suggested to consider other alternatives.

PUE data for all large-scale Google Data Centers. Source: Google

At the same time, cloud computing also brings drawbacks such as service downtime or significant slowdowns due to connectivity or network issues. This could lead to slower responses and undoubtedly increased energy consumption. The emerging Edge AI is well positioned to address this issue. Edge AI eliminates the need for connectivity between systems and allows users to process data in real time on local devices such as computers, Internet of Things (IoT) devices, or dedicated edge servers. As a distinctive disrupter, Edge computing reduces the need for high-performance computing infrastructure and thus leads to a significant reduction in energy consumption and carbon emissions.

Edge computing is increasingly seen as the next potential to compete with GPUs for the vanguard of the AI computing market. OmniML, an AI startup recently acquired by NVIDIA in a secret deal in February 2023, is a company that specializes in shrinking machine learning models to edge devices, enabling machine learning tasks to be 10x faster on different edge devices with 1/10th of the engineering effort. Last year, OmniML launched Omnimizer, a platform that can adapt computationally intensive AI models to low-end hardware. The adaptation bridges the gap between AI applications and edge devices and hugely increases the potential of the devices. As data storage and computation become more accessible to users, the adapted and hardware-aware AI is also faster, more accurate, energy efficient, and cost-effective. Edge AI plays a critical role in Green AI, enabling energy-efficient and decentralized AI systems.

Designing algorithms from a systematic view unlocks exponential reduction in energy consumption

To reach the overarching goal of green AI, it is comparably notable to develop more efficient models and algorithms accommodated to the progress of hardwares. As state-of-the-art machine learning is shifting to run on the edge devices, more constraints are introduced compared to traditional algorithm design approaches. This could also prompt the efforts in developing better models to represent data patterns and algorithms to fine-tune the model's parameters. 

Approaches to reduce electricity usage can be identified in different stages of an AI system’s life cycle (e.g, data collection, training, monitoring). In the pre-training session, feeding structured data instead of large raw data can reduce the size of training sets by several orders of magnitude. With a baseline set, similar performance can be achieved with fewer training examples or fewer gradient steps. These reference frames set initially will require substantially fewer samples in the model. During the training, designing more efficient training procedures and inference can reduce the required model variants. In addition, the chosen model and algorithm are crucial in implementing a holistic view of computational power savings in the pre-training and training phase.  For example, tree-based models with sparse features rather than neural networks in deep learning could serve as a viable alternative to mitigate energy use. A study in the International Journal of Data Science and Analytics in 2021 has shown that by selecting branches that require less computational efforts, the tree-based models can be 31% more energy efficient with minimal impact on accuracy. 

Reporting performance curves and building up consumption metrics will be the catalyst for making progress toward measuring and mitigating carbon footprint of algorithms. Training curves provide opportunities for future developers to compare at a range of different budgets and running experiments with different model sizes provides valuable insight into how model size impacts performance. Last year Microsoft, in partnership with the Allen Institute for AI and the Green Software Foundation, released energy consumption metrics within Azure Machine Learning, allowing developers to pinpoint the most energy-consuming work. The methodologies allow users to make wiser decisions about selection of models and highlight the stability of different approaches. It is also a vital step toward more equitable and green AI with clear and transparent reporting of electricity consumption, carbon emissions, and cost. 

Workflows to assess machine learning models. Source: Azure Machine Learning

Ensuring the efficiency and circularity of components of physical assets is key

A majority of carbon emissions of AI usage is classified as scope 3 emissions under the category 2 Capital Goods, referring to the emissions related to long-lasting physical assets such as infrastructure and equipment. To reduce the emissions from manufacturing, transportation and disposal of components, it is essential to ensure that the components sourced from the suppliers are not carbon intensive from a life cycle perspective. 

A key approach is to advance the life cycle assessments of components procured and adapt the sourcing strategy to favor more energy efficient hardwares. For instance, Microsoft has set a responsible sourcing strategy and ensured eco-design requirements for cloud hardwares. They have made sustainability considerations a key part of the entire Microsoft Azure hardware design process - including energy efficiency, repairability, upgradability, and durability. They have also taken initiatives around their zero-waste goal in managing cloud hardwares at their growing fleet of data centers. 

Some companies have also taken similar measures to ensure the efficiency and circularity of their data center components, whereas current initiatives must be upgraded with more stringent policies and concrete targets set by the companies. AI players should constantly keep their engagements with their suppliers to incentivise them to innovate themselves and bring more carbon-free solutions to the market. A comprehensive circularity design guidance and a recycle scheme are also essential to reduce the resources to operate an AI system needed.

What are the quick wins?

AI is likely to continue growing in the upcoming years both in terms of capacity and application. Given the growing attention on environmental sustainability matters brought by AI usage, companies are looking for quick wins that can be applied today. Whether a solution is on one hand low-hanging, on the other hand impactful, depends on its technology and market maturity, affordability, and abatement potential. It also varies with different types of AI stakeholders in the first place. 

Switch to cloud or consider edge computing (for AI adopters)

Switching directly to cloud or leveraging edge computing capacities would be a much better option than optimizing the efficiency of current data centers. Since the investments to improve efficiency could be costly and painful specifically for those AI adopters, companies relying on AI to improve their traditional business processes. 

More efficient and centralized cloud service or edge AI is regarded as a great helper to reduce both environmental and economical cost. 

Improve the algorithm

A portfolio of Green AI tactics in choosing right models and algorithms will help mitigate  energy consumption across the Machine Learning lifecycle. What needs to bear in mind is that small changes and conscious choices compounded in each step during all the different stages make a big difference in the final energy consumption. While the hardware is evolving to allow more decentralized and economical computing, upgrades of algorithms are expected to be adapted with power- efficiency and responsibility in mind, not just to be developed to stay at the bleeding edge.

Explore more eco efficient cooling methods (for tech giants)

For companies whose AI strategy is at the core of their business models, like Google and Microsoft, instead of transitioning to the cloud services they already possess, it is recommended for them to explore novel approaches for cooling infrastructures. Based on our analysis, the current PUE of the data centers is already low, while there is still a lack of well-established methods for cooling the operational computational power in a sustainable manner. For smaller deployments that must remain on-premise for a specific purpose, it is suggested to carefully evaluate the temperature and cooling conditions of the chosen location and circulate the heat generated back to usage. This will help ensure optimal energy efficiency for the cooling infrastructure in use, while remaining affordable and eco-efficient. 

Source renewable power

Of course, sourcing renewable power by signing PPA contracts with local utilities or generating green electricity by companies themselves is a universal option for AI players, which has already been adopted by many tech giants.

Establish the capability to better measure emissions

In terms of the life cycle emissions coming from the AI hardware, the primary step is to establish an inhouse Life Cycle Analysis (LCA) capability to better assess where the emissions come from to build AI infrastructures. Knowing that the majority of emissions comes from a single or a selection of components, companies can effectively act upon it. 

Set proper policies and incentives

A systematic approach is to integrate environmental and circularity metrics into their internal policies. With corporate policies that favor components with smaller footprints, the scope 3 emissions derived from the capital goods purchased within the value chain will be mitigated. This could also result in a virtuous cycle to encourage players in the whole value chain to develop more carbon-free solutions in the market. 

Closing thoughts

To harness the full potential of AI without  negative impacts on the planet, relevant stakeholders in the industry should be aligned on their definition of the concept. Rather than be vaguely elaborated by technical experts. Transparency is essential to make it actionable. By now, rather than accordant practices around sustainability developed by small and industrial AI players, we see a lot of variation of strategies and lack of data and information provided by companies. AI emissions should be important for tech players, but the actions are neither sufficient nor consistent enough to solve the problem. A shift toward more sustainable AI adoptions necessitates huge investments, proper market mechanisms and readiness, which by now, are yet to come. 

We advocate for the essential role of regulations to intervene and drive transparency in the market. Green requirements for AI should be developed to ensure a minimum sustainability attribute of AI usage. Right incentives should be introduced to the market to encourage companies to go for cleaner AI solutions when making business decisions. Green certifications and resources could reduce the information asymmetry in the market and promote clear guidelines and standards for environmentally friendly AI practices. 

The EU is a pioneer in governing the green AI sector. It has already set a tone in the development of a comprehensive regulatory framework and has provided concrete recommendations for AI players to mitigate their environmental impacts. But with the rapid speed of AI proliferation and the pressing environmental consequences in recent years, we anticipate more to come.

Green AI is not just a technological process to automate computation. It's how we collectively bring together all the brilliance and expertise to solve the world’s challenges: economical, environmental, social and legal challenges. Provided a clearer regulatory framework and more actionable guidelines for all relevant stakeholders in the industry, more solutions around green AI are foreseen to grow rapidly in the future. A more holistic and responsible mindset and joint efforts involved in AI development will produce a ripple effect.  The ultimate goal is to trigger a paradigm shift so that sustainable Artificial Intelligence applications could become the norm for the whole industry.  

References

[1]  The power usage effectiveness (PUE) ratio is a metric of how efficiently a datacenter consumes and uses energy. 

[2] Karen, H. (2019, June 9). Training a single AI model can emit as much carbon as five cars in their lifetimes. (MIT Technology Review)

[3] Vida, R., Emi, B., Brendan, R. (2023, July 11). Data Centers and Data Transmission Networks. (IEA)

[4] Gerrit, B., Luca, B., Anamika, B., Andrea Del, M., Jeffrey, L., Pankaj, S. (2022, September 15).The green IT revolution: A blueprint for CIOs to combat climate change. (Mckinsey Digital)

[5] Garcia-Martin, Eva & Lavesson, Niklas & Grahn, Håkan & Casalicchio, Emiliano & Boeva, Veselka. (2021). Energy-aware very fast decision tree. International Journal of Data Science and Analytics. 11. 1-22. 10.1007/s41060-021-00246-4. 

[6] FORTUM CORPORATION PRESS RELEASE (2022, March 17). Fortum and Microsoft announce world’s largest collab­o­ration to heat homes, services and businesses with sustainable waste heat from new data centre region

[7] 2022 Environmental Sustainability Report. (Microsoft)

[8] Peter, G., Anke, H., Jan Peter, S., Cara-Sophie, S., Cristina, U., Andreas R., K. and Sibylle, B. (2021, May 1). A role of Artificial Intelligence in the European Green Deal. (European Parliament)

Institute for AI & Business Review has just been released!

Enter the domain of innovation, where the most brilliant young intellects come together to unravel the intricacies of the digital revolution.

The Institute for AI & Business team take immense pleasure in introducing the inaugural edition of the Institute for AI & Business magazine, which is a curated compilation of erudite articles composed by students, shedding light on the symbiotic relationship between data and artificial intelligence, and their profound impact on the realms of commerce and society at large.

In this first volume, we invite you to explore a thought-provoking assortment of articles crafted by IDEAS students, where knowledge converges with inspiration, and the future of data takes on greater definition.

To access the magazine please follow this link.

[CURATED CONTENT] This article was published on the Le Monde and is available here (in French - access through paywall).

by Guillaume Chevillon - Professor at ESSEC Business School and Co-Director Institute for AI & Business for Data, Technology & Society

Sep. 15, 2023

Abstract

While the European regulation of digital markets and services gets implemented, the European Parliament has started this summer examining AI regulation. Their approach focuses on assessing the level of risks associated with each algorithm or system. This ex ante regulation is similar to authorizations of new treatments, as granted by the US Federal Drug Agency or comparable entities in other countries. Unfortunately, such an approach ignores dynamic interactions and evolutions in human behavior induced by AI.

Instead, the author proposes to draw inspiration from Central Banks and financial market authorities. He argues for continuously monitoring essential algorithms in real time, while maintaining a medium to long term perspective. This will foster trust and responsible innovation. It can also introduce a democratic oversight of social and environmental targets in AI development.

Founded in 2020 by ESSEC Business School, The Institute for AI and Business for Artificial Intelligence, Data and Society helps organizations navigate and better understand the social, economic, cultural, and ethical impacts of AI and data

metalab@essec.edu

Learn more about the Institute for AI and Business

copyright © 2026 Institute for AI and Business

↓
Résumé de la politique de confidentialité

Ce site utilise des cookies afin que nous puissions vous fournir la meilleure expérience utilisateur possible. Les informations sur les cookies sont stockées dans votre navigateur et remplissent des fonctions telles que vous reconnaître lorsque vous revenez sur notre site Web et aider notre équipe à comprendre les sections du site que vous trouvez les plus intéressantes et utiles.